• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Much Ado About Nothing - Which man would you prefer to marry? Benedick or Claudio? Consider the ways in which each is presented before coming to a decision.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Laura McPherson 11.4(7) Shakespeare Coursework - Much Ado About Nothing Which man would you prefer to marry? Benedick or Claudio? Consider the ways in which each is presented before coming to a decision. Benedick and Claudio are the main male characters in the play. They are very contrasting in their action, words and approaches to love, which is shown throughout the play. The first impressions we have of each are derived from their entrance and first words from Act1, Scene 1, when the soldiers have returned from war. Benedick shows he is a witty and somewhat cocky character from even his first line, in which he and Leanato are joking about the fact that Hero is Leanato's daughter. Leanato says 'Her mother hath many times told me so,' Benedick's reply being 'were you in any doubt, sir, that you asked her?' (1:1:79), showing his quick-witted and light-hearted nature. Claudio's first words however, speak of Hero, 'the daughter of signor Leanato' and he makes known to Benedick that he thinks she is a 'modest young lady' (1:2:119-121), meaning she is sweet and he likes her a lot. As the play continues we begin to establish more of the men's characters. ...read more.

Middle

but it is clear to both the other men and the audience that this changed image is due to his new-found love for Beatrice. The fact that he denies he is trying to impress her shows that perhaps he is embarrassed about his feelings though it could just be that he doesn't want the others to know he was eaves dropping on their conversation. Claudio again in this scene shows a romantic and sensitive side, saying 'I hope he be in love,' (3:2:13) which shows his friendship for Benedick, and also in a way could be a way of him expressing his love for Hero, in that he wants Benedick to have the chance to experience the same feelings. However, this calm, sensitive, side is soon brought to a halt when at the end of this scene Claudio is told Hero is being 'disloyal' (3:2:76). Claudio is told that Hero is sleeping with Borachio, one of the men of much lower status than he. He is told by Don John yet still believes there is some truth behind it as he states that if it is true he will 'shame her' 'in the congregation where (he) ...read more.

Conclusion

Benedick's witty, comical, light-hearted approach is attractive and would make him an entertaining partner. Beneath the outward bravado there is a sensitive side to Benedick; he loves deeply and is willing to back up this love with actions. These are important qualities to have in a husband. However, his cocky side can lead him to be antagonistic and argumentative at times and he does not always show his feelings making him sometimes difficult to understand. Claudio is a kind, loving and sensitive romantic. As a husband he would be good at showing affection and would care deeply for his partner, but his sensitivity sometimes turns into over-sensitivity, making him too quick to jump to the wrong conclusion. When hurt or upset he can be thoughtless in the way he acts, as we see in Act 4, Scene 1. This could be a problem in a marriage, though once he realises his faults he is very apologetic and would go to great lengths to show how sorry he is. So, in my opinion both men have advantages and disadvantages. In conclusion I suggest that they would both make good husbands, it just depends on individual preference, and in this play I think both couples are well matched. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Much Ado About Nothing section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

4 star(s)

Response to the question

The answer here is very extensive, and a little too extensive to be considered completely focused on what is asked, as a lot of it waivers from the steer of the question, though much of what is relevant is very ...

Read full review

Response to the question

The answer here is very extensive, and a little too extensive to be considered completely focused on what is asked, as a lot of it waivers from the steer of the question, though much of what is relevant is very good and suggests that, with a little more directional incentive, this candidate could aim for a high A grade. As it stands, this essay is of a high B grade standard. The focus on the question is evident, even if the candidate does stray slightly. They have done well to draw upon numerous points in the source text to inform their answering this question, as this shows a good understanding of the whole text - an imperative requirement for candidates hoping to achieve higher than a low C grade.

Level of analysis

The Level of Analysis, were evident, is very good, The candidate have dug to an appropriate depth with regard to the question and deducing which man - Benedick or Claudio - they would rather marry. I would perhaps have liked to have seen a more evidently personal response, rather than pure analysis as this particularly question does address the feeling of the candidate themselves towards the characters. And in this respect there should be a consistently personal response to all the points made, with links back to the question. Where this candidate lost marks is that they did not actually answer the question explicitly by stating which man they would rather marry even in the conclusion. Even though the question is quite ridiculously worded, it is imperative that the candidate does this.
Where the candidate excels is in the analysis of character that directly constitutes an appropriate appreciation of what makes a good husband, each point made backed up with an excellently-sourced quote from the play. Of course, it would have been far better if the candidate had outlined why the certain character traits they analyse do/do not suit them as a life partner but nonetheless, this is a sound analysis.

Quality of writing

The Quality of Written Communication (QWC) here is extremely good. There is a range of diverse grammatical syntaxes used to vary sentences length and also a very sound knowledge of how to use complex punctuation in order to shape meaning in the answer. There are very few spelling mistakes - none at all that compromise the clarity of the essay. This candidate's QWC is very high indeed.


Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by sydneyhopcroft 13/03/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Much Ado About Nothing essays

  1. Act 4 Scene 1 is often considered a key scene in 'Much Ado About ...

    Don John and maybe Claudio or Leonato because of the way they treat Hero. The role of conflict in the scene changes the mood of the whole play and it becomes a severe and wicked game of deceit and judgement.

  2. Compare and contrast the characters of Benedick and Claudio in

    This shows just how much Benedick finds Beatrice's words to hurt as if her words were like her breath, there wouldn't be anyone around alive in which she could torment. This shows Benedicks sensitive side as he talks a great deal about how painful her words are to him and that her words are like "daggers".

  1. Gossip in "Much Ado About Nothing".

    In Act 1, scene 2, Leonato and Antonio gossip about Don Pedro's feelings towards Hero. Consequently, Leonato is led to believe that Don Pedro intends on asking Hero's hand in marriage. As a result, he informs Hero of his expectations of her in Act 2, Scene 1, lines 48 -

  2. Compare and contrast two characters from 'Much ado about nothing' as presented by Shakespeare.

    Pedro that Benedick once "lent" her his heart "awhile" but "won" her heart "with false dice". She and Benedick obviously have had a relationship in the past - one that they would both like to resume. So far, Beatrice's antagonism to marriage is comparable with Benedicks.

  1. How Beatrice and Benedick's relationship is presented in Shakespeare's comedy 'Much Ado about Nothing?'

    Beatrice and Benedick have similar attitudes towards romantic love. Both characters denounce it as a viable alternative for themselves. Benedick is known to be fickle and inconsistent with women, his inability to make romantic commitments is commented by Beatrice and she uses it against him on several occasions, usually with

  2. For man is a giddy thing and this is my conclusion Comment on Benedicks ...

    In honour of what he has said, Claudio promises to marry Leonato's niece, but is immensely relieved when Hero's face is revealed underneath her wedding veil. Their love is restored, and Claudio is forgiven. Claudio is not the only one with a change of heart during the painful process of Hero's accused infidelity.

  1. Explore the possible meanings of the title 'Much AdoAbout Nothing'.

    in all four plots of Beatrice and Benedick, Hero and Claudio, Don John ruining people's lives, and Hero pretending to be dead. In the Beatrice and Benedick plot it is suggested that maybe they do actually love actually from before the play starts but hide from it until they think that the other loves them too.

  2. What is the Dramatic Significance of Act 2 Scene 1 in 'Much Ado About ...

    ' I pray you dissuade him from her, she is no equal for his birth; you may do the part of an honest man' The prime thing he does is to try to ruin a relationship between Claudio and Hero by persuading Claudio to believe Don Pedro has taken Hero for himself.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work