• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Merchant of Venice - is Shylock an evil villain?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Merchant of Venice Coursework SHYLOCK: VILLAIN OR VICTIM? IS SHYLOCK AN EVIL VILLAIN, WHO DESERVES THE HARSH PUNISHMENT DOLED OUT TO HIM, OR IS HE A TRAGIC FIGURE, MORE SINNED AGAINST THAN SINNING, A VICTIM OF THE ENVIROMENT IN WHICH HE LIVED? In Merchant of Venice, Shylock, a Jew, plays the role of a moneylender. Shylock has a daughter called Jessica and wife called Leah who, as we know it, is dead. Shylock is quite a greedy and selfish person and cares more of his ducats and jewels than his daughter. I believe Shylock is more of a villain than a victim because he is a mean, selfish person, but it also a victim in his society, as not many people like him or treat him fairly. In Act 1, Scene 3, we learn of Shylock's first appearance in the play. Shylock comes across as a very confident and pleasant person. I also think Shylock is a good businessman. In this scene, Bassanio is confronting Shylock about a loan of three thousand ducats. Bassanio has borrowed money off Antonio in the past, but now wants to set himself up to try for the hand in marriage of Portia. At the start of the scene, when Antonio enters, we learn of Shylock's hatred for Antonio. Shylock says aside, "How like a fawning publican he looks. ...read more.

Middle

In Act 3, on page 99, Tubal, Shylock's friend, brings some news of Antonio. Shylock's mood is completely turned around. He goes from being sad to very excited at Antonio's misfortune. Shylock starts saying, "What, What, What? I'll luck, I'll luck?" and "I thank God, I thank God. Is it true, Is it true?" But as soon as Tubal mentions his daughter spending some money in Genoa, he doesn't even show sadness for his lost daughter, only his riches. Tubal doesn't show anger like Shylock, towards Antonio, but sympathy. I believe this is because Shylock has had a lifelong feud with Antonio and all he wants is a chance of revenge. I think this side of Shylock makes him a villain. All Shylock is after at this stage, is Antonio's pound of flesh. He doesn't care about his daughter, Jessica, at all. Tubal says, "But Antonio is certainly undone." He does think that Shylock is a bit obsessed by Antonio's bond. One of the other main plots of the play is that of the relationship between Shylock and his daughter. They don't seem to have a very relationship. Most fathers and daughters have a very pleasant bond, unlike Jessica and her father. As we can see in Act 2, Scene 3 on page 59, Jessica very much dislikes her father. ...read more.

Conclusion

Gratiano continues to mock Shylock. At this point I feel sorry for Shylock in a way because al he wants to do is settle for the original bond and leave, but now everyone wants to mock and give Shylock punishment. Because Shylock has tried to kill a Venetian citizen, half of his goods must go to the intended victim and half to the state. Also, only the Duke can spare his life. Showing the mercy that Shylock would not, the Duke spares his life. At Antonio's request, Shylock is allowed to keep half of his wealth, as long as the other half go to Jessica and Lorenzo, and then all of his wealth when he dies. Also, Shylock must become a Christian. Shylock is a broken man. But does Shylock deserve all this harsh punishment? I think he should be punished for what he has done, but I wouldn't punish him as far as the Duke and court did. Because of what Shylock had done, tried to kill Antonio through revenge and spite, I think he should give all of his money to Jessica and Lorenzo, instead of just half of it. But telling him to convert to Christianity is on a whole new level. In Shakespeare's day, it was quite common for a Jew to be converted into a Christian. Nowadays though, nobody can be forced to change their religion. Religion is a big part of today's society and I believe no one should have that taken away from them. Daniel Scotton 11R ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Merchant of Venice section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Merchant of Venice essays

  1. What is your assessment of the presentation of the character and role of Shylock ...

    This seems to be one of the only points, if not the only point in the play, when Shylock seems to have personal feelings and emotions. I think the fact he has lost this priceless item of great sentimental value is a great way of seeing Shylock as a victim,

  2. Merchant of Venice - Comparing and Contrasting Antonio and Shylock

    This has caused Shylock's desire for revenge and hurt. Shakespeare is showing the audience Shylock's obsession with money. This is also the build up to the court scene. The audience can sense tension and curiosity as to who will win. In the lead up to the court date the Duke, 20 merchants and the magnificos have all tried to reason with shylock.

  1. Is Shylock More Sinned Against Than Sinning? Discuss...

    He says that he is being starved in the service of Shylock, 'I am famished in his service' Line 102-103 'You may tell every finger I have with my ribs' Line 105, in saying that he was confused and meant you may tell every rib I have with my fingers, showing he must be very skinny.

  2. How just is the outcome of the trial scene for Shylock in the Merchant ...

    Shylock was extremely obsessive with the law as we see throughout the trial scene, yet his judgement or his code of justice was based on what was written in the bond. In lines 88 to 104, the Duke does plead for mercy from Shylock, realising the certainty that Shylock's actions would lead to a brutal death.

  1. Shylock - Victim or Villain - What is your assessment of the presentation of ...

    Portia gives Shylock many chances to relent, she even says to him "Take thrice thy money; bid me tear the bond" directly asking him to be merciful but Shylock does not relent. Shylock wastes many chances to be merciful, and this does make him a villain, cold-hearted as he earnestly

  2. The merchant of venice, Modern audiences probably find it difficult to accept Shylock as ...

    Another example of Shylock being murderous is in the court scene, when he becomes obsessed with wanting Antonio dead - he even turns down Bassanio's

  1. "Shylock is a two dimensional villain who does not deserve our sympathy" To what ...

    The argument stated above that Shylock is in fact also a victim of racism and is unfairly judged by the Christians also makes him deserving of sympathy. However, although like any other he deserves sympathy for the many misfortunes of his life, the many evil deeds he committed must also

  2. how does one experience sympathy for shakespeare's shylock - in the merchant of venice

    The way Shakespeare equates Christians to Jews and asks whether or not they are 'cooled by the same winds' and 'subject to the same diseases' adds rhetorical eloquence inducing pity. Although Shylock's speech does take a sinister turn the audience still retains compassion acknowledging how shylock's deplorable mental state has been induced by relentless provocation.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work