• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Nora Helmer vs. Miss Julie - the Role of Women being Degraded by Man

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Nora Helmer vs. Miss Julie - the Role of Women being Degraded by Man "A Doll's House" by Henrik Ibsen and "Miss Julie" by August Strindberg are two plays, the first from 1879 and the latter from 1888, which portrays the life and role of women at their time in society, as both have as their main characters two women - Nora Helmer and Miss Julie. Still, the role of women in the two plays is shown to be different. Strindberg, in one hand, conveys in "Miss Julie" that women are inferior in the society, as he pictures them as a less important form of human beings. In the other hand, Ibsen portrays Nora, at a first look, to be a standard innocent wife - showing women to be plain wives, mothers and working at home at the eyes of society. In order to show the need for change, Ibsen illustrates and emphasizes the subordination of women in the social pyramid. The purpose of this essay is to make a comparative analysis in order to understand the lives of these two women and the roles they've taken up in each play. In "A Doll's House", Nora is a housewife married to Torvald Helmer, and she stays at home with her children and managing the household. ...read more.

Middle

Nora believes that she has been acting throughout her life in order to make other people happy, like Torvald and her father, but now she is no longer carrying this further so she tells her husband everything that she feels. "I have been performing tricks for you, Torvald. That's how I've survived. You wanted it like that. You and Papa have done me a great wrong. It's because of you I've made nothing of my life." The play "Miss Julie" consists of three major characters, Miss Julie being the major one. She is the mistress, with Kristin the cook and Jean her valet. Miss Julie has just suffered from a broken engagement, which was caused by the fact that she wanted to make her husband her little puppy. This engagement problem causes her to advance over Jean, on Midsummer Eve. Other factors also may have caused her to take an action over Jean, like the fact that she has her period, her own nature, the sensual dancing and at last the man. Her mother hates men and therefore she raised Julie to dislike them too and this is why Julie becomes so obsessed to take command over men. "Oh, I'd love to see the whole of your sex swimming in a sea of blood just like that. ...read more.

Conclusion

From the beginning of the play "A Doll's House", it is conveyed that Nora is a wife that is completely manipulated by her husband, Torvald. Nevertheless as we get to know her better it is suggested that Nora isn't as innocent and pure as she looked like. Nora realized that she was living in "a doll's house" and therefore everything was coming to an end so she should search for her individuality. Nora realizes that Torvald isn't devoted to her but to the idea that she is manipulated by him. At this point, Nora has enough courage to leave all her life behind and go after a new start. This suggests two different ideas; first that she was strong enough to go against Torvald and the second that she wasn't so strong as she should have been, because instead of staying and fighting for an importance she decided to run from it. Ibsen sticks with the idea that she runs away from Torvald and from this past life as seen in previous quote. Ibsen also conveys through his play the idea to women that they have a subordinate position in society. The title "Miss Julie" values the Miss Julie as the main element of the play while the title "A Doll's House" gives out the idea of a "doll's family" where everything is perfect but there's no real feelings for each other. Word Count: 1.738 ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Henrik Ibsen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

3 star(s)

This is an interesting essay and a very difficult subject to write about as there are so many similarities and differences.
There are some errors of expression which make the writer's meaning unclear at times.
Quotes are appropriate but are sometimes too long and although they highlight comments there needs to be analysis of the language used in the quotes.
There is some social and historical context.
Some mature and insightful comments are made.
*** 3 stars.

Marked by teacher Katie Dixon 10/05/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Henrik Ibsen essays

  1. Analysis of the opening scenes of "A Doll's House."

    The coat and cloak is worn by Nora to protect her from the world outside. The outside world symbolises Nora the way in which everything is metaphorically dead out side whilst she is emotionally dying inside. However as Nora comes into her house she does take her coat off, this

  2. Investigation of Power in Ibsen's 'A Doll's House'

    The initial balance of power lies with Kristine in this renewed relationship, as Nora appears envious of her individuality and freedom in having no commitments to a family. Yet, when Kristine declares 'Nora, you're a babe in arms,' this catalyses the first revelation of Nora's actual power to the audience.

  1. The plays 'Miss Julie', August Strindberg, 1888 and 'A Doll's House', Henrik Ibsen, 1879 ...

    Julie becomes a sick woman, suffering from hysteria and feminine masochism, Julie had the desire to fall and be dominated by a man. Now Julie was totally dependent upon Jean. Jean was superior to Julie in terms of morality as he was a man and she was a degenerate woman.

  2. The context of the play in Ibsen's 'A dolls house'

    A more obvious importance of A Doll's House is the feminist message that rocked the stages of Europe when the play was premiered. Nora's rejection of marriage and motherhood scandalized contemporary audiences. In fact, the first German productions of the play in the 1880s had an altered ending at the request of the producers.

  1. Ibsen's realist play, A Doll's House, is an accurate imitation of life in this ...

    The Christmas tree symbolizes Nora's sense of security and is an emblem of the deceptive values generated in a doll's house. Nora fails to recognize that the tree parallels her mind-set; it grows and changes its meaning as Nora matures from a doll to a woman.

  2. Question: Compare and contrast the characters of Nora and Ms Linde. What do we ...

    Knowing the kind of "pride" men held at that time, Nora knew the devastation such matter will cause and the results of the public finding out Torvald, a men, was saved by a women were horrifyingly unimaginable. Nora herself understands this very well as she speaks of how "terribly hurt

  1. A Doll's House: 5 Elements

    of the play changes and the tree is placed in the corner stripped and candles burnt to their sockets.

  2. Two Men Destroyed by a Secret: A Comparative Study of Oedipus the King and ...

    This is true of his lengthy dialogue with Tiresias, the following argument with Creon, and the encounter with the Shepard at the end of the play. During this dialogue with Tiresias he remarks, "Enough! I won't listen to this sort of talk from you. Damn you! My curse upon you!"

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work