• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Case of the Stolen Bacillus by H.G.Wells and the Half Pair by Bertrum ChandlerTask Discuss and comment upon the similarities and differences between these two stories from the science fiction genre.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

June 2001 South Wolds School - Keyworth Harriet Farish Number 9 English Crossover Piece - English and English Literature Sources The Case of the Stolen Bacillus by H.G.Wells and the Half Pair by Bertrum Chandler Task Discuss and comment upon the similarities and differences between these two stories from the science fiction genre. I have been asked to read two stories from the science fiction genre and discuss and comment on the similarities and differences. The two stories that I have read are; The Case of the Stolen Bacillus by H.G.Wells and The Half Pair by Bertrum Chandler. Both of these stories are of the same genre, but science fiction is difficult to define. In order for me to complete this essay, and compare the two stories to their full extent, I feel that I must comprehend what 'science fiction' means and what makes a good science fiction story. Different writers have their own definitions. I have chosen two, which I believe to express simple but different views. Ray Bradbury's definition states; "Science fiction is really sociological studies of the future, things that the writer believes are going to happen by putting two and two together." Whereas Bruce H. Franklin said; "In fact, one good working definition of science fiction may be the literature which, growing with science and technology, evaluates it and relates it meaningfully to the rest of human existence." Both of these definitions are comprehensive and frequently used, although, we have to recognise that they represent the writer's own opinions and are therefore subjective. Although the definitions vary, and are influenced from different sources, they could prove useful in considering the likeness of the stories to the definitions and provide a good framework for assessing them. Studying definitions is not the only way to classify the stories as being 'good science fiction'. There are main elements which all 'good' science fiction stories contain that fit into the science fiction genre. ...read more.

Middle

This is shown in the two stories by the way the writers express themselves and include references to daily life i.e. the references to nautical terms in Half Pair and references to class in Stolen Bacillus. During the 1950's there was seen to be more freedom within society, which was less inhibited by the class structure that had nearly been abolished. This is one of the biggest differences between the two stories backgrounds, however there are similarities. Although the class system was comparatively non-existent at the time of Half Pair's writing there are still small references to the belief that men were more prominent than women in society. This is evident in Half Pair by the way the wife is stereotypically portrayed as a housewife. An example occurs as she makes dinner for her husband. Bertrum Chandler has also created some humour in regards to the roles of men and women in society. Both the husband a wife have a conversation which makes light of the small belief that men had a greater position within life, but it also shows how women had gained a lot more respect in society and were not as dominated by their husbands. This is shown in a particular conversation between the husband and wife, where the wife says, ' Some women are fools enough to trust their husbands. They're the ones who haven't learned the hard way, the same way I did.' The husband replies, 'Some men are fools enough to kid themselves that their wives have an elementary knowledge of pluming.' The writer's backgrounds are totally different, and consequently, as I have shown, the stories differ greatly as a result. Another aspect of the stories which is affected due to the writers backgrounds, are the plots. Although from the same genre the plots differ extensively. The Case of the Stolen Bacillus's main plot involves an amateur bacteriologist who receives a visit from an undercover anarchist in Victorian London. ...read more.

Conclusion

As I have said before, Minnie is put across as being a typical Victorian housewife, very trustworthy, proper and correct. She abides completely by her husband and is very loyal to him as well as to the rules of the time. This part of Victorian society is shown by Wells when Minnie is keen to make sure that her husband does not leave the house without his hat and coat, as it was seen to be disrespectful in these times. It is shown using dialogue, by Wells when the wife is shocked about the fact that her husband has left not properly dressed and she says, 'But running around London - in the height of the season, too - in his socks!' Included in the plot of Stolen Bacillus are other minor characters which all have their significances in some way even though they do not have a large part to play. The cab drivers are an example of this. As I have said earlier Wells stereotypes them and portrays them as lower class, using dialogue to help illustrate this. I have also noticed that Wells does not name the bacteriologist or the anarchist, he just labels them or describes them, which is probably done to emphasises their characters. The structure regarding the characters in the Half Pair differs in comparison with The Stolen Bacillus as The Half Pair only contains two characters. These prominent characters however, do have similarities between the main characters in The Stolen Bacillus. Similarly to The Stolen Bacillus, in The Half Pair there is a husband and wife as main characters. In The Half Pair the couple remains nameless, similarly to the Anarchist and the bacteriologist in The Stolen Bacillus, the only prominent character to be given a name in either story was Minnie, the bacteriologists wife. The relationships between the two couples in both stories are similar, however they also differ because of the different time of writing. As I have said earlier, The Stolen Bacillus represents a Victorian relationship between Minnie and her husband, which is rife with the idea of male dominance. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE H.G. Wells section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE H.G. Wells essays

  1. This essay will consider the similarities and differences between the techniques and devices used ...

    In `The Red Room' the reader is also being guided through the story by the central character, because his view is that ghosts do not exist. The reader is encouraged to share in his beliefs, as what is described in the story and the events which follow are all seen through his eyes.

  2. Discuss The Elements Of 'The Time Machine ' By H G Wells. What are ...

    superior in both technoligly and in interlect, but I'm sure wells has a reason for this. In conclution I think wells has whit and well strrucherd novel. He contiusly uses strong imagery, metfors ans simley. He has a geat number of contasting word 'light' and 'darkness' and 'night' and 'day' to convay they extreme contast of his own fellings.

  1. The Time Machine and the Sound of Thunder are both science fiction stories. Their ...

    out that mankind has split up to become two totally opposite creatures that the Time Traveller calls the Elio and Morlocks. The Morlocks have become a cannibal race and eats the other half of mankind called the Elio. As the Time Traveller is finding out how life is in the

  2. knowing and not knowing humour and iriony in H.G Wells' short stories

    He also feels more safe with the candles, he puts them in every corner of the room to shield himself from the misleading darkness. The most humorous part of the story is when he fundamentally gives up his sanity - he starts seeing things that are not there and noises that no one else can hear.

  1. How do the H G Wells Stories The Red Room, The Cone and the ...

    The old woman states, `and eight and twenty years you have lived and never seen the likes of this house.' This illustrates that the house is historic and it could also be decaying. At the beginning of the story, the character of the narrator is not open minded and sure of himself.

  2. Discuss the Influence of Gothic Fiction on two Works - Emphasise the Features which ...

    He feels safe when he is with the old men and woman, even though they themselves make him uncomfortable. He even tries to comfort himself by thinking of them instead of anything supernatural ~). It is as if lust the thought of being with others will protect him in some way.

  1. "What are the differences in the size and shapes of the sphere of influence ...

    The variety of shops is also much better due to the shopping mall that is on Calverly Road - Royal Victoria Place. 2. I expect that Royal Tunbridge Wells is a lot better for shopping as it has a wider range and choice due to Royal Victoria Place and the other shops specialist shops on Calverly Road.

  2. Knowing and not knowing, humour and irony in the short stories of H.G. Wells

    The cholera is aboard!' Meanwhile during the whole palaver Minnie doesn't know a thing. At the start of The Story of the Inexperienced Ghost we know that Clayton is always telling stories that are all lies so we know that this one is probably fake as well.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work