• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Lack of Change in the Detective Genre.

Extracts from this document...


The Lack of Change in the Detective Genre Sherlock Holmes is the most famous detective in literary history. He was the first detective to solve cases by the use of deduction, not because the criminal made a mistake. This genre gained favour with many authors of the time, and spawned many other detectives, like Arsene Lupin and Hercule Poirot. How do these detectives compare to Sherlock Holmes? I will try and glean the similarities between short accounts of Sherlock Holmes and Hercule Poirot, a Belgian immigrant who worked in the Belgian police force as a detective. I have noticed that the basic elements are present in both sets of accounts, which is suggestive, meaning that the genre hadn't evolved much over a period of 30 years. In fact, Agatha Christie, the author of the Hercule Poirot stories, stated in her autobiography that she had set out to emulate the content and writing style of the Sherlock Holmes accounts, written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. I will try and find these similarities, and also illustrate the lack of change that had occurred in the detective genre between the late 1900s and the 1930s. The most obvious point of comparison is the many similarities between the two main characters, the detectives themselves, Sherlock Holmes and Hercule Poirot. The fact that both are most "colossally vain" and "self-obsessed", in Dr. ...read more.


He scoffs at all the others who "jump about, measuring footprints, interview people...". Holmes is very similar, in the respect that he has habits and methods that aren't orthodox, in every sense of the word. For example, he plays the violin "extremely well", takes drugs: "...cocaine sniffing was one of his vices", and is a decorated pugilist, who bends pokers that have been bent into a U-shape, back to their original form, to use one example. He also keeps his cigars in the coal-scuttle, his tobacco in the tow end of a Persian slipper, and "his correspondence transfixed by a jackknife in the very centre of his mantelpiece". I think that the idea to make both detectives different from their conventional stereotypes was taken from Sir Arthur Conan Doyle by Agatha Christie. This would make the detective memorable to the reader, as the 'curious mannerisms' would make the stories stick in the memory. One such aspect of the two detectives is their superior powers of observation. Both sets of stories contain two very similar examples. In both cases, the detective manages to follow the thinking of their assistants though their actions and recent doings. For example, Holmes can follow that Watson will not want to invest in New Zealand bonds, as he has been playing billiards as he has chalk on his sleeve, and he only plays billiards with one person, and that person has recently invested in NZ bonds, and wants others to join him, but Watson hasn't asked for his checkbook which is locked in Holmes' drawer. ...read more.


Hastings also says that Poirot doesn't "give credit where it's due". They also think that vanity is a quality they do not possess, but through their accounts, show that they do. Both think themselves as equal to their great friends, but in a sense fall flat on their faces as, in Hastings' case, he is not ordered and methodical, and in Watson's, because he doesn't possess the powers of deduction necessary. There are still other clues to suggest that the detective genre hasn't changed much in 30 years. One such clue is the police detective, Lestrade in Holmes' accounts, and Japp in Poirot's. These two detectives are very similar to each other. Both are very methodical, following every lead, and "measur(ing) footprints and mak(ing) observations". They try to maintain a friendly relationship with the detectives and their assistants, sometimes enlisting the help of the assistants to gently poke fun at the detectives, using sarcasm and word-play to get a measure of revenge for the fact that the detectives are much superior to them, and have increased levels of deduction and observation. Both are, at various times, accused of not being logical, and not giving thought before giving chase. I believe that after Sir Arthur Conan Doyle invented Holmes, other writers fell over themselves to create a successful detective based on the legendary pipe-smoking sleuth. Hercule Poirot was, I believe, modeled on Sherlock Holmes. These similarities between the two accounts show that the detective genre hasn't changed over the years. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle essays

  1. Analysation of the detective genre, Sherlock Holmes

    Watson, on the other hand, is Holmes' right hand man, his intelligence is maybe not as decisive as Holmes's, but any traditional detective story should not be without its less observant side-kick. In the stories Watson acts as an audience for Holmes and a narrator and reporter for the readers.

  2. Question: What features of Arthur Cannon Doyle's a story make them typical of the ...

    He 'took the lady's un-gloved hand and examined it with as close an attention and as little sentiment as a scientist would show to a specimen' From simply looking at her hand Holmes is able to conclude that Miss Smith 'is a musician'.

  1. Explore the detective story genre with particular reference to Conan Doyle's stories.Show it's social, ...

    Conan Doyle adopted Poe's formulae, cut his elaborate introductions, restating them in conversational exchanges between his two chief characters, and emphasised Poe's least realistic feature: the 'deduction' of astonishing conclusions from trifling clues. My essay is going to explore Doyle's narrative methods in 3 stories: * 'The Five Orange Pips'.

  2. Agatha Christie -

    That told me had knowledge about things that was above average. Agatha Christie's "Death on the Nile" started off in England. Linnet Ridgeway a young, beautiful, and rich girl had just bought an estate there, after she had just inherited a great fortune from her father Melhuish Ridgeway.

  1. Relevant history & Business environment.

    Since September 11th the subsequent downturn in the global economy has been further cause for concern. In response to these factors, many hotel companies have frozen or reduced expenditure programs and cut back on investment. There has also been competition in the leisure market, with hotels seeking to compensate for the fall in corporate expenditure by raising consumer revenue.

  2. The Lack of Evolution in the Detective Genre.

    This is an interesting contrast in the depiction of the two detectives' vanity. Doyle, through Watson's eyes, shows his idol, Holmes to be infallible, but shows Holmes' vanity in his criticism of Watson. Christie on the other hand, shows Poirot's vanity by creating a situation where he almost makes a fool of himself.

  1. An Analysis of the Detective Genre

    Ace Ventura, a ruthless but comic pet detective is in the mind frame of Holmes himself and will do what it takes to solve a crime. This shows that the determination of Holmes has not been forgotten a hundred years on to modern detectives.

  2. An analysis of the Detective Genre.

    Holmes's appearance does not follow the Victorian values. In stories written during the Victorian times every evil person tended to look evil. However Holmes description in A Study in Scarlet is; ' his eyes were sharp and piercing...his thin hawk like nose gave his whole expression an air of alertness and decision.'

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work