• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10

Points of comparison between 'Of Mice and Men' by john Steinbeck and 'The Withered Arm' by Thomas Hardy.

Extracts from this document...


Points of comparison between 'Of Mice and Men' by john Steinbeck and 'The Withered Arm' by Thomas Hardy. Include social and historical context, setting, plot, characters, theme and language. 'The Withered Arm' written by Thomas Hardy and 'Of Mice and Men' written by John Steinbeck have many differences in their social and historical background but similarities can be seen between the two. Of Mice and Men' is set in Soledad, California during America's great depression in the 1930's. Transport was very different then, most people travelled around on foot or by horseback. There were busses but very few of them and if you were a couple of 'bindle stiffs' like George and Lennie you never got a full ride or taken to where you wanted to go. A train were available but for people like George and Lennie hiding in boxcars and riding for free was more common. As it was during the great depression many businesses went bankrupt and many people lost their jobs. This was the reason that many people, including George and Lennie, travelled around so much looking for work. Work was mostly found on farms and ranches but pay was very little. Wages were $50 per month with food and accommodation included. However the accommodation was very basic, they were communal bunkhouses so George and Lennie and anyone else had little privacy. Jobs on the ranch weren't that glamorous either, 'barley bucking' was the most common then there were skinners, stable bucks and swappers. There were few employment rights and no job security because as soon as a job was finished workers were just dropped and had to move on to find other jobs in other places. ...read more.


So I married Curley. Met him out to the Riverside Dance Palace that same night" Curley doesn't seem to pay that much attention to her or care about her, as he doesn't hesitate to go to the 'cat house' in town with all the guys and leave her on her own. In 'The Withered Arm' the incomer in this story is Gertrude. She enters the story as Farmer Lodges new wife. Unlike Lennie and George, Gertrude enters the story at the top of the social scale. However, like George and Lennie she also doesn't receive the friendliest of welcomes and all the villages are very curious about her on her arrival, " 'Well, did you see her?' ". In 'The Withered Arm' there is also an injury but this one is very different to the one in 'Of Mice and Men'. This injury has a strange, paranormal meaning to it as the dream Rhoda had about hitting Gertrude's arm mysteriously comes true when a hand mark appears on her arm and it starts to wither, "She uncovered her left arm, and their outline confronted Rhoda's gaze as the exact original of the limb she had beheld and seized in her dream". In this story there is also an unhappy marriage of Gertrude and Farmer Lodge. At the beginning of the story they seem like a happy couple in love but he only really sees her as is pretty girl to go on his arm, "you must expect to be stared at just at first, my pretty Gertrude". When Gertrude becomes marked and her arm begins to wither, Farmer Lodge begins to loose interest. As Gertrude becomes imperfect the marriage begins to fall apart, "'six years off marriage and only a few months of love' " The female characters in both stories have many differences through how they live but some similarities can be made between the three. ...read more.


" 'We'll take 'um into Soledad an' get 'um fixed up' ", all 'um means is him, and the 'd' is misses off of 'and'. Using the actually dialect and slang makes the story sound more real and to try and give you more of an idea about what each character is like. In 'The Withered Arm' Hardy also uses slang and dialect to bring his characters to life and make them sound more realistic through the way they speak. Nineteenth century 'Wessex' has a very different dialect to 'Of Mice and Men'. " 'He do bring his bride home tomorrow' ", almost doesn't make sense but it just mean that 'he will bring his bride home'. " 'Ah- 'tis all a-scram' ", just means that 'it is all shrivelled up'. The dialect in this story also has completely different word for things like 'chimmer' means bedroom and 'fancied' means imagined. Hardy uses all this language to make his story and characters more believable and to give the effect of the place it's set in. Out of these two stories I preferred 'Of Mice and Men' by john Steinbeck. I think that this story has more of a powerful ending than 'The Withered Arm'. I think that 'Of Mice and Men' is more realistic than 'The Withered Arm' because in 'The Withered Arm' the ending is all tied up neatly and really that's not like real life. Where as in 'Of Mice and Men' it just ends and is left open like it can carry on, just like life really is. "Curley and Carlson looked after them. And Carlson said, 'Now what the hell ya suppose is eatin' them two guys?' ". I think that 'Of Mice and Men' has a more interesting plot that keeps your reading till the end unlike 'The Withered Arm' that I found got a bit boring. By Lorna Peltell 11T1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE John Steinbeck section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE John Steinbeck essays

  1. Loneliness in 'Of Mice and Men'.

    George snapped his fingers sharply, and at the sound Lennie laid the mouse in his hand." (Chapt 1, pg 11) George and Lennie travel together, do everything together, eat together and share everything, but their relationship is only made as strong as it is by one thing-the fear of loneliness, of being left alone.

  2. Loneliness In Of Mice and Men

    makes conversation with the other men that work on the ranch, but Crooks turns towards books, and becomes hostile towards the other men on the ranch who have rejected him before because of his race. They are both fascinated and envious of the friendship shared by Lennie and George and

  1. How does John Steinbeck use George as a symbol of good friendship in ...

    Man's need to produce and chase dreams, man's craving for camaraderie, and man's responsibility to his fellow man are the main themes of the novel. They are distinctly elaborated through numerous characters in the tale. Loneliness "A guy needs somebody--to be near him.

  2. A Comparison of two stories 'of Mice and Mice' And 'The Ostler'.

    Curley's wife asked him "How did you do that?" Curley said he got it caught in a machine out on the meadows. Lennie was in the barn with Curley's wife when he started to pet her hair. He began to get obsessive with her hair and would not let go.

  1. Of Mice and Men

    George discovers Candy eavesdropping outside the door and he re-enters with his old sheepdog. George is initially angered by Candy's nosiness, but warms to the old man when Candy responds: "I ain't interested in nothing you was sayin'. A guy on a ranch don't never listen nor he don't ast no questions" (27).

  2. Of Mice and Men - summary

    whisky and allows a fight between the stable buck and 'Smitty,' one of the Skinners. The boss could be worse: Candy insists he's 'a pretty nice fella' and, after all, he keeps two of the cripples on payroll.

  1. Why I think Candy was added by John Steinbeck to his book

    Crooks, the stable buck was kicked in the back by a horse when he was young limiting him to the amount of work he could do and Candy also being disabled with only one hand limited him to the amount of work he could do too.

  2. Of Mice and Men

    While Lennie debates whether or not to tell George, Curley's wife appears, and soon gets Lennie involved in a conversation with her, although George had warned Lennie never to talk to her. She kindly lets Lennie stroke her hair, but when he won't let go she panics and struggles.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work