• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  6. 6
    6
  7. 7
    7
  8. 8
    8
  9. 9
    9
  10. 10
    10
  11. 11
    11

the educational theory of Professor Higgins and Governor Phillip

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Nicola Barratt 16th December, 2004. GCSE English Literature Post-1914 Drama G.B. Shaw (1856 - 1950) PYGMALION (1916) Timberlake Wertenbaker (1951 - ) OUR COUNTRY'S GOOD (1988) 'Fine language, sentiment': the educational theory of Professor Higgins and Governor Phillip In this essay, I would like to examine the respective educational theories of the two men: Professor Higgins Pygmalion and Governor Phillip Our Country's Good. Both men believe in the process of amelioration: that is, both believe in the redemptive power of 'fine language'; if people speak fine language, they will find themselves morally or socially improved. Both believe that people, who are born into the lower classes, are not doomed to live their lives at a disadvantage. Moreover, if given the opportunity to use the 'divine gift of articulate speech', then they can achieve a degree of upward mobility. I should like to look first at the relationship between Professor Higgins and Eliza in Pygmalion, which is set in an era of social mobility and depends for its effect upon the English class system. In particular, I would like to examine the idea that a person's position in society can be accurately measured by her speech-style. Henry Higgins, a professor of linguistics, believes that Eliza Doolittle ('draggletailed guttersnipe') can be transformed into a 'duchess.' Higgins is a scientist conducting an experiment. He wants Eliza to talk genteelly. His precise ambition is to 'pass that girl off as a duchess at an ambassador's garden party'. Higgins is extremely selfish ('What does it matter what becomes of you') and professes not to be interested in Eliza's personal progress at all, in fact only teaching her to win a bet between Pickering and himself: THE NOTE-TAKER (HIGGINS): Well, sir, in three months I could pass that girl off as a duchess at an ambassador's garden party. PICKERING: I'll say youre the greatest teacher alive if you make that good. ...read more.

Middle

The only play they have is George Farquhar's The Recruiting Officer (1706), which is a Restoration comedy. In Act One Scene Five, Phillip asks Second Lieutenant Ralph Clark to organise the play. He doesn't really want to do it and to begin with is not very enthusiastic, but he is hopeful of promotion and so does it to please the Governor. He hears that a convict called Mary Brenham can read and write, so he roots her out. She is with her friend, Dabby Bryant, when he comes to talk to her. When he asks her questions to discover if she can read and write, Dabby interrupts and tells him: 'She used to read to us on the ship. We loved it.' This disclosure reveals Mary's human potential; it reveals also that some convicts are sensitive to those who have been desensitised through brutal treatment. When Dabby says, 'Mary wants to be in your play', she is telling us that Mary wants something to look forward to, something to anticipate. When Ralph Clark starts reading some lines with her from the play, she reads the line: 'Whilst there is life, there is hope' This is a perfect example of a syntactically balanced 'sentiment'. This proverbial saying comments exquisitely on their situation within the colony. In Act One Scene Six, 'The Authorities Discuss the Merits of the Theatre', Major Robbie Ross shows his contempt for the play ('we'll all be struck with stricturing starvation - and you - you - a play!') Ross is a reactionary figure; he adopts a hostile manner towards the idea that the convicts may be capable of 'sentiment' and rehabilitation. He believes that they are incorrigible, beyond redemption; he has no confidence in the redemptive power of Farquhar's language. Ross wastes no opportunity to vituperate against the convicts ('vice ridden vermin!'), especially the women, whom he considers lower forms of life ('Filthy, thieving, lying whores'). ...read more.

Conclusion

In Act Two Scene Seven, 'The Meaning of Plays', John Wisehammer kisses Mary Brenham. Ralph Clark is angry and jealous because a convict has access to Mary. Wisehammer defends his kiss by passing literary judgement: ' It's right for the character of Brazen'. The play has educated him. Just as when Mary says: 'I like playing Silvia. She's bold, she breaks the rules out of love for her captain and she is not ashamed'. She sees a role model in Silvia, just as Arscott sees an escape from himself in playing Sergeant Kite: 'When I speak Kite's lines, I don't hate anymore'. In the same scene, when Dabby asks 'Why can't I play Kite?' we see her great expectations. She wants to better herself, just like Eliza, in her role as an actress, let alone as a human being. She also examines the role of Melinda ('All she does is marry Sideway, that's not interesting') and in doing so persuades Dabby to look at her own identity. She has decided that she does not like Melinda because she is content to marry a man and sacrifice her identity to become a trophy wife. In Act Two Scene Ten, 'The Question of Liz', we hear Phillip state that 'the play seems to be having a miraculous effect'. He wants Liz to speak up for herself and for 'the good of the colony' against the allegations that she stole food from the colony stores. When she finally speaks, she becomes involved in the process of justice. It is also in this scene that Liz utters an equivalent to Eliza's 'How do you do?' in Pygmalion: 'Your Excellency, I will endeavour to speak Mr Farquhar's lines with the elegance and clarity their own worth commands'. Now we can hear that the process of amelioration is complete and that the educational theory of Governor Phillip has been proved in practice. I believe that this is where Higgins went wrong, for central to any educational theory is the giving of 'confidence' and 'encouragement' which the Professor, unlike the Governor, makes no effort to give. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Miscellaneous essays

  1. An Analysis of Old Major's Speech: Animal Farm

    "Man is the only creature who consumes without producing", Old Major states. Old Major then describes how man does this with inclusive language, statistical data and rhetorical questions. With a common enemy, whom all the animals now are enraged with after hearing so clearly all the injustices committed by them,

  2. Dulce est Decorum est and For the Fallen

    In 'Dulce et Decorum Est' the dying soldier's face is 'like a devil's sick of sin' with 'writhing eyes'. The phrase implies that the soldiers committed the greatest sins, most probably killing, and this altered the way they viewed life forever.

  1. The role of the Inspector in 'An Inspector Calls.'

    The Inspector does get justice for Eva in a way because he makes the family feel worse than any real Inspector could. The Inspector called himself 'Goole,' which could be a pun on the word 'ghoul' which is defined as 'a person interested in morbid or disgusting things.'

  2. Great expectations

    Innocence and trust is a hazard of childhood. Pip was both innocent and trusting. In the Victorian times, criminals were the lowest members of the working class and often referred to as the 'criminal classes'. People that were higher than those in the criminal class thought of them as having

  1. Adventure begins here.

    I could almost hear Billy Black's screams in my head, his accelerated heart beat. I could see the fear in his eyes. I shook my head making the weird assumptions and visions disappear. All I needed now was to look guilty going home to mum.

  2. conflicting perspectives joan of arc and julius caesar

    "And Brutus is an honorable man" (L79) Repetition is used throughout the speech to question, challenge and create uncertainty regarding Caesar the megalomaniac. Harming the reputation of Brutus encourages skepticism among the audience as to whether he is a credible person to except the reasons and motives for slaying Caesar.

  1. one girl one dream

    I asked him "what's wrong, what did you see?" There was no reply, I asked again, but still no reply. Then I also stepped back for a better look. "Ahhhhh" I screamed, the builder had a arrow gauging sharply into his back, I tried to call for help but I was grabbed and within seconds was deep in the

  2. the crucible in earley 1950

    All the characters involved in the witch trials have many things to lose. For most of them it's either their lives or their reputation. The Proctors are in a desperate situation, which is becoming more and more hopeless. The audience empathise for them because they never seem to be in power in court.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work