• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"The merchant's tale presents a thoroughly cynical view of women and marriage" How far do you agree off such a statement as an accurate general description of the Merchant's Tale.

Extracts from this document...


"The merchant's tale presents a thoroughly cynical view of women and marriage" How far do you agree off such a statement as an accurate general description of the Merchant's Tale. It is true to say that the merchant presents a thoroughly cynical view of women and marriage but it is not an accurate general description of the tale. The cynicism is apparent at the very beginning in the Merchant's Prologue. The outburst by the merchant even before the tale opens sets the scene for what is to come: a parody of women and marriage. "I have a wyf, the worste that may be; For thogh he feend to hire ycoupled were, She wolde him overmacche, I dar wel swere" Although the Merchant prepares his audience for a story about a shrewd wife, he begins the Tale with an extended debate about the pros and cons of marriage. The beginning of the tale serves as a warning against marriage. Justinus prophetically warns January that "Or wheither hire thoughte it paradis or helle". There is also a mounting criticism towards women that is inherent in the way Justinus argues his point that a wife, especially a young wife will be his purgatory: "Where she be wys, or sobre, ...read more.


The merchant presents May as being cold-hearted and manipulative. Whilst January is ravishing May, she is described as being 'as stille as stoon'. There is also suggestion of cynicism towards women that is implicitly and explicitly implied through May's actions and characters' language. When May receives Damian's love letter, she merely shoves it down the toilet. Although this is done with apparent sincerity, it is indeed ironic. The audience would recognize this disparaging action and would immediately reflect this on not only on May, but on women's attitude in general. This cynicism is further demonstrated by Proserpine's attitudes and action. Throughout the entire tale there is a mock en conium of marriage that is consistently evident throughout the tale. Firstly, the reasons for marriage put forth by January are a complete mockery of marriage because his reasons are purely selfish and self-satisfactory. January feels that he should get married merely to avoid sin and to provide him an heir as to which he can give his wealth to. "On which he mighte engendren him an heir, And lede his lyf in joye and in solas" He requests a wife that is 'fair and tendre of age' because `bene-straw and greet forage'. ...read more.


When Proserpine gives May the art of deception, May's surge of confidence is deliverance to the female race. May has successfully had her revenge for January's previous actions. After all, the cynicism towards May and her actions were arisen from January's previous actions. May resorts to cuckolding January because of how January treats her in the beginning: 'buying' her from the market, ravishing her on their wedding night and building a garden so that he may do to her what cannot be done in the house. Therefore by being cynical towards women and marriage, Chaucer is synonymously being cynical to those who exploit marriage and women such as January. The conversation between Pluto and Proserpine underpin this argument because as they discuss the virtues of men and women in marriage, they come to the conclusion that few men are admirable and no women are worthy. Therefore it is fair to say that the merchant's tale presents a thoroughly cynical view of women and marriage but it is equally fair to say that it presents a cynical view of men and those who exploit women and marriage. Stephanie Ko, U6 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Geoffrey Chaucer section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Geoffrey Chaucer essays

  1. "Though told by a self-confessed liar and hypocrite, the tale has a powerful moral ...

    In contrast the tale itself is relatively plainly told and we can safely assume that the Pardoner is well practiced in the art of telling this specific tale and even inserts some of his sermon into it. His sermon is based on several medieval conventions, such as that of the mysterious old man, whom Dr.

  2. The Merchant's Tale -summary

    The Merchant's blindness leads to the negative attitudes he develops about marriage and contributes to his bitterness. The Merchant, in his disillusionment, does not advocate romantic sentiment. Instead, he makes it his sole purpose to reduce it, and plans to do so by telling a tale that will portray all wives as deceitful.

  1. Did Attitudes Towards the Status of Women and Marriage Change in the Late- Middle ...

    This is a tremendous change from the cruelty if the earlier Middle Ages. The Menagier understands that he will die before his wife and believes that it is her duty to make his latter years comfortable, however he also states that he believes that it is his obligation to make this task as easy as he can.

  2. What view of Indian culturein Amrita Pritam's A stench of Kerosine.

    a secret resolve that she would not let it go beyond the eighth year". It appears Pritam is insinuating that Indian mothers' do not look into the future interests of their children, but instead desire to build upon their position in society's hierarchy.

  1. How does the tale of the Merchant reflect the character of the Merchant himself?

    human reality' at least from the point of view of the fictional May and historical wives bound by law to their husband's dominion. Aers considers the 'Merchant's Tale' to be one of the most 'disturbing visions of traditional Christian marriage as an institutionalization of human and sexual degradation' that accepts

  2. "What do the first 149 lines of the Merchant's prologue and Tale tell us ...

    who is so trewe, and eek so entenif' revealing an obedient and attentive women. He argues that such qualities should be regarded as 'goddes yifte' (L, 99), this view is reinforced by rhetoric, a biblical reference of Eve being a gift to Adam, which justifies how valuable women are.

  1. "The Country Wife shows us that people's attitude towards love, sex and marriage have ...

    Pinchwife claims, " What is wit in a wife good for, but to make a man a cuckold?" This interestingly portrays how men were extremely conscious of their wives purity and faithfulness, however, what provokes humour in the play is the complete one sidedness attitude of the men especially when

  2. Concentrating on lines 33-186, comment on the ways in which the theme of marriage ...

    Januarie also believes that his marriage would withstand if he were to marry a younger woman. He thinks that if he married an older woman it would be easy to unfaithful and that she wouldn't be able to give him an heir, he would rather be eaten by hounds than

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work