• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Modern Eye Views Isabella

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Andrea Justice November 11, 2002 Survey of Shakespeare The Modern Eye Views Isabella Isabella is a character that modern audiences would have a hard time connecting to. Though her role in Measure for Measure is critical, a modern audience may wonder that she is simply a weak, selfish woman. Isabella strives to present herself as a godly woman but in the end can only be seen as a self righteous pawn used to further the Duke's plans. Isabella believes she is a virtuous woman. She is not only about to enter a convent in which she will be restricted for interaction with men she obviously has no issue with. Isabella longs to uphold Christian morality and religion. At the time this play was written the virtues that Isabella possessed seemed ideal. A virtuous woman was to uphold the rules of decency, remain a virgin, either remain a maid or become a wife. Modern audiences might read these virtues as prudishness or even possibly see her religion as a crutch, a loss of her own personality in exchange for a life of celibacy and protection from the outside world. ...read more.

Middle

In the scene where the Duke is instructing her as to his plan for the bed trick, she says little other than to agree with him, submitting her will to his own, "I am directed by you" (Shakespeare 4.1. 137). There is no argument and no protest. Isabella is perfectly contented to become an actor or even a puppet, if you will, in the Duke's charade. Isabel Isabella's virginity is highly prized by her, and in the time she lived it was essential. A woman's worth would be judged by her blamelessness in regard to sexual matters. In modern society however virginity is not viewed in the same light. Modern audiences are desensitized to the idea of sexual matters. For a mainstream audience member to have had sexual relations outside of marriage, even more than once, is not uncommon. At the time she lived she would seem right in her decision to retain her virginity even though it meant her brothers life, as she says about it in 2.4 lines 105-108 "Better it were a brother died at once than that a sister, by redeeming him, should die forever" (Shakespeare). ...read more.

Conclusion

She, supposedly a virtuous woman, is supposed to become a nun to help others follow in the footsteps of Christ, is advocating that another woman commit a mortal sin so that her own brother Claudio may live. It could be argued that she is doing her duty as a nun would to a friar, but as a good Christian her conscious should tell her otherwise. To cause another to stumble in place of you is a sin in itself, and the strong woman of God would stand up to the Friar and refuse to participate in his scheme. Although Shakespeare's intent may not have been to create a frigid ice queen a modern eye cannot help but wonder that Isabella is a woman only able to stand on her own two feet with the proper crutch of religious dogma under one arm and self-righteousness under the other. Though she puts on the disguise of piousness, quite possibly it may be that her choice to join the convent may be less about a passionate desire to be Christ like and more about hiding the undeniable fact that she cannot function in her society on her own. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Measure For Measure section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Measure For Measure essays

  1. Compare the characters of Angelo and Isabella and discuss how they are characters of ...

    Angelo is deceiving himself as well as risking everything. The audience here can see Angelo as a "Pernicious caitiff" and "an Hypocrite", from these acts we can see his determination and need to gain everything he desires. Angelo is willing to allow Claudio to go free in exchange of Isabella

  2. Measure for Measure By William Shakespeare - Explain the significance of the title.

    For Angelo and Lucio, marriage is punishment but for the women they marry it is a sort of reward. This takes away the romanticism of marriage. The appropriate balance of crime and punishment run through the play. It looks at how Claudio is in a committed and loving relationship and shouldn't be unfairly punished.

  1. "The last act of Measure for Measure raises more questions than it solves, is ...

    This doesn't seem like an obvious match. The second, less obvious problem is whether Marianna will be happy with Angelo. It is clear that she loves him far more than he loves her, if indeed he does at all. A relationship like that is not stable. Although we are shown some evidence of a character reformation on

  2. In what ways does Shakespeare present Isabella up until the end of Act 2?

    He replies simply, "Maiden no remedy". It is here that Isabella seems to give up: "O just but severe law! I had a brother, then: heaven keep your honour" Isabella turns to leave, this shows a weakness to her character; just because she feels as though she is losing the argument, she soon gives up.

  1. How Does Shakespeare Create Dramatic Interest in Act1 Scene2 Of Measure for Measure

    Shakespeare changes the tone of Lucio's character in act1 scene4 almost immediately after this meeting with Claudio; it changes to quite a serious tone, 'Under whose heavy sense your brother's life falls into forfeit. He arrests him on it' I feel the affect of the contrast of these quotes on

  2. What do you find interesting in the presentation of Isabella?

    Angelo: Be you content, fair maid, It is the law, not I, condemns your brother;' Shakespeare uses Isabella's careful interpretation of certain words to further defend her position. Angelo's term of earthly justice, 'is a forfeit of the law' for example is used to turn the argument around by stating

  1. Discuss Shakespeare's Presentation of Isabella in 'Measure for Measure'.

    Also I would assume that they are also developing a dislike for Angelo due to his hypocrisy and general unpleasantness towards Isabella and Claudio. Although I shall deal with the subject of soliloquies later, now is a suitable time to include some analysis of Angelo's personal reflections.

  2. Discuss Shakespeare's Presentation of Isabella in Act 5 of the Play.

    She takes part in the fist and one of the most important sections of the Act, when she exposes Angelo and is then called mad by the Duke. In her fist speech she claims that she seeks justice for the crimes committed to her, she really emphasises this point by repetition, "given me justice!

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work