• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Othello': A Tragedy of Deception or a Tragedy of Self-deception? Depicting the downfall and eventual suicide of the honourable central protagonist of the play, Shakespeare

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'Othello': A Tragedy of Deception or a Tragedy of Self-deception? Depicting the downfall and eventual suicide of the honourable central protagonist of the play, Shakespeare unequivocally presents 'Othello' as a tragedy; however the nature of this tragedy is somewhat ambiguous, and thus has caused controversy amongst critics. In order for the audience to believe that the tragedy of 'Othello' is one of mere deception, they are predominantly to be convinced of Iago's opportunistic, foul, manipulative, nature juxtaposed with Othello's righteous nobility and honour. Alternatively, the audience may look beyond the obvious, recognising faults within Othello that consequently lead them to believe that he aids Iago in bringing about his own downfall. They may therefore identify the nature of the play as a tragedy of self-deception on Othello's part. Immediately, Shakespeare imposes Iago's sadistic, ruthless nature on the audience in Act One of the play, as he exhibits the villain's swear to gain revenge against Othello for promoting Cassio above him. Initially, the audience may feel that Iago's bitterness is justified, as he appears to be giving understandable reasons to be irritated. For instance that Othello promoted a man who's 'never set a squadron in the field' above Iago 'of whom his eyes hath seen proof/ At Rhodes, at Cyprus, and on other grounds,/ Christen'd and Heathen'. ...read more.

Middle

For instance in his reply to Othello's query about the reason behind Iago's curiosity, he states 'But for satisfaction of my thought. No further harm'. His repeated repetition of Othello's words, for example 'Think, my Lord?', also proves to be extremely effective in evoking Othello's suspicions. In withholding his thoughts Iago appears to Othello as being loyal to Cassio and this is the quality recognised by Othello; not Iago's incrimination of the dependable Lieutenant. Therefore, Othello does not suspect Iago of foul play. The evidence of the effectiveness of these techniques is conveyed through Othello's words; '...thou echo'st me;/As if there were some monster in thy thought...And when I told thee, he was of my counsel...thou criedst, Indeed?...as if thou then had shut up in thy brain/Some horrible conceit.' This is the first indication that Iago's attempts at manipulating Othello's thoughts have been successful, and prove Shakespeare's success at depicting Iago as a wily, calculating villain, which must be achieved if the play is to be a tragedy of deception. As well as communicating Iago's poisonous nature in this scene, in seeking his sworn vengeance against Othello, Shakespeare displays immense intelligence and cunning in the villainous character, as he is opportunistic and exploits Othello's insecurities and personality flaws. ...read more.

Conclusion

In my opinion, the nature that one believes the tragedy of the play to be depends on whether they see the so-called flaws and insecurities in Othello's nature to be thus, or to be the attributes of a purely noble and honourable general. In Othello's final speech, having realised the error of his ways and the victim he has been to Iago's masterly manipulation and thirst for revenge, the tragic hero states that he is 'one, not easily jealous, but being wrought,/ perplexed in the extreme'. This is a claim that must be carefully considered when stating the nature of the tragedy of 'Othello'. It is my belief that Othello would never have accused Desdemona of being unfaithful had the idea not been planted in his head, due to his genuinely honourable and trusting nature. Hence, I believe that the play is a tragedy of deception of Iago against Othello, though only to a certain degree. I also believe that there is an element of self-deception on Othello's part, as he seems easily convinced by Iago with little evidence, due to his existing insecurities about his marriage. I do not agree that 'Othello' is completely a tragedy of self-deception however; as I don't think that Othello would have deceived himself to such a degree if he was not subjected to Iago's ruthless manipulation, and intent to deceive. ?? ?? ?? ?? Bethany Weston 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Othello section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Othello essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Is Iago The Perfect Villain?

    5 star(s)

    anything as he harbours a wide range of emotions for Othello- love, respect and, ultimately, hatred. This ultimately contributes to him being the perfect villain, he is unrestricted, Shakespeare can take his character anywhere and the audience will never be able to second-guess him.

  2. Is Othello a 'noble hero' brought down by 'a devil of motiveless malignity' or ...

    be his best friend, so as not to make him suspicious that Iago was causing all the trouble for him. Iago is jealous of Othello for many reasons, one being that Othello has higher ranking in the army than him, and also he has a good marriage with Desdemona which Iago does not have himself with Emilia.

  1. Othello Essay. The theme of deception.

    "Go to; farewell. Put money enough in your purse", and as naive as Roderigo is he replies by saying "I'll go sell all my land" allowing Roderigo to think that he is on his side using his vulnerabilities aginst him just to get what he wants.

  2. Othello" is a tragedy and Othello is a tragic hero. Discuss

    By the end of the scene the audience sympathise with Othello and see him as a victim of racist but also blame him for his weaknesses. After Act 3 scene 3 the audience think that Othello is more to blame than Iago. The sympathy for Othello decreases after this scene.

  1. Should we blame Iago for all the events that occur in the play?

    The play opens amidst confusion and darkness, confusion which Iago is at pains to increase. At the council, Othello's charismatic presence, together with the Duke's judicious carefulness, is enough to resolve the rising domestic and military disorder. But by the time we reach Act 5, however, the clear judgement and

  2. Why did the marriage of Othello and Desdemona end in tragedy?

    his image, he is only on the surface, he hides nothing because that is his image, and to only have one side, the military side. Thus Desdemona also seems to him very open, he likes her because he thinks she is like him however when he finds that she might be hiding something from him then he stops loving her.

  1. For a tragedy to be effective, the audience must recognise in the hero, the ...

    However, despite his high standing and moral, trusting nature, Othello has a tragic flaw in his character. It is also in the beginning of the play, that the main villain Iago is introduced and it is revealed in his soliloquy, "The Moor is of an open and free nature that

  2. Explore how Shakespeare examines the themes of jealousy and deception in 'Othello' the play ...

    Iago uses this imagery to manipulate the secret Desdemona kept from her father. In Elizabethan times daughters 'belonged' to their fathers, and then after they are married they belong to their husband. Audiences would have found Desdemona and Othello's secret very shocking.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work