• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Review Of two screen adaptations Of 'Great Expectations'.

Extracts from this document...


Louise O'Neill 01/05/07 GCSE Bitesize Review Of two screen adaptations Of 'Great Expectations' For a GCSE Bitesize Magazine David Lean's production of Great Expectations was created in 1946 and was originally written by Charles Dickens in 1860. Later, in 1999, Julian Jarrold directed Tony Merchant's dramatisation of Great Expectations. The openings of both films would appear to be similar, however in their own individual ways each opening is portraying its own powerful images to represent the novel. Camera work, lighting, setting, dialogue and sound effects are all applied to create the startlingly different effects in both adaptations of the novels. David Lean's 1946 adaptation would appear to be more of a horror-based narrative whereas Julian Jarrold's utilises realism. In the period around 1946 horror entertainment was frequently used in films. Examples such as 'House of Dracula' and 'House of Horrors' may have reflected David Lean's approach to his production of the novel. However later he was known for his epic films and ground- breaking cinematography. The openings in both adaptations are very different due to the techniques each director has used. Both of the films openings are set in a churchyard yet travel there in very different ways. ...read more.


Pip is dressed well in a scarf and jacket and looks clean. His hair is blonde and tidy so he doesn't look homeless or unkempt. When Magwitch speaks to him Pip doesn't freeze, this shows Pip's na�ve nature. He answers him politely and talks clearly, answering him fully with no nervousness coming through in his voice. Magwitch however is dressed in dark clothes and many of the camera shots are focused on his chains as he tips Pip upside down. The emphasis on the chains indicates to the audience that he may be dangerous and could be a danger to young Pip. In addition he may have escaped from somewhere as if he were animal to be locked up. After Pip and Magwitch depart, Pip runs home and the same shot is repeated as in the opening of Pip running across the marshes past the gallows, which is a good effect. Jarrold's approach is quite different. The first shot shows Pip's head ducking up from a cornfield with a terrified expression and hawk like eyes. Then edits to a panning shot as Pip runs through the cornfields. The camera is chasing Pip from the view of Magwitch as he sees Pip running from him, which is very effective. ...read more.


For both of the productions I think the films are suitable for children of eight years and upwards with a PG rating as its violence could disturb children with out their parents. In both adaptations the overall message relies upon many stereotypes. One clear example is that a convict would be a bad person not a kind loving man. The strong contrasts made between Magwitch and Pip are created in so many different ways by the use of clothing, lighting, camera shots and dialogue. However all these strong differences between the two characters makes it a little to clich�d to be realistic. Both openings are very effective in creating an atmosphere of fear and mystery. In both films each opening would make a viewer want to watch more, particularly in the 1999 film when you cannot see the face of Magwitch just his chained ankles, which fits the convention of horror and mystery. The 1946 film brings the novel to life magically. The repetitive shots work really well and the contrasted lighting on Pip and Magwitch create a great atmosphere. The 1999 film improvises the book and creates a different storyline, which has the same functions. Both film adaptations whether they are 53 years apart or not, both illustrate similar messages of stereotypes, significant roles and emotions of the two characters. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Great Expectations section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Great Expectations essays

  1. In the ending of the BBC adaptation of Great Expectations, how does the director, ...

    The director is trying to show that Pip is not scared of Manor house and Miss Havisham's old ways, he does this to make the audience see how much braver Pip is now than when he was younger. In this part the first thing we see is Pip jumping off the fence and walking towards the house.

  2. Another technique that is frequently used in the film is the 'close up' type ...

    The first scene in the text is very prolific to the rest of the story as it introduces two of the most important characters in the rest of the play (Pip and Magwitch) but it also has a great affect on the audience.

  1. Comparing the beginningsOf the two films ofGreat Expectations

    The convict says that there is another man with him that is hidden among the bushes. The convict tells pip that if he doesn't do as he is told the other man would creep slowly and softly into his bedroom when Pip is sleeping and tears Pip open.

  2. Great Expectations - review

    All of Magwitch's actions since were to repay Pip: he devoted all of his life to it. Pip's education, money and the fact that he was a gentleman were due to Magwitch. At first is misled to believe that the money was off Miss Havisham, when it was really off Magwitch.

  1. Great Expectations - review

    Being poor as a child, Dickens decided to use money as a theme to show how powerful it can be and to show how it can change people. He makes reference to his life, allowing the reader to see how true and different life can be.

  2. How is tension brought to the screen in David Lean's Great Expectations?

    This contrasts to the convict who looks dirty and wears dirty clothes and has a scary facial expression, this makes the convict seem frightening. The weather added to the rundown look of the graveyard, Pips actions in the graveyard as well as the appearance of the convict sets the scene and makes you know something is going to happen.

  1. Great Expectations - review

    Havisham looks as she has been wearing the same dress since she was stood up on he wedding day. 'You are not afraid of a woman who has never seen the sun since you were born?' At this point Pip is very scared of Miss Havisham as he describes being uncomfortable in her and Estella's company.

  2. How do David Lean and Julian Jarrold use film techniques to influence the viewers ...

    Making the film seem more isolated also adds to the eerie atmosphere. By beginning in the marshes, Lean also shows through this, how Dickens makes the marshes seen symbolic to Pip, demonstrating the solitude of his childhood, which Lean does by increasing the importance of the marshes, as they are the first scenery the viewer sees.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work