• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Poem comparision showing importance of identity

Extracts from this document...


Essay comparison: "Love after love" and "This room" compare the way in which the importance of identity is written about in "Love after love" and "This room". In "Love after love" by Derek Walcott and "This room" by Imtiaz Dharker, the poets explore how outs own identity should be celebrated. Walcott portrays this by using positive language such as "elation" and "feast on your life" to show that once you have found your identity, you can celebrate that you have found yourself. Dharker gets her message across by also giving positive images of hands "clapping" which is what people do to celebrate happy occasions. In this case, Dharker could be outside clapping in celebration for finding her own identity. Both poems use metaphors including "the stranger who has loved you" in "Love after love" and "this room is breaking out of itself". The room is personified to become Dharker's mind breaking out and throwing out the nightmares and the dark memories to become who we really want to be. ...read more.


However, she also shows confusion about what to get rid of but wants to get rid of as much as possible to give her brain space and become the person she wants to be. Both poems are similar as they help us find our true identity but one is about how to find ourselves and the other is the celebration of finding ourselves. The imagery of both poems are similar because they both include celebrating about finding our identity but they also show us how to become ourselves. Walcott shows an image of you "greeting yourself" which is a metaphor of you before you were in a relationship "and each will smile at the other's welcome" which shows that you have successfully found who you were before the relationship. Dharker has an image of "from dark corners, chairs are rising up to crash through clouds" which can be seen in two ways. It could be seen as the bad memories and thoughts of the chairs are crashing through the clouds and getting rid of the bad memories also from the dark cloud. ...read more.


The quote "When the improbable arrives" in This room makes the reader think that nothing is impossible and that getting rid of the bad but also good memories is a good thing to do when it comes to finding your identity. However, there is confusion in Dharker's poems where "I've left my feet" and "my hands are outside clapping" which shows that she could have divided herself in the process and she is still metaphorically two people. But it could also be seen as the hands clapping, which shows happiness, being left outside the room and that she has left some of her good memories in the process of getting rid of the bad thoughts. Walcott's poem talks shows the reader how to find your identity after a relationship and the celebration from it whereas Dharker's poem talks about the celebration of finding your identity but it can also come at a price. Both poems show the importance of finding identity and the importance of finding our true identity, in different ways but it made me think about what makes me, me. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Comparing poems section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

3 star(s)

Response to the question

This question asks the candidates to analyse the importance of identity in Imtiaz Dharker's 'This Room' and Derek Walcott's 'Love After Love'. The answer has every indicative quality of a B grade response, but it is cluttered down with poorly-expressed ...

Read full review

Response to the question

This question asks the candidates to analyse the importance of identity in Imtiaz Dharker's 'This Room' and Derek Walcott's 'Love After Love'. The answer has every indicative quality of a B grade response, but it is cluttered down with poorly-expressed analysis and is often repetitive in itself, which give the impression the candidate has run out of things to say. However, there is a pleasantly sufficient focus on the question at hand, with the response addressing many different components of the two poems and how they express the importance of identity.

Level of analysis

There is a balance of similarities and differences that the candidate has picked up on: an imperative requirement for questions asking candidates to compare pieces of literature, though it does feel as though only few are made clearly and are then repeated or interpolated throughout the majority of the rest of the essay, meaning a lot of focus is dedicated to the same points. This can constrict an essay and should be avoided in an exam because it means candidates will spend much time writing Evidence and Explanation for the same Points. However, where this candidates excels is that they have wisely chosen a selection of appropriate quotes from the base texts to illustrate their points. Unlike some candidates who, for the purpose of thinking it will gain extra marks, quote up to two or more lines from a stanza when trying to make a point, this candidate avoids this. They are very concise in the way they select quotes, only opting for small phrases like "Give bread." that are key to providing Evidence their Points.
What compromises this candidates higher marks are that they do not consider the religious connotations of the poems and how religion imposes itself as the entity from which the protagonist breaks away from. This kind of analysis is indicative of the ideal GCSE candidate and the contextual appreciation of poems and their authorial intentions are something that all candidates must comment on.

Quality of writing

The Quality of Written Communication here is acceptable of GCSE standard. The sentence variation is good but there is a limited use of punctuation, with the candidate sticking very safely to the basics of punctuation (full stops, commas, quotation marks, apostrophes). For higher marks, candidates should look to use a variety of punctuation to show their adeptness in using the English language. Also, correct capitalisation of words must be used at all times when referring to the names of the poems - "Love after love" and "This room" are not acceptable. Small things like these aren't going to lower candidates' grades dramatically, but to achieve the highest grades even these need to be tended to.

Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by sydneyhopcroft 16/02/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Comparing poems essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Compare Two Robert Frost Poems, The Road Not Taken & Stopping By Woods On ...

    4 star(s)

    As previously mentioned it implies that it is possible that the poems are talking about a personal experience of Frost; he wrote about walking through autumnal English woods with a friend around the time he wrote 'The Road Not Taken'.

  2. Australian Identity as evident in the poetry of Judith Wright.

    'Australian' traits are not shown only by Wright herself, but by characters in her poems. This is shown in 'South of my Days' with the character of 'old Dan'. In him the uniquely Australian 'laid back' spirit is captured, with him letting Thunderbolt the bushranger run free, giving 'him a wink', warning him of the police just behind.

  1. My Last Duchess and La Belle Dame Sans Merci Comparison

    This displays the underlying power of the love that had blossomed between these two individuals, and how the power of the painting was so influential that up to this point (in the poem), he still feels the attraction of the painting.

  2. The Differences and Similarities Between 'Caged Bird' and 'Still IRise'

    This is again to reach the message across to the reader. In 'Still I Rise' verbs aren't used as strongly although they are used to describe the main treatment coloured people received from the white race. The writer uses the word 'you' as the white race, she asks the whites

  1. Post-colonial literature: "A far cry from Africa" by Derek Walcott.

    "How can I face such slaughter and be cool? / How can I turn from Africa and live?" Walcott points out that individuals such as himself find themselves asked to choose between incompatible cultures, or spread amongst multiple cultures so they cannot lay claim to a singular, unmixed identity.

  2. When cultures meet, seen in "Two Kinds" by Amy Tan and "No Witchcraft for ...

    This shows that the mother smuggles to understand the American culture in her own way. She only understands half and she is going about it all the wrong way. The daughter's relationship to the two cultures is different she is American and this is were she grow up.

  1. In my essay I will be comparing the two poems nothings changed by Tatamkhulu ...

    to carry these people and to protect them, in a away she is expressing that this gift she has been given has know been unveiled, and she is know were she has always wanted to be, she has power and know one can stop her, in the same way know one can eradicate an ocean.

  2. Snakes and Pigeons Poetry comparision

    Lawrence writes like the snake is a guest, "Someone was before me at my water-trough, And I like a second comer, waiting", he personifies the snake almost like a human being. As he has to wait for his water, the snake has a hierarchy over him.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work