The Long and The Short and The Tall The reasons why Mitchem spares the prisoners life Mitchem sapres the prisoners life as he intends to take the prisoner

Authors Avatar

The Long and The Short and The Tall

The reasons why Mitchem spares the prisoners life

Mitchem sapres the prisoners life as he intends to take the prisoner back to camp with them for interrogation, as shown on page 40, ‘we’re taking this boy back to camp with us’. Mitchem orders for the prisoner not to be killed as he sees the bigger picture of the war. Mitchem thinks that if he captures a prisoner and brings him back alive this could result in him being merited and information could be revealed about the Japanese which could result in one step forward in the war for the British forces. Mitchem’s decision makes military sense.

What Johnstone’s motives are for wanting to kil the prisoner

Johnstone wants to kill the prisoner as he feels that the prisoner may either try to escape or call for help, ‘suppose he tries to come it on? One shout from him with any of his boys and we’re in the cart’, as shown on page 43. He also believes that taking the prisoner with the squad may cause them a delay in retreating to camp, possibly resulting in the loss of the squad’s lives, as shown on page 42-43, ‘we’ve go fifteem miles to slog it back... we know tha Japs are coming through – and quick’. Johnstone basically is thinking about the safety of the squad and is realising that it is more important than the life of an enemy prisoner. He also may be being selfish and possibly cowardly by not taking the risk of taking a prisoner as this could result in his death. This could also be seen as sensible.

Join now!

Why Bamforth becomes friendly with the prisoner

Bamforth becomes friendly with the prisoner because the prisoner takes orders from Bamforth. When Bamforth orders the prisoner to put his hands upon his head, he complies. Bamforth feels respected and believes that he has a sense of authority over the prisoner. He takes joy in this as he is at the bottom of the rank ladder in the squad. He has no authority over anyone else in the hut. He finally is able to experience what it is like to give orders and for them to be followed. This is ...

This is a preview of the whole essay