• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Some critics claim that the casket scenes are 'boring and predicable', Others say that 'Shakespeare has cleverly contrived the casket scenes so that each is different - Consider these opinions then give your own views.

Extracts from this document...


Some critics claim that the casket scenes are 'boring and predicable' Others say that 'Shakespeare has cleverly contrived the casket scenes so that each is different in its variations of form and structure, presentation, exploration of characters and moral values. Consider these opinions then give your own views on the way the casket scenes are presented The casket scene is a set up for Portia to pick her husband to be. This was the way that her father wanted her husband to be picked. The one who chooses the casket with a portrait of Portia in it is the suitor that will marry her. These scenes can be looked at on two different levels. One being boring and predictable and the other that Shakespeare has clever contrived these scenes so that they are all different. It can be seen as boring and predicable firstly because of the order in which the caskets are chosen and who chooses them. The three caskets are gold, silver and lead. The first suitor is the Prince of Morocco and he picks the gold casket because he is very materialistic and he thinks that it is obvious that Portia is worth as much as gold as ...read more.


The Prince of Aragon's speech is self -centered, full of snobbery and deceit for example, "I will not choose what many men desire Because I will not jump with common spirits, And rank me with the barbarous multitudes" But with Bassanio Portia talks a lot with the longest speeches we have herd her say so far. She rambles on, and doesn't make sense which adds to the boredom of these scenes. By Portia only expressing these long meaningless speeches it also gives the casket scenes a sense of variation which is one of the reasons why some critics feel that Shakespeare has cleverly contrived some variations in the casket scenes. In the first two casket scenes Portia was not interested in the princes as soon as they arrived she wanted to get rid of them also in the first two casket scenes she makes a comment when they leave after choosing the wrong casket for the Prince of Morocco she says "a gentle riddance" and for the Prince of Aragon she comments "Thus hath the candle singed the moth. O, these deliberate fools! ...read more.


Bassanio's character becomes a bit muddled because of the contradictions that he says, and we cannot workout weather he is materialistic or not. But we certainly see how smart Bassanio is through his long speeches and his realisation of the appearances being deceptive. Through moral values each scene is varied. In act 2 Scene & with the Prince of Morocco, his moral value appears to be that he picked the gold casket was because of the idea that everything he wants has to be the best of the best. Like the way he praises Portia "mortal breathing saint" etc. The Prince of Aragon's choice of the silver casket was also led by his moral values he didn't want to choose the lead casket because he felt that it was lower than him. He also dismissed the gold casket because he didn't socially want to be like everyone else and desire what other men desire. I think that the casket scenes are more boring and predictable than cleverly contrived because on reading the scenes I felt that it was repetitive in the way that they choose the caskets and singled them out and not cleverly contrived as some critics suggest. ?? ?? ?? ?? 23/3/04 Christina Murphy ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Merchant of Venice section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Merchant of Venice essays

  1. The play "The Merchant of Venice" is described as Romantic Comedy. One aspect of ...

    type seating arrangement for a fuller view of the court room scene for every one. The trial scene does not need to be changed so the curtain is not needed. The Set: to make it an informal court room scene where I would be highlighting the speeches I have chosen

  2. "All that glistens in not gold" Explore the theme of deception in the Merchant ...

    Again, this is another deception as later in the play Shylock wants full revenge by taking his pounds of flesh from Antonio. These are two deceptions played on Antonio by Shylock. An Elizabethan audience might expect nothing less of a Jew.

  1. "All that glistens is not gold" Explore the theme of deception in the Merchant ...

    Lorenzo doesn't care about the consequences to Shylock as Shylock is a Jew and Lorenzo doesn't respect him because of this. He describes Shylock as "A faithless Jew". Jessia doesn't respect her father either and dislikes being a Jew. Jessica tells the audience how she is "ashamed to be my

  2. Feelings and opinions concerning different characters from the play 'The Merchant of Venice'.

    Jessica has done and helps to bias the audience against Shylock and towards Jessica. In Scene IV Portia leaves Lorenzo and Jessica in charge of her house in Belmont. As we recognise Portia as wise and clever, this strengthens our belief in Jessica.

  1. "Portia is a mixture of both attractive and less attractive qualities." Explain.

    She is a mixture of good and bad in this instance, which can confuse you a little as to what her motives for being so mean are. Maybe she is just racist against Jews, or maybe she is just trying to fool her husband into thinking she is a good

  2. Shakespeare reveals prejudice of a character with dark complexion with the very first line ...

    "Yea, mock the lion when he roars for prey To win thee, lady". The prince tries to act courageous and tries to influence Portia by his intentions. The Prince of Arragon didn't try to boast about himself but agreed to try his luck at the caskets without further ado.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work