• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  6. 6
    6
  7. 7
    7
  8. 8
    8
  9. 9
    9
  10. 10
    10

The Ostler by Wilkie Collins and 'Of Mice and Men' by John Steinbeck.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'The Ostler' by Wilkie Collins and 'Of Mice and Men' by John Steinbeck. 'The Ostler' was written by Wilkie Collins (1824-89), a Victorian novelist. Collins' work became popular because he wrote plots that often included mystery, suspense and crime. His stories always had extremely well constructed plots. Collins also reflected the Victorian era's interest in gothic stories. These are stories that contain supernatural or horror themes. Readers at this time enjoyed stories like 'The Ostler' and other work by Wilkie Collins like 'The Moonstone' and 'The Woman in White', although sometimes the events were a little far-fetched and improbable.'The Ostler' supports this, as it is improbable that a hallucination could in fact come to life. John Steinbeck (1902-68) was born in California and used the state as the background to his early stories and novels. Steinbeck, like his characters George and Lennie, had worked on a ranch like the one in 'Of Mice and Men'. He was shocked by the plight of many agricultural workers, whose lives were thrown into disorder during the depression in farming. This occurred in California, during the 1930's. Steinbeck's novella, 'Of Mice and Men' is effective as he was able to describe in depth the emotions that those who worked hard on the land felt. He was able to empathise with his characters, as he had experienced these hardships himself. This means that readers are able to sympathise with the workers far more. The book, at the time, was an extremely successful way to draw attention to a serious issue. Although the book doesn't dictate the rights of workers, nor bombard you with figures, the situation of the men on the ranches is still portrayed effectively. The message still gets across due to Steinbeck's excellent use of the emotions and empathy. Both 'Of Mice and Men' and 'The Ostler' begin with journeys in unpleasant circumstances. In 'The Ostler', the reader first learns of Isaac Scatchard and his 'ill luck'. ...read more.

Middle

Similarly, they are both destructive and dangerous. Rebecca Murdoch is dangerous because she is the woman of the dream, who haunts Isaac's life from then on. She, effectively, ruins his life. This is because she achieved her dream to be truly happy. Curley's wife is also like this. She could be seen to 'haunt' the men, constantly hanging around and bothering them. She spoils their lives as she dampens the atmosphere whenever the men are thinking positively. Also, the stories contain characters that attempt to protect the person they love. Similarly, both characters fail in their mission. The protective character in 'The Ostler' is Mrs.Scatchard, Isaac's mother. She wants Isaac to stay away from Rebecca as soon as she sees her. She knows she is the girl of the dream. 'Be warned, oh, my son! Be warned! Isaac! Let her [Rebecca] go and do you stop with me!' The protective character in 'Of Mice and Men' is George. He tries to look after Lennie and tells him 'Well, you keep away from her [Curley's wife], 'cause she's a rat-trap if I ever saw one.' Unfortunately, Lennie doesn't heed this advice and it results in his death. There are another two characters that are very alike, Isaac and Lennie. Each of the characters has a partner, someone they depend on to help them cope. Lennie has to almost completely rely on George, as he can't look after himself. Lennie is mentally ill and even remembering just little pieces of information are a serious challenge. George has to be there to prompt Lennie all of the time. Isaac is slightly different to this. He depends on someone, his mother, but not quite so much as Lennie. His mother is more of a guide and, although he goes out into the world by himself, she keeps him in-line. The pair are also alike physically. Both do jobs that are typical 'physical' tasks as Lennie is a ranch hand that lifts bails of hay and moves large bits of machinery all day long. ...read more.

Conclusion

This interests the reader as they imagine themselves in the character's places, they wonder if they could shoot their best friend. Curley's wife is also appealing to the readers, as they begin to wonder which one of the workers will give in to this flirty, pretty, yet dangerous, woman. Broken dreams also feature in the book. They appeal to the reader greatly as you wish so hard that George, and especially Lennie, get their little dreams of happiness. When they don't, it brings home the apt title of the book. That no matter how hard people try, things go wrong. I prefer 'Of Mice and Men' to 'The Ostler' as I find Steinbeck's work has more emotional death. In 'Of Mice and Men' you always know how the men truly felt and that this was accurate, because of Steinbeck's empathy of the experiences. Also, I find the more modern themes to the book more interesting. To me, 'The Ostler's theme was too unlikely and unrealistic for me to enjoy and this type of supernatural horror is unappealing to me. I enjoyed the themes of 'Of Mice and Men' far more than those in 'The Ostler' as there were many more relevant themes in the story, like friendship and racism. There was a lot to think about in 'Of Mice and Men' and it meant I got a lot more out of the text. The themes in the story are also more inspiring and I discovered that Steinbeck's treatment of friendship was immensely moving. To me, this type of writing that changes the way people think and makes them consider exactly what their life means. Personally, I found 'The Ostler' simply meandered on and I didn't feel I'd learnt or gained anything at the end. 'Of Mice and Men' could be seen as a piece of propaganda that was partly produced to portray the appalling working conditions of ranch workers, but also it was a plea to change the lives they had. For these reasons, 'Of Mice and Men' is the book that appealed to me most directly. 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE John Steinbeck section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE John Steinbeck essays

  1. How does Steinbeck present the relationship between George and Lennie in

    He has married in an attempt to overcome his loneliness, but has blindly chosen a wife totally inappropriate for the kind of life he leads. His feelings are all directed into aggressive behaviour, which further isolates his wife and leads to the incident with Lennie where his hand is crushed.

  2. How does Steinbeck present and develop Lennie in Of Mice and Men

    This is shown to us in the line 'an' he made like he's gonna bite me...an' I made like I was gonna smack him...an'...an' I done it. An' then he was dead'. This shows us how Lennie doesn't fully understand the concept of life and death, or that it isn't

  1. Loneliness In Of Mice and Men

    When one of the members of a friendship is removed, it causes misery and pain; when Candy lost his dog, he kept thinking about him, and felt terrible because he kept thinking that he should have shot his dog himself, and looks for friendship elsewhere.

  2. Describe how John Steinbeck creates the atmosphere of loneliness and desperation throughout the story ...

    Steinbeck creates atmosphere brilliantly in this book. Animal imagery is not only used to describe the characters, but also their movements, which give us an idea of the overall atmosphere and description of the two people. For example, "Lennie lumbered" shows us that there is tension between the two as it sounds like he doesn't really care.

  1. How does John Steinbeck use George as a symbol of good friendship in ...

    (Page 52) Candy's dreams shifted in the story when his dog dies and he suddenly becomes interested when George gives him the idea to come and start a ranch with him and Lennie. It almost seemed as if Candy had no reason to go on after his dog died.

  2. Explore John Steinbeck's presentation in Of Mice and Men of the culture and experience ...

    the novel, many members of the 1900's American society disagreed with the book and the writer's views, Steinbeck was even known to have issues with the government and the FBI. There were many problems that came with the book, but the book also brought along the realisation of the troubles

  1. A Comparison of two stories 'of Mice and Mice' And 'The Ostler'.

    Lennie started to chase her. When he got close to her he touch her dress and actually ripped a tear in it. Lennie didn't mean any harm or to rip the red dress. This is why Lennie and George were forced to leave. They emigrated to a place called Soledad.

  2. The significance of Slim in 'Of Mice and Men' By John Steinbeck.

    So through Slim, Steinbeck uses him as a way of criticising society. George and Lennie, and most of the men at the ranch, are typical migrant workers of the period. They drifted from ranch to ranch, sometimes picking up casual work but often being rejected, as there was so little work to be had.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work