• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Some critics argue that the Glass Menagerie is a tragedy. How far do you agree with this comment?

Extracts from this document...


Some critics argue that the Glass Menagerie is a tragedy. How far do you agree with this comment? The Glass Menagerie has, of course, been labelled as many different types of play, for one, a tragedy. At first glance it is clear that audiences today may, indeed, class it as such. However, if, looking at the traditional definition of the classification 'tragedy', one can more easily assess whether or not the Glass Menagerie fits under this title. To do this I will be using the views of Aristotle, the Greek philosopher, who first defined the word 'tragedy' and in his views, a tragedy contained certain, distinctive characteristics. His work was written in between 384 and 222 BC, and his views were taken on by some of the more traditional playwrights, such as William Shakespeare. As I develop through this essay, it will be clear to see how Shakespeare's tragedies indeed fit into Aristotle's definitions. To begin with, in order for a play to be a tragedy, it must involve 'an action that is serious' Aristotle argues. I believe that, in relation to the Glass Menagerie, it is certainly one that William's has used, as the whole situation that the Wingfields find themselves in does appear to be very serious indeed. The world is looming upon World War II, and America has hit the Great Depression. ...read more.


It is an arguable fact that indeed Amanda, once rich and living in the south, is now poverty stricken, but this is similar for all of the families, as the Great Depression was occurring. It is not, therefore, a simple reversal of fortune, as it is occurring everywhere in America at the time. It is also questionable as to whether Tom's fate is reversal of fortune. Before he left his family he has friends, a job, a house, and a family, and upon leaving, lost it all. However, his life was not, in many ways, satisfactory to him in the first place, so I would not consider his outcome to be reversal of fortune either. Aristotle's further analysis that a tragedy should 'involve people of a higher status' does also not really come together in the Glass Menagerie. Aristotle believed that a tragedy should involve Kings and Princes, people who has a lot to loose when their reversal of fortune occurred. In the Glass Menagerie, there is no one with a high social status at all in the play, so I would agree, here that the critics argument does not indeed appear to be correct. It is also stated that a play should be written 'in poetry embellished with every kind of artistic expression' if it is to be a tragedy. This is certainly apparent in many of Shakespeare's plays, which are full of poetic soliloquies and the like, but does this occur in the Glass Menagerie. ...read more.


The last point that Aristotle makes is that there must be a unity of time, place, and action. To begin with, it is clear that time is not united in the play. Aristotle believed a tragedy should take place over one day. This certainly does not occur in the Glass Menagerie, partly because the play takes place over a series of days, but also because it is, as Tom tells us in the opening soliloquy, 'a memory play'. Place, I believe, is united in the play, as it the sequence of events take place in the apartment, and here only. However, it is arguable that place is not really united, as we do not know where the certain characters, mainly Tom, go when they leave the apartment. The last point is that of the unity of action. This, I believe, does occur throughout the play. The whole of Amanda's existence is to find a gentleman caller, through Tom, for her daughter. This is the main point of the play, involving every character, and which, when not accomplished, tears the family apart. Therefore, I would argue that time, place and action of the play are actually fairly united, even though it does not appear this way at first. After examining Aristotle's views I would define the play as tragedy. Although the Glass Menagerie does not consist entirely of his views, the main points are clearly there, as I have discussed, and consequentially agree with the critic's argument. 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Glass Menagerie section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Glass Menagerie essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Discuss the extent to which language creativity can be identified in everyday interaction in ...

    4 star(s)

    Repetition is a part of overall features of language play. Gupta (1994) in Reading C observed that the sociodramatic play in which the children were engaging in collaboratively in dramatic performance (with particular reference to bilingual children). However, there has also been research into sociodramatic play amongst monolingual children.

  2. Badminton - Observation, Analysis and Evaluation of strengths.

    The follow through is a very important part of the drop shot and I carry out this at a much better standard than Owen as he doesn't tend to follow through at all. My recovery is much stronger than that of Owens as he doesn't seem to be bothered about

  1. The Glass menagerie - 'Being a memory play, it is dimly lighted, it is ...

    Menagerie being interpreted by Tom's memory is the unusual use of lighting throughout. The most notable use of lighting is the fact that the play is 'dimly lit'. This appears to be due to the fact that dim lights prevent details from being seen and it is details, rather than significant objects and events, that fade from the memory first.

  2. The importance of theatrical devices in the staging of 'The Glass Menagerie'

    Music is used to emphasise a particular scene which portrays emotional emphasis to suitable passages. 'The Glass Menagerie' tune is probably the lightest, most delicate music in the world, as well as the saddest. One of the play's most unique stylistic features is the use of an onstage screen on which words and images relevant to the action are projected.

  1. Relationships in The Glass Menagerie, by Tennessee Williams.

    As for Jim himself, he never gave "that weird girl from high school" Laura any important significance, never stopped to think too much about her, and he is acting in a rather irresponsible way when they are together, not making very clear his intentions and his feeling for Laura.

  2. Important Symbols and Themes of The Glass Menagerie

    of Laura where ever he went, and he could not shake that memory (Kirszner and Mandell 1854). When he comes back to their apartment it is seen that sometime between when he was last seen and now he has undergone another transition.

  1. Tennessee Williams' main concern is to show that in this world escape is impossible. ...

    Quite selfishly her protection, over Tom, is very compelling. She minimises his freedom, always asking why he has to go out. Tom feels a constraint to stay, but the temptation to repeat his fathers' actions is always a presence. "What right have you got...."

  2. tConsidering the opening two scenes of 'The Glass Menagerie', how effectively does Tennessee Williams ...

    Laura's dream also lies within the past and her memory of Jim. Tom dreams of escape from his mundane life as the breadwinner and father figure whilst still being treated like a child by Amanda and feeling trapped in his job.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work