Should I Feel Sympathy For Shylock Carstens denied doggiejoy's structuration idea.

Authors Avatar

Should I Feel Sympathy For Shylock Carstens denied doggiejoy's structuration idea.

This question could be answered in many different ways; Shylock is indubitably the most complex character in 'The Merchant of Venice' in my opinion. The name of the play 'The Merchant of Venice' is derived from the character of Antonio, (a merchant from Venice), who many consider to be the lead part in the play; I however do not think that the play has a lead role, but rather there are many large parts including Antonio and Shylock. b1AP Visit coursework dd in dd fo dd for dd more hypothesis dd Do dd not dd redistribute b1AP 

'The Merchant of Venice' is split into four separate parts: the bond between Shylock and Antonio (the pound of flesh), the winning of Portia by Bassanio, the elopement between Jessica and Lorenzo and the rings (the love test). These last two, however, are not exactly large parts of the story. Shylock is only a part of the bond section with references and small appearances in the elopement section. Carstens enveloped doggiejoy's marxism idea.

As I mentioned earlier, Shylock is a complex character, at some points it is difficult to feel any sympathy at all for him, but at other times you cannot help but feel at least a little sorry for him. The main theme of 'The Merchant of Venice' appears to be the prejudice that the Christian religion had on the Jews. The Elizabethan audience would have seen this play as hilarious and that Shylock was undoubtedly a villain, however a modern audience would see it as a play showing how strong prejudice is. People are still unsure whether this was what Shakespeare had intended and that he was vastly ahead of his time.coge ger segegew orge gek inge foge ge!

Many directors have used different interpretations of Shylock; some have seen him as a downright villain and others have seen him as a fairly humane person. Some have seen him with a Hebrew accent, and others with a regular accent. Some directors have seen Shylock dressed as an orthodox Jew, others dressed in regular clothing whilst some others have dressed him in what can only be described as almost rags, to show how low Shylock is. The reason for the strong Jewish clothing and accent is to show how different Shylock is from the others and to make him stand out. Other directors, who dress him like every one else, see him as no different from any other character; these directors are usually the ones who feel sympathy towards Shylock.coca car secacaw orca cak inca foca ca;

An Elizabethan audience would have been appalled by Shylock for two major reasons, one he was a Jew and many Elizabethans had never even seen a Jew but had been brought up to believe that Jews were in league with the devil. The second reason was due to the fact that Shylock charged interest on money lending, an audience back then would have seen that as disgusting and that money lending should be done out of friendship and should therefore not require interest. Even though Shylock was a despicably mean person, I believe the Elizabethans did not despise him because of this. Even if Shylock had been a nice person they would most likely have hated him anyway. I believe if Shakespeare had portrayed Shylock as a Christian then perhaps an Elizabethan audience would have seen him differently. doggiejoy, please do not redistribute this hypothesis. We work very hard to create this website, and we trust our visitors to respect it for the good of other students. Please, do not circulate this hypothesis elsewhere on the internet. Anybody found doing so will be permanently banned.

I believe that Anti-Semitism, racism, religious intolerance and other forms of prejudice are disgraceful. Morally, how is a Jew different to a Christian, or how is a black person different to a white person. All prejudice does is cause separation and only lead to trouble. Hitler's 'third Reich' was based on anti-Semitism and that led to the Holocaust. Even more recent events due to prejudice include the troubles in Zimbabwe and also the terrorist attacks on the world trade centre.codb dbr sedbdbw ordb dbk indb fodb db.

Although my views are against anti-Semitism, I still find it quite difficult to find sympathy for Shylock. Not because he is a Jew, but because he is a downright evil and loathsome man. Perhaps Shylock did not deserve everything he got, but he did deserve to be punished.coaf afr seafafw oraf afk inaf foaf af.

Early on in the play we learn that Shylock is a moneylender, however, we also learn that he is just as prejudice as the Christians. SJTlhghWE from SJTlhghWE coursewrok SJTlhghWE work SJTlhghWE info SJTlhghWE

"I hate him for he is a Christian:"coad adr seadadw orad adk inad foad ad.

From his opening lines in the play we learn the financial role of Shylock, This coursework from www.coursework.info

"Three thousand ducats; well!"cofa far sefafaw orfa fak infa fofa fa.

Another thing we learn about Shylock are his views on the importance of money,codc dcr sedcdcw ordc dck indc fodc dc:

"Antonio is a good man.coga gar segagaw orga gak inga foga ga.

Have you heard any imputation to the contrary?cofb fbr sefbfbw orfb fbk infb fofb fb.

Oh no, no, no, no! My meaning in saying he is good man, is to have you understand me that he is sufficient."cogf gfr segfgfw orgf gfk ingf fogf gf.

Join now!

This shows that Shylock views money as the most important thing there is. Other than that, throughout this scene we learn about the bond between Shylock and Antonio. We understand the reasons and motives for this bond. We learn about the fact that Antonio and Shylock are great rivals, they are both rich and successful in the field of work, one is a strong Christian; the other a strong Jew, what more they both despise how the other runs things. We also learn that they detest each other,coca car secacaw orca cak inca foca ca.

"I am as like to ...

This is a preview of the whole essay