• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Romeo and Juliet, the 'star-crossed lovers', are doomed from the start, not by fate, but by their own personalities and by the people that surround them." Discuss

Extracts from this document...


"Romeo and Juliet, the 'star-crossed lovers', are doomed from the start, not by fate, but by their own personalities and by the people that surround them." Discuss Romeo and Juliet loved each other, but they knew that it wouldn't be possible to have a relationship because of their feuding families. Their deaths were tragic, as it was mainly the people around them that made them so unhappy. They were so in love with each other that they took risks to be together, which lead to their unfortunate deaths. Romeo is a Montague. He falls in love with Juliet the moment he sees her at a Capulet ball. Juliet is just under 14 years old, and a Capulet, whose family are bitter enemies of the Montagues. As the prologue explains, "From forth the loins of these two foes A pair of star-crossed lovers take their life". The words "star-crossed lovers" suggest that fate is an important element in the events in the play, but the personalities of those involved, particularly Romeo, play a vital role in the tragedy. I think that Romeo should not have killed Tybalt, as the result of Tybalt's death was Romeo's banishment. He could have left Tybalt to the Prince's justice; he had decreed that if anyone disturbed the peace their "lives shall pay the forfeit". I do think that Romeo can be excused for killing Tybalt though, as Tybalt killed Romeo's best friend, Mercutio, and Romeo was blind in a heat of passion. ...read more.


Tybalt could also be to blame for the tragedy. He is well known for his fighting skills as he is "the Prince of Cats". He has a very fiery temper and is always trying to show off with his 'macho' behaviour, which eventually gets him killed. His view of the Montagues is shown very clearly when he is talking to Benvolio: "What, drawn and talk of peace! I hate the word As I hate hell, all Montagues and thee" Again, at the Capulet ball, when he finds out that Romeo is there, he is angry. He wants to fight Romeo but is luckily stopped by Lord Capulet, who has a surprising change of character, and tells Tybalt that he does not want a fight to break out, so he lets Romeo stay. He humiliates Tybalt, which directly leads to Tybalt's challenge to Romeo, which Mercutio answers for him. I think Tybalt should take some blame in the tragedy because he killed Mercutio, however he might not have done so had not Romeo intervened. I do not feel that Mercutio bears much blame for the tragedy. He is Romeo's best friend. He tries to cheer Romeo up when he is upset about Rosaline. One way of trying to cheer him up was to go to the Capulet ball, as he thought that maybe Romeo could meet someone new and forget about Rosaline. ...read more.


He is upset that it took the death of these two lovers to bring the families together. Shakespeare took the idea of this play from a long poem written by Arthur Brooke, written in 1562. This itself came from an older Italian story. Shakespeare added some scenes and changed the story line slightly to make it more dramatic and more of a tragedy. For example, the poem was based over a period of nine months, but Shakespeare shortened the time span to just 5 days. This makes the play much more interesting to watch on stage. I do not think there is just one person alone that is to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet, but Friar Lawrence and Romeo both play a large part in the tragedy, mainly because of the Friar's poor planning, that simply did not work out as he hoped. Romeo did not receive the letter, so when he heard the bad news from Balthasar about Juliet's death, he believed Juliet was really dead. I don't think that Friar Lawrence should have wedded Romeo and Juliet without thinking about the consequences it could have. I think that fate might have played a small part in the events in the play because it is all very co-incidental that two people met, married and died for each other all in the time span of 5 days, but I think fate didn't play a big role. It was too easy for Romeo to blame fate, when he should have been less impetuous himself. 1 James Taylor 5N ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. Romeo & Juliet were doomed from the start. Discuss.

    Rather, they were married according to the benefits such a match would provide for the two families . If Romeo and Juliet was instead set in modern times, marriage would not have as strong an emphasis. For example,when Paris expresses his interest in wedding Juliet to Capulet.

  2. Shakespeare cleverly masks the true meaning of Romeo and Juliet behind the idea of ...

    throughout the play sets up warnings that this love is no t a good thing. Romeo and Juliet suffer nothing but misery throughout the play and all because of an old family feud. Shakespeare dedicates little time to the marriage, this shows how little importance romance affects the play, Shakespeare

  1. Romeo and Juliet - Who is to blame for the death of the star ...

    Romeo's parents seem caring and loving, but Juliet's parents, especially Lady Capulet are very cold hearted and uncaring, and force Juliet into marrying Paris without seeking her approval. 'She shall be married to this noble earl'. However Lord Capulet is a bullying father who considers Juliet his property and expects to be obeyed.

  2. 'Who is to blame for the death of Romeo and Juliet? Discuss.'

    'Be strong and prosperous in this resolve.' The friar advises Juliet about the poison and soon becomes involved in the scenario. Her parents are also unaware of this situation. He is a holy man and should have respected the Capulet's wishes and yet he ignores that image and want love to blossom in the eyes of Romeo and Juliet.

  1. Romeo and Juliette: Who is to blame for the star-crossed lovers tragic death?

    She refers to sexual encounter constantly and her language is full of sexual connotations: "Go, girl, seek happy nights to happy days". This validation of Juliet's awakening sexual desire can be seen in her impatience for Romeo to arrive in act 3 scene 2: "O, I have bought the mansion

  2. The concept of fate - Romeo and Juliet

    Another line said by Montague, which is "Unless good council may the cause remove" (I, i, 140), also is evidence of Romeo's tragedy. In the first act, Romeo is introduced. His great sadness is shown right away and the theme of love is seen as well.

  1. Romeo and Juliet 'the star-crossed lovers' are doomed from the start, not by fate ...

    here we get the impression that fate is on the couples side. Romeo is suggesting to Juliet that love had sent him to her this is not only fate, but adds to Romeos romance in wooing Juliet. This is an important reference to fate, for Romeo later feels that fate is against him and that he is 'fortunes fool.'

  2. didn't think I would ever fall in love, come to think of it I ...

    Romeo drank his juice in one go and I put my salad carton in the bin and my fork in the sink. "I'm going to change; I'll take you to the guest room so you can change." Romeo put his glass in the sink.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work