• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Media Coursework comparison of two media texts

Extracts from this document...


Media Coursework comparison of two media texts I am going to compare two articles about medical testing on animals. One is a newspaper article written by Polly Toynbee and is called 'Sorry, but I think dying people are more important than dumb animals,' this was published in the Guardian. The other is a leaflet with the title 'It's a crying shame' which is design for animal aid. The Guardian news article is for medical testing on animals. The Animal Aid is against medical testing on animals. Both texts are aimed at the general public who are old enough to have an educated opinion. The newspaper article taken from the Guardian is very basic and is set out like a typical newspaper article would be. The image used does not have an effect to the argument because it has no relevance to the topic, it is just a picture of the author Polly Toynbee. However if pictures of animal testing were used in this article I could make readers see how terrible it really is. That is why pictures are not included in this article. ...read more.


The words 'shame' does not represent anger towards the persons who carry out the medical tests, it is a calm word so it makes you sympathise towards the animals. It meets its purpose of making the reader pity the animals. The other two on the reverse of the leaflet serve the same purpose as the main image on the front. The image from the Guardian article does not relate to medical testing on animals because images of them are cruel and would probably make the reader disagree with what Toynbee has to say. Instead there is an image of Polly Toynbee, the author. The expression on her face is a blank one. It shows how she does not care much about the animals. To persuade the reader more perhaps an image of a person in hospital dying could be used because it links in with the title, 'Sorry, but I think dying people are more important than dumb animals.' The two titles used are very different. The Animal Aid leaflet is entitled 'It's a crying shame.' The word 'shame' does not represent anger towards the persons who carry out the medical tests, it is a calm word so it makes you sympathise towards the animals. ...read more.


For example 'Every year around 3 million animals are tormented and killed in the name of scientific research,' tormented is an emotive word to accompany the fact. It emphasizes the point. By using this it is informing and persuading the reader. Toynbee's article's purpose is to persuade readers therefore emotive language is used throughout the article in most of the opinions used. To describe the animal activists she has to use emotive words to emphasize the point. The use of quotations in the Animal Aid leaflet is effective because they are ironic. The use of irony powerfully emphasises the cruelty of science experiments on animals. What is 'acceptable' to scientists is unacceptable to animal rights activists. Quotations used in Toynbee's article just show that someone else is speaking. Using quotations like the Animal Aid leaflet would have been more effective if used in Toynbee's article. By reading these articles it has slightly changed my views. The Animal Aid leaflet has made me more aware of what happens to animals during the experiments however it has not made me take action (e.g. donation.) The most persuasive texts is the Animal Aid leaflet because it informs and persuades using fact and opinion which is made more effective with emotive language, powerful images and ironic quotations. Shaun Meadows ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Animal Farm section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Animal Farm essays

  1. An analysis of Eric Arthur Blairs writing

    It is written for entertainment, but contains harsh and important comments on the Russian revolution and it's leaders, offering a false setting with real people. Part of the story's humor lies in the straightforwardness with which the characters are drawn.

  2. Animal Farm.

    They also work to convince the animals of Napoleon's superior bravery during that battle. So vividly does Squealer describe Napoleon's alleged heroic actions that the animals are almost able to remember them. Four days later, Napoleon convenes all of the animals in the yard.

  1. Animal Farm Media Coursework

    Jones is. Mr Jones is shown dark and unpleasant. The music is very slow. Another way the directors have shown the characterisation of Mr. Jones is to show all the animals expressions as being sad and upset. In the real film, the flashback is explained by the sheepdog and shows the farm how it used to be.

  2. Animal Experimentation

    Through false assumptions on incorrect results on animal studies have caused people to die through their diseases left untreated. One very important example being animal exposure to cigarette smoke. This led researchers to believe smoking did not cause cancer, and because of this warning labels on cigarettes packets were delayed for years.

  1. Animal Rights

    In similar studies on rabbits and guinea pigs, Pasteur isolated the microbe that causes anthrax and then developed a vaccine against the deadly disease. With the information from animal experiments, he proved no only that infectious diseases could be produced by microorganisms but also that immunization could protect against the diseases.

  2. Compare two pieces of text called: 'It's a crying shame' and 'Sorry, but I ...

    The newspaper article is very plain and boring, defiantly aimed at the mature audience. It contains an image of the author, Poly Toynbee, in black and white and the text is Times New Roman size 10. It is set out into 4 columns and starts with a large capital letter.

  1. Animal Testing.

    There are also many uses of animal testing that most of us do not realise. For example, more than one million phone calls are received by poison centres every year and if testing had not been carried out on consumer goods, such as household cleaners, these centres would not know the antidote for that poison.

  2. A Comparison between Orwell's Concerns and methods ofmaking his points with Swift's.

    Orwell's first popular success 'Animal Farm' was published in 1945. It conveys political tyranny and its effects on a society. As the title suggests the novel is set on a farm, detailing the farm animals struggle with the farm's manager to achieve an equitable, sharing and harmonious community.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work