• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Owen & Thomas

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Evacuee, By R.S Thomas & Disabled, By Wilfred Owen In this report I will be comparing and contrasting two poets from two different styles of life and cultural traditions. I will compare differences and similarities of how they deal with casualties of war. The first poet is R.S.Thomas. The poem that i have chosen is called evacuee, it is about a young girl who was born and grew up in a large city maybe London. She is evacuated to the Welsh countryside during the Second World War. She has no parents or family when she leaves and she is accepted into a farming family. She grows up and it shows that she has no plans of returning to the city. This poem is about the healing power of nature and someone who is saved from the disastrous effects of war. The second poet is Wilfred Owen. The poem is called Disabled and it is about a young man who is a football player, an athletic man, he has a girlfriend and he enjoys going out and drinking. He comes out of the pub one evening and he sees a military sign up and he is attracted to the salutes, marches, uniforms, etc. ...read more.

Middle

When an evacuee child is moved out of the city a large amount of them go to good homes where they can live there for free and not have to work and where they would get three meals a day but some evacuees would be moved to bad families that would become slave drivers and force the children that they took in to work on their farms until they dropped down dead. This was not legal at the time but because of the situation not many questions were posted at farming towns or families. There also was a large threat of gas attacks all the time which is why every single house in London had at least two gas masks. Thomas would most likely have grown up around farming families and his family may have even took in an evacuee at one time so it is more likely that he knew more about evacuees then Owen did and vice versa that Owen would have know more about casualties of war from experience then all the knowledge that Thomas would have read. In my opinion to actually experience something like fighting in war is more knowledgeable then reading every book in the world about war. ...read more.

Conclusion

In my opinion the disabled man could not be healed. He could move to the countryside and he might be happier but it is not going to make his legs grow back. The poem The Evacuee is more superior because it shows how anyone can be healed by nature and how anyone can be saved from war. Thomas believes in nature and its powers, he believes that the evacuee girl is just an example of a casualty of war that has been saved. He has shown in his poem that nature and God combined together are unbeatable in the way that they can heal mental problems and maybe not physical ones like the disabled man but they could be made happier because living in a hospital for the rest of his life it would not be healthy for him. However if he had been given the chance to live in the countryside he could see nature for what it is. In my opinion both poems are equally superior in the way that they both describe casualties of war and both in their own way put in all the needed detail. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Comparing poems section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Comparing poems essays

  1. Compare how Wilfred Owen uses the natural world to reinforce the suffering that the ...

    The words 'cold' and 'thrills' are very different to the stanza before because they are more active and descriptive words. Another important aspect of war that is put so mercilessly into Owens poems is death. Once there is absolutely nothing left for the soldiers there is death.

  2. The Charge Of The Light Brigade And Disabled

    Tennyson uses metaphors in the poem "... Into The Jaws Of Death..." to emphasise danger. In this case, the metaphor is also a form of personification. The difference between both poem's use of metaphors is that Wilfred Owen uses them to show pain and loss whilst Alfred Lord Tennason uses them to exaggerate danger.

  1. Balance sheet by John Montague - In Romney Marsh by John Davidson - ...

    The meaning of value is just in terms of financial benefit instead of the value of observing the beautiful surroundings and the general beauty of a place. The poet's feelings are strong and simple and they are that the change that is happening is not for the good, as the

  2. Culture Shock

    and injured; great concern over minor pains and eruptions of the skin; and finally that terrible longing to be back home"( Manz,2003,online). These physical, psychological and emotional effects of culture shock are obvious. Normally, these effects last between five to ten weeks.

  1. Comparing and Contrasting Poems

    To me the feeling this line portrays is of helplessness and maybe of shock, he does not go on to describe the event or tell the reader how he feels about the occurrence but as if he is numb, he says it all in a line.

  2. Compare "Sonnet" and "No second Troy"

    We can see Yeats' opinion of her was very impressive, in my opinion Yeats is telling the reader that her beauty is too good for earth, but after reading the next line you can see that unnatural beauty can come with consequences and be dangerous.

  1. comapring and contrasting pre 1940's poems

    He does not talk down to the person he is talking to-who is likely not to be as high in status as a king-and appears to be telling him the truth. He also talks as his comrades in battle as his 'peers' implying that they were all the same, and that he was not better than any other soldier.

  2. "Welsh Landscape" "Small Window" and "Reservoirs" exhibit R.S Thomas views on Wales and Welshness ...

    " In Wales there arse jewels" Thomas expresses Wales in a good mannor and it emphasises at least one good thing about Wales and also it bring's the poem to life. Also there is some ambiguity and enjambement in the first few lines of the stanza.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work