• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Romeo & Juliet – Did love or hate win in the end?

Extracts from this document...


Romeo & Juliet - Did love or hate win in the end? Introduction Shakespeare wrote Romeo and Juliet around the 1590s. During much of the twentieth century, critics tended to disparage this play in comparison to the four great tragedies that Shakespeare wrote in (Hamlet, King Lear, Macbeth, and Othello). Romeo and Juliet appears to lack the psychological depth and the structural complexity of Shakespeare's later tragedies. But over the past three decades or so, many scholars have altered this assessment, effectively upgrading its status within Shakespeare. They have done this by discarding comparative evaluation and judging Romeo and Juliet as a work of art in its own right. Viewed from this new perspective, Shakespeare's drama of the "star-crossed" young lovers is seen to be an extraordinary work. The latter include the antithesis between love and hate, the correlative use of a light and dark polarity, and the prominent status accorded to Fortune and its expression in the dreams, omens and forebodings that presage its tragic conclusion. Scene I In a public place of Verona, we first see two servants of the Capulet family armed with swords, ready to fight with any "dog of the house of Montague." They express the enmity toward Montague in vulgar terms. Just then, two servants of the Montague household enter and the two sides begin to fight. The fight ends temporarily when Benvolio, a Montague and a cousin of Romeo's, appears and beats down their swords. Immediately after this, however, a member of the Capulet family, Tybalt, bursts in, and begins to fight with Benvolio. The fight attracts others, including Old Capulet and his wife, Old Montague and his wife, and the Prince of Verona, Escalus. The Prince commands these rebellious subjects to stop breaking the civil peace, complaining that these street battles have erupted on several occasions, and threatening lives of the combatants. Old Montague asks Benvolio about the cause of the argument at hand, but Lady Montague's concern is with their son, Romeo. ...read more.


Now the ''Star-crossed lovers are united and never to be parted. Act III Scene I The play's duel scene takes place in a public place of Verona. Benvolio says that they should lay low, for it is hot and the "Capels" are in the street. Mercutio says that Benvolio only anticipates a brawl because he is by nature a quarrelsome youth. The "Capels" do, in fact, arrive led by Tybalt who tests Mercutio's temper. Romeo appears, and Tybalt challenges him to a duel. But Romeo refuses to fight: even after Tybalt calls him a villain, Romeo wishes him well. Nevertheless, Mercutio is rankled by his friend's "dishonourable, vile submission!" He draws his sword and duels with Tybalt. Romeo intervenes, but this gives Tybalt the chance to stab Mercutio under Romeo's arm. Mercutio is mortally wounded and curses the Capulet and the Montague families with "a plague a' both houses." When Tybalt comes back, Romeo fights with him and Tybalt is slain. Romeo flees from punishment by the Prince, crying out that he is "fortune's fool." Along with Old Montague and Old Capulet, the Prince follows a group of citizens to the site of the mayhem. Benvolio recounts what has occurred. Recognizing that Tybalt was the instigator. The Prince spares Romeo from a death penalty, but banishes him from Verona (and Juliet) on pain of death. Both families in this scene express a lot of hate as the fight takes two victims. After Mercutio is mortally wounded he whispers, ''you shall find me a grave man''. He is saying that tomorrow I'll be dead and long buried. This upsets Romeo and he wants revenge. Before the fight with Tybalt Romeo offers peace. He says, "Good Capulet, which name I tender as dearly as my own". Romeo is saying this because he doesn't want to hurt his new brother in law. This is because Romeo and Juliet are married. ...read more.


Romeo takes Paris' body further into the tomb and lays it alongside the "corpse" of his beloved Juliet. He stands over Juliet's body, saying that not even death can conquer her beauty. He kisses Juliet, takes the apothecary's swiftly acting potion and dies. Just then, Friar Laurence appears: trying to run to the tomb of the Capulets, the good cleric tripped and stumbled over tombstones and arrived too late to save Romeo from his rash suicide. He then enters the tomb just as Juliet wakes from her slumber. Friar Laurence tells Juliet that Romeo is dead. She takes Romeo's dagger from its sheath and stabs herself to death when Friar Laurence is distracted by some incidental noise. The Prince, the Capulets, and the Montagues then enter. Friar Laurence tells the Prince and the others about the failed plan to bring Romeo and Juliet together and of their tragic, mistaken suicides. The Prince chastises the heads of the warring families, declaring that it is their fault that this catastrophe has occurred. Old Montague and Old Capulet join hands; the feud is over, and they agree to construct golden statutes of Romeo and Juliet. When Romeo talks of Juliet he says, "Here lies Juliet, and her beauty makes this vault a feasting presence full of light". Although the tomb is gloomy and depressing, Juliet can still conquer darkness to light the vault. Conclusion At last the two families that have waged war on each other for so long have been brought together by death. It is weird that five people have to die in order for the two families to be friends? Love wins here because Romeo & Juliet are apparently going to spend eternity together and the Capulets and Montagues can finally live together in peace. In a better world maybe they would be known as 'The Capulgues!' The 'Star-crossed lovers are now together if this play were to end with love the victor. However, if you don't believe in life after death then I suppose they wouldn't be together, so hate would win. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. Romeo & Juliet.

    Zefferelli doesn�t use any change of scene in his version of the fight, which dampens the effect and seriousness of Tybalt�s death. Shakespear would have greatly preferred the Luhrman version of this scene I think because it has much more impact on the audience, and is more exiting than the Zefferelli version.

  2. Presentation Of Love & Hate In Romeo & Juliet

    encourages this hunch, hinting through the dialogue between Friar Lawrence and Romeo, which is quickly paced. Again this scene is done very effectively in the movie, as Romeo speaks with such great excitement, clumsily following Friar Lawrence about his cell as he desperately tries to convince him his love for Juliet is genuine.

  1. To what extent do you consider Friar Laurence to be responsible for the tragedy ...

    This is demonstrated throughout the play with various plans he makes. Regardless of his prophetic reservation that "these violent delights have violent ends" he does unite the pair through marriage which is why he still must accept some blame. Additionally, there is no insinuation that the Friar knew that it

  2. Shakespeare Coursework Macbeth and Romeo and Juliet DUNCAN, MERCUTIO AND TYBALT; A COMPARISON ...

    Macbeth then returns with two bloody daggers and says 'I have done the deed', this makes it obvious to the audience that he has killed Duncan. He then acts shocked as he cannot believe he has just killed the King even though he is a great warrior and has killed

  1. didn't think I would ever fall in love, come to think of it I ...

    I assured him "It's all right" I sat next to him and might I add how he smelled mmmmmm cologne I thought he was the cutest boy in the class, and I also thought that we would set it off.

  2. Views of love in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet.

    Romeo seems to realize this, crying out that he is 'Fortune's fool'. He flies to Friar Laurence' cell and bursts out in tears. When the clergyman informs him that the Prince's doom is not death but banishment, Romeo moans about this banishment because it means that he has to leave

  1. Romeo and Juliet - Friar Lawrence is the man who provided help for ...

    (Act 2 sc. 3) Friar Lawrence himself could never get married or be in love because he is a member of the Catholic Church, by helping Romeo to be with person he loves the friar could be trying to give Romeo something that he would never get to experience.

  2. Who is to blame for the tragic death of Romeo and Juliet, The Nurse ...

    The nurse also got too excited at times as she was very close to Juliet and felt as if she was marrying her own daughter. She also encourages Juliet to marry him as she also says that she wants to see her married and happy in her lifetime.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work