• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Much ado about nothing - How far do you agree with the feminist contention that the treatment of women in this play reflects deep insecurities in men about the potential threat of the female to undermine patriarchal order?

Extracts from this document...


How far do you agree with the feminist contention that the treatment of women in this play reflects deep insecurities in men about the potential threat of the female to undermine patriarchal order? There are many ways in which the play, 'Much Ado About Nothing', by Shakespeare could be interpreted and read. This ambiguity is present in all of Shakespeare's works yet one interpretation is prominent in 'Much Ado About Nothing' particularly. The feminist contention that the treatment of women in this play reflects deep insecurities in men about the potential threat of the female to undermine patriarchal order, such as that of Messina's society, highlights Shakespeare's tendency to override the freedom of female characters. Of course, it is only in recent years that the play has been read from a feminist viewpoint and the shift of social focus during the years since it was written has also offered a vast range of interests, so much so that throughout the ages Shakespeare has meant different things to different people. However, the passive oppression of women seems to be a common denominator and is present here at its greatest strength in the arranged marriage between Hero and Claudio and her subsequent disgrace. It must be considered whether this is just a misinterpretation of Shakespeare's preference to focus on male characters because there were no female actors at the time when it was written (a prejudice reflected in the play), or the greater impetus that dramatic scenes had when acted out within a patriarchal society. ...read more.


We may admire Beatrice's spirit but the play "continues to endorse a particular view of women's nature", as Terence Hawkes believed. This idea of going against the male 'grain' of the play and abandoning the female nature, dominated by marriage and the prospect of children, draws comparisons to Lady Macbeth in the play, Macbeth. This comparison is also relevant when Beatrice exclaims, "O God that I were a man!" (Act 4:1), when confronted by her own conflicting emotions in her desire for Claudio to be killed. This idea of women becoming 'unsexed' to commit acts of violence or brutality is present in Shakespeare's plays to the extent that it comments on the behaviour of the men. This in itself makes it impossible for any woman to be a man's equal in the society of Messina, where women are incapable of violence due to nature's order, yet men transcend nature such is the dominating force that they have in the play. Whilst never going to the extreme of becoming 'unsexed', Beatrice is reluctant to submit to the predetermined role of women in Messina and this contributes to her reasoning behind the use of irony as a defence mechanism, to prevent herself becoming too close to Benedick. The consciousness of Beatrice of diminished freedom after marriage is never present in Hero. Her willingness to be married is yet another indicator that she has never experienced true freedom. The behaviour of Claudio in the period before his wedding is an example of how women did not feature predominantly in the actions of the men who held high positions in society. ...read more.


Margaret is a minor female character yet she is grossly wronged by Borachio in the deception by Don John to provide visual evidence of Hero becoming intimate with another man. She remains silent throughout Hero's ordeal, even after realising what part she had to play in the proceedings, which is akin to Hero's conduct whilst having her future decided by the men around her. Margaret is reluctant to reveal the truth due to the shame that it would bring on herself, a common jeopardy faced by women. Therefore, it is not just the mistreatment by men that suppresses the threat posed by women but also the reaction of society that females must endure following events instigated by men, ironic in itself. Although both men and women had predetermined positions and roles in society, the feminist contention that the treatment of women reflects deep insecurities in men about the potential threat of the female to undermine patriarchal order is predominantly evident in this play. Beatrice, as a strong-willed woman, holds great influence whilst refusing to be treated badly by any man. Such an example is her persuasion of Benedick to kill Claudio, an action a female could not carry out herself unless she were 'unsexed' such as Lady Macbeth. The deed that Hero is supposed to have perpetrated is a threat to Claudio's reputation and his treatment of her subsequently is the best proof in this play of this feminist contention. The female characters are pushed into less significant roles within the play as a way to 'contain' the threat and feminist readings place emphasis on the idea of structuralism - interpreting the play against the male-orientated grain that it was written in. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Much Ado About Nothing section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Much Ado About Nothing essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    How does Shakespeare challenge the conventional role of women within the patriarchal society of ...

    5 star(s)

    Her greatest challenger is of course, Benedick. It is through this verbal bantering that the audience can see their strengths and gets to hear their opinions, and together they glory in the challenge of their next duel. Beatrice's gratuitous impertinence and unseeming forwardness upsets many people. She comes across as feminist and says at one point that

  2. Compare the characters of Hero and Beatrice, as they are presented by language and ...

    Hero's speech is in the form of an oath. This is important at the time because she is protesting her innocence in the strongest way possible, she is protesting her innocence before God, as religion was very important to the Elizabethan people.

  1. Much Ado About Nothing clearly shows the attitude of the Elizabethans towards women and ...

    Balthasar sang this song to men however none of the men pick up on the theme of unfaithfulness in this song because soon after in the play Hero will be accused of speaking with a man at night. In the play Shakespeare uses a vast range of imagery to get

  2. Discuss the character and role of Beatrice in Much Ado About Nothing. What do ...

    This shows the audience another sub-plot to the play, deception and over-hearing. Without the other's medalling towards the couple, they would not have overcome their differences and admitted they loved each other, showing the importance of intervening. Shakespeare shows the audience that everyone has the capacity to love and to be loved, using Beatrice as an example in this.

  1. "Much Ado About Nothing" in fact has a great deal to say about love ...

    From their first appearance, the audience sees that their relationship, again, is very traditional. Leonato is the respected, commanding father, and Hero, the idealistic, dutiful daughter. Unfortunately, this relationship mirrors Claudio and Hero's relationship. At the climax of the play, when Hero is accused of being immoral, Leonato, like Claudio,

  2. How does Shakespeare dramatically present power and authority in the relationship between men and ...

    Beatrice is the only female character who Shakespeare presents as unconstrained by this restriction. However, the only male character that seems to listen to her is Benedict, which only magnifies the uniqueness of the two characters, both as a couple and as individuals, in that Beatrice is not tamed by male power, and Benedict acknowledges female wisdom.

  1. Act 4 Scene 1 is often considered a key scene in 'Much Ado About ...

    Leonato's behaviour is also striking and outrageous and because of his status in society as a man he chooses to believe Claudio and his friend Don Pedro. Once Leonato finds out what Claudio is speaking of he goes against his daughter and does not believe what she says.

  2. From your reading of "The Taming of the Shrew" and "Much Ado About Nothing" ...

    Nobody questioned the way Petruchio was treating his wife, it was the man's prerogative to treat his wife in the way in which he pleased and he was rarely ever challenged. Another example of how the woman was the property of the man in Elizabethan England is shown in Katherine's words at Bianca's wedding feast.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work