• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Shylock is a two dimensional villain who does not deserve our sympathy" To what degree do you agree with the statement?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Shylock is a two dimensional villain who does not deserve our sympathy" To what degree do you agree with the statement? The above statement makes two main assumptions about Shylock. One is that Shylock is a two-dimensional villain, a man who is a stereotypical, one-sided man with no true motive for his actions. This assumption also implies that Shylock is extremely superficial, an supposition that we strongly disagree. The second assumption is that Shylock does not deserve our sympathy as although he is not superficial, what he has done has outweighed all senses of morality. In this, we agree to a certain extent only. Pertaining to the first assumption, Shylock is not a one-sided, superficial villain but has actually two sides: one of a comic villain that invokes our dislike, and the other as the helpless victim of the Christians. Most of the time, Shakespeare portrays Shylock as cruel and mean, the most striking example being Shylock's reaction after his discovery of Jessica's eloping with an enemy and the theft of his belongings. His seemingly pure hatred of his daughter can be seen from `"I would my daughter were dead at my foot and the jewels in her ear!" Act 3, Scene 1. This portrayal of a Jew for Christians and readers to rightfully ridicule and hate is further emphasized when Shylock laments about his money along with his daughter, as can be seen from `My daughter! O my ducats! O my daughter! Fled with a Christian! O my Christian ducats! Justice! The law! My ducats and my daughter! (II.8.15-17)'. This implies that Shylock views his daughter and his money at equal value, perhaps even preferring his money over his daughter as implied by the first quote. This fuels readers to further hate Shylock for his lack of love for Jessica. Another striking example that portrays Shylock as a typical villain who is cruel is in Act 4, Scene 1, where time and again, Shylock turns down all offers of money for his revenge on Antonio. ...read more.

Middle

Act 4, Scene 1. As can be seen, he had already lost his money and his daughter, but at the end of the court scene, his fortune is given to the Christian with whom his daughter had eloped with, and he also loses his religion, which he values more highly than money, as can be seen when he decided that revenge was more important than reclaiming the ducats from Bassanio. He also loses his dignity, as can be seen from "Down therefore, and beg mercy of the Duke." Act 4, Scene 1. Shylock came into court, expecting to walk away with his shame avenged but ends up losing everything, including his religion and his dignity, and his very life itself, as as Shylock says, a meaningless life is not worth living. This can be seen from, "Nay, take my life and all...You take my life when you do take the means whereby I live." Act 4, Scene 1. However, he is ignored and he loses everything while the `hero' of the story, Bassanio, ends up with riches, a beautiful wife and his enemy dead. His portrayal as the helpless victim who can say nothing more but "I am content." Act 4, Scene 1, in defeat and resignation, causes readers to feel pity for him. Another reason why Shylock is deserving of pity is the fact that he has no friends, whereas Antonio seems to have so many who try to comfort him when he is upset. This can be seen from "No satisfaction, no revenge, nor no ill luck stirring but what lights o' my shoulders, no sighs but o' my breathing, no tears but o' my shedding." Act 3, Scene 1. Yet, Tubal, his `friend', answers with "Yes, other men have ill luck too." Act 3, Scene 1, in a tone that seems almost uncaring. The lack of anybody in the play that seems to care for Shylock is striking, and contrasts with Antonio, as mentioned earlier. The pity felt seems therefore deserving. ...read more.

Conclusion

The other possible explanation would be that Shylock hates Antonio because Antonio is denying Shylock his livelihood. This in itself is also without ground, since Shylock was proven to be rich as can be seen from "Two thousand ducats in that, and other precious, precious jewels." Act 3, Scene 1, and does not actually need the money but only wishes to add to his wealth as he views it as extremely important. Another example to further emphasise Shylock's lack of love and trust for Jessica is "Perhaps I will return immediately. Do as I bid you, shut doors after you." Act 2, Scene 5. Shylock's lack of trust implies that he has spent little time with Jessica and they are not very close. Besides reflecting that Shylock was not a very good father to Jessica, it also seems to imply that Jessica is like a possession that he does not want to lose, much like his diamonds and ducats and worth no more than that. Shylock's view that money is extremely important is also further stressed in "My meaning in saying that he is `a good man' is to have you understand that he is sufficient." Act 1, Scene 3. While Bassanio interprets `a good man', as a person who is kind, generous and follows the Christian faith, Shylock's interpretation is one who has enough money such that if the bond is forfeit, he would earn much in return. This further emphasizes Shylock as a money-loving villain, who views wealth above some of the more important parts of life. Thus, pertaining to the second assumption, while Shylock deserves sympathy as he is a victim of racism and marginalisation, his unfounded and unneeded crimes must also be taken against him, and he does not deserve too much pity. Concluding this essay, we firmly believe that Shylock is a three-dimensional character capable of deep emotions with more than one side to him, and deserves pity as the victim of the marginalisation by the Christians but not too much as he too committed unspoken crimes that the Christians did not commit. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Merchant of Venice section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Merchant of Venice essays

  1. Is Shylock More Sinned Against Than Sinning? Discuss...

    Portia asks what mercy Antonio can have for Shylock, he wishes for all the money he earned out of the bond goes to support Jessica and Lorenzo, and Shylock must carry on going supporting them. It is also said that when Shylock dies all his money and belongings must go

  2. 'Shylock deserves our sympathy, not our hostility.' To what extent do you agree with ...

    He explains his motives for revenge in a rational way, showing how his actions are no different from the Christians'. Look carefully at the language he uses, as well as the insulting and mocking language used by the other two.

  1. The merchant of venice, Modern audiences probably find it difficult to accept Shylock as ...

    Due to this significant change in belief, it would nowadays be viewed as racially prejudice to mock Shylock because of his religion or to even dress him up as a stereotype on stage. Shylock, in this day and age, is seen as more of a victim than a gluttonous villain,

  2. Explore the conflicting responses, which the character of Shylock provokes in the audience. How ...

    The very last line of the Dukes speech highlights this aloofness, when he spits: 'We all expect a gentle answer Jew'. This quote is hugely effective in making the audience sympathetic towards Shylock's cause, as the reference to Shylock's religious beliefs are completely irrelevant to the running of this trial.

  1. Should I Feel Sympathy For Shylock Carstens denied doggiejoy's structuration idea.

    "Antonio is a good man.coga gar segagaw orga gak inga foga ga. Have you heard any imputation to the contrary?cofb fbr sefbfbw orfb fbk infb fofb fb. Oh no, no, no, no! My meaning in saying he is good man, is to have you understand me that he is sufficient."cogf gfr segfgfw orgf gfk ingf fogf gf.

  2. Shakespeares Portrayal of Shylock is Stereotypical and Anti-Semitic. Discuss.

    Also, the words "bleed", "laugh" and "die" are all things that humans experience; Jews are human too. Shakespeare draws Christians in by portraying the villain as a typical Jew but then turns the whole thing around by showing that Shylock is really a victim in all this; it sends out a message that should challenge the Christian's conscience.

  1. The Merchant of Venice: Is Shylock a villain or a victim who deserves our ...

    They had been allocated a district, the Ghetto Nuevo (new iron foundry) where they could run what happened in that certain section of Venice. However, there were drawbacks to this. They had to be locked up in the ghetto at night and on Christian holidays, and were obliged to brick up any windows facing outside of the ghetto.

  2. Why we feel sympathy for Shylock

    Adding to Shylock?s humiliation, he is ordered to become a Christian or face the death penalty? He leaves the court with nothing. I sympathise with Shylock after the court case because he loses everyone he loved and everything that he worked for.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work