• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy. Henchard - Well -Meaning Villain or Tragic Hero?

Extracts from this document...


Henchard - Well -Meaning Villain or Tragic Hero? In the novel 'The Mayor of Casterbridge' by Thomas Hardy, the main character Michael Henchard earns the contempt of many readers due to his strict, arrogant and sometimes cruel and callous nature. But is it right to hold this against him? Does he really deserve all he got? Or should we perhaps feel some sympathy towards him? After all, the disastrous incidents he endures in this book are surely not worthy of anyone, simply due to the fact they may have a negative attitude at times? In some ways, Henchard could be thought of as a 'well-meaning villain,' one who has no principal morals but no particular desire to be heartless or hurtful either. There are some incidents in the story that would suggest a villainous side to Henchard, especially at the beginning and in the closing stages of the book, where his alcoholism gets the better of him and he becomes hotheaded and violent. Instances such as the sale of his wife Susan and baby daughter Elizabeth-Jane to Richard Newson, a complete stranger, at Weydon-Priors Fair, and his drink-inspired fight with Donald Farfrae - who was once his friend - in the granary convey this idea. ...read more.


he realises what he has done and goes straight about trying to find her - and swearing an oath, by the Bible, to stop drinking in the immediate future: " I, Michael Henchard.... do take an oath before God...that I will avoid all strong liquors for the space of twenty-one years to come..." We are not told what exactly Henchard goes through in the 19-year gap in the story - the time between his selling of his family and their return after Newson's supposed death - but it would seem that although he has been unsuccessful in his quest to find his wife he has managed to keep to his vow: "They don't fill Mr Henchard's wine glasses.... he sware a gospel oath in bygone times and has bode by it ever since." Of course, it is not possible for Susan to have heard about this in her absence, but on her return when she sees what he has become she is obviously more than impressed, even in awe of Henchard: "I don't think I can meet Mr Henchard. He is not what I thought he would be - he overpowers me!" Presumably, Henchard will have worked extremely hard to have turned his life around from about the lowest possible position he could be in to the highest likewise. ...read more.


Henchard's devotion to Elizabeth-Jane is, incidentally, the only reason for his admittedly heartless lie to Newson about her being dead - he just cannot bear to lose the only person still caring for him. However, again he feels bad about it and on Newson's return lets them alone, resolving to leave Casterbridge. As to Henchard's rash, spur-of-the-moment decisions, I consider this his flaw - every 'Tragic Hero' has a defect and I fear that this is his. He does not think much about his decisions at all, and this he why he has so many regrets. For example - if he had thought of the long-term effects of dismissing Farfrae, they may have continued to work together still and Farfrae would never have taken over. If he had not stopped the courtship of Farfrae and Elizabeth-Jane, Farfrae would never have considered marrying Henchard's fianc�e. If Henchard had not lied to Newson about Elizabeth-Jane's death, the latter would not have turned against him in the end. In conclusion, I find that, despite all the things Henchard has done wrongly, I feel a great deal of compassion and sympathy towards him. He is a good and honourable man who has lost everything, due to his impetuousness; which I feel is not directly a fault of his own. It is, however, this defect that leads to his downfall, and, in my opinion, earns him the title 'Tragic Hero.' ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE The Mayor of Casterbridge section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE The Mayor of Casterbridge essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    "Discuss how the passage of time is presented in the first chapters of The ...

    3 star(s)

    been a big thing" showing the attitude towards such things at the time. She did however remember Henchard returning and saying that if a women ever asked he was in Casterbridge. On arrival at Casterbridge they were met by a great wall of trees "a dense stockdale of limes and chestnuts" which represented a wall between present and past.

  2. Analyse the change in character of Michael Henchard throughout the novel, the Mayor of ...

    His direct, no-nonsense approach meant that he willingly admitted, "the wheat had turned out badly." Also, his instant reaction to the note clarifies that Henchard is still as rash as he used to be nearly twenty years ago. The actual encounter with Farfrae discloses a commendable effort from Henchard.

  1. How Far Is Michael Henchard Responsible For His Own Ruin? , Do You Feel ...

    prosperity, it is interesting to question why Susan has even bothered come to find Michael. Susan may have even forgiven Michael for what he did in his life previously. The observation by Elizabeth Jane that the waiter does not fill the wine glass of Michael Henchard and instead by-passed him

  2. In ‘The mayor of Casterbridge’ Henchard is presented as atypical tragic hero. How far ...

    Henchards farewell words reveal his good intentions; "Judge me by my future works- Good-bye!" Henchard is not told about Elizabeth-Jane not being his daughter until he read Susan's will. This shows that there wasn't a completely truthful relationship between him and Susan, and that Susan was in the wrong all along for not telling him the truth.

  1. The mayor of casterbridge

    This gives the effect of a close village, that everyone knows everyone else's name, age and business round the community and that a large event like an auction of a wife would be unforgettable. They are used to the quiet and simple way of life rather than the complex ways of the cities.

  2. What the Mayor of Casterbridge tells us

    The workers had to wake up at extremely early hours so they could take full advantage of the amounts of sunlight; business for the farmers was difficult as the hours of sunlight was limited and the machinery was limited.

  1. How does Thomas Hardy control the reader's response to Donald Farfrae in 'The Mayor ...

    At this point the reader has a liking for Farfrae because he brings joy to Henchard and is doing great things for his business. The reader's perception of Farfrae starts to change when he becomes progressively more popular with the people of Casterbridge, which is underlined when Henchard talks to

  2. The Mayor of Casterbridge - Discussing Henchard's personality, and the reasons for his success ...

    Later, he is forced to look for work as a hay trusser in chapter 44 as 'he ends up the way, which he had come' because of his deceitful lies and his authoritative arrogance. Hardy presents Henchard very well, implicating that he is a hard working person skilled countryman, as

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work