“We interviewed all the terrorist cells, including an interview with the guy who financed the bombing and has just this November finally been arrested. We talked to the bereaved also. The book was a nonfiction bestseller in Canada. We were under death threat for two years. When I sat down to write ‘The Middleman and other Stories’ as a collection of stories about Diaspora, ‘The Management of Grief’ came out in one sitting. It was a very sad story to write. I would have been on that plane if I hadn't left Canada for the U.S. five years before - that's the plane we used to take to India, the first one after school closing. I lost a friend on that flight.” (Weich interview)
Bharati Mukherjee was influenced to write this story for many reasons. She lived in Canada and saw for herself the way the community looked at her as a minority and discriminated against her for being an Indian, just as Shaila was. She was born in India so she knows the many religious traditions and their very difficult ways of life, just as Shaila was. The tragedy of flight 182 affected Mukherjee and Shailas’ life as well; it was her people, her family, her friends, and her neighbors that lost their lives that horrible day.
Imagery is a very important aspect in a story; it keeps the reader interested at all times by having very vivid details. Mukherjee uses imagery throughout the story. One example is stated in the beginning of the paper. The way the Mukherjee tells about a specific scene makes the readers believe that they are in the story with Shaila. “But one has to argue with a man in uniform. He has large boils on his face. The boils swell and glow with sweat as we argue with him…I know that my parents, elderly and diabetic, must be waiting in a stuffy car in a scorching lot.” (Mukherjee 497)
The use of subtle irony is portrayed as an underlined meaning. The irony is not “point blank,” the author makes it be known by giving the reader small innuendos. In “The Management of Grief” Shaila talks about her and her family moving to Canada to avoid the religious and political problems they were facing, when in fact, they become the victims of the issue. They face even more religious and political problems then before they moved, when they lived in India.
Mukherjee also uses symbols to help the reader show the theme of the story. “I do not know where this voyage I have begun will end. I do not know which direction I will take. I dropped the package on a park bench and started walking.” (Mukherjee 503) The package that she drops on the bench is a symbol for the weight of burdens that she has had on her shoulders. She has an epiphany when she realizes it is time to move on with her life. She hasn’t heard from her lost family in weeks, she decides to let go of the burdens and start over with a new life, after hearing from her family one last time. “Your time has come, go, be brave.” (Mukherjee 503)
There are many critiques about “The Management of Grief.” Hitmanhart408 stated, “I thought that the ‘Management of Grief’ was a pretty boring short story. It had no real appeal to me overall and just seemed to drag on a bit. Sometimes I was really confused when Kusum, her friend, was speaking because I was not sure if it was Kusum or Mrs. Bhave.” (hitmanhart408 1)
I, on the other hand, see her work as being bold, brave, and honest. I disagree with the opinion that this story is boring and drags, I think it was very fascinating and heartfelt; I wanted to just keep reading. I do agree that sometimes it was confusing as to who was talking, mainly with Pam and Kusum.
Some critics insist that Mukherjee is exploiting a fad of postcolonial literature, but many reviewers find her work valuable. Critics often point out the violence in Mukherjee's fiction arising from the clashing of old and new worlds. However, most reviewers do not find Mukherjee's vision as without hope. Mukherjee has been recognized for developing her own style and message that has relevance in American literature. (Mukherjee web) Racism is an issue everywhere, and people face it every day. If more people were to read Mukherjee writings, maybe it would help open people’s eyes and make them realize we are all the same, we are all human.
Bharati Mukherjee uses imagery, irony, and symbolism in “The Management of Grief,” to show the grieving process of individuals during a tragic event; the death of family members, and loved ones. Mukherjee was influenced not only by the personal racism she encountered when first moving to Canada, but also by the Air India Flight 182 explosion, where she lost an old friend, and where she herself may have also been killed if not for moving to Canada 5 years earlier. She is a very vivid writer giving much detail in many of her scenarios making the readers feel like they are actually there, in the story. Mukherjee is also great at using irony in small amounts throughout “The Management of Grief.” It is ironic that Shaila Bhave and her family move to Canada to get away from the religious and racial issues that are all around them in India, yet, when they move to their new home there is more conflict surrounding them than before they moved. Symbols are a little harder to pinpoint in her stories. However, when symbols are found they are heartfelt and deep. The mysterious package that Shaila drops on the park bench at the end of the story is not a literal package. It is a symbol of the weight of burdens that is now lifted off her shoulders when she decides to move on with her life and let go of her past. There are some people who will argue that Mukherjee’s work is boring and jumps around too much. However, most critiques argue that Mukherjee is a bold writer who steps “out-of-the-box” throughout much of her stories. Mukherjee takes all of her thoughts and ideas and puts them together in a brilliant story of how the grieving process happens in different cultural locations, and how deep down inside everyone there is a darkness that makes it impossible not to grieve over loss in their own way.
Work Cited
Allison. Rev. of The middleman and Other Stories, author Bharati Mukherjee.
Goodreades. 10 Oct. 2008. Web. 16 Oct. 2010.
“CSC News. In Depth: Air India.” The Bombing of Air India Flight 182. Toronto: Wolsak,
2006. Cbc.ca.com. 25 Sept. 2006. 14 Oct. 2010.
.
Henderson, Gloria Mason, et al. Literature and Ourselves: A Thematic Introduction for
Readers and Writers. New York: Pearson, 2009. Print.
Hitmanhart408. Rev. of the Management of Grief, author Bharati Mukherjee. Anti
Essays. 27 March 2008. Web. 18 Oct. 2010
“Mukherjee, Bharati - Introduction." Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W.
Hunter. Vol. 115. Gale Cengage, 1999. eNotes.com. 2006. 19 Oct, 2010
<http://www.enotes.com/contemporary-literary-criticism/mukherjee-
bharati>
“Napierkowski, Marie Rose.” Literature of Developing Nations for Students. ED.Vol. 1.
Detroit: Gale, 1998. eNotes.com. January 2006. 26 Sept. 2010.
<>.Weich, Dave. “Bharati
Mukherjee Runs the West Coast Offense.” Powell’s 4 April 2002. Print.
