The young man is hung up on appearance and fails to see that age has its compensations, like wisdom and experience, he only sees “grotesque custodians” and feels that “the human qualities seem to drop from old people insensibly day by day.”
He is uncomfortable around them and so asks that he be shown to “this haunted room of yours” because he intends to “make myself comfortable there”
Images of cold and dark are present throughout the story until they give way to light and a kind of warmth.
The narrator noted the cold way the old people had acted towards each other and to him, so he gladly left them, swapping one kind of cold for another as he “walked down the chilly echoing passage.”
It was around about this time when his mind started to play tricks on him and he allowed his imagination to run away with him. He began to consider the possibility of time “when things spiritual were different from ours, less certain, an age when omens and witches were credible, and ghosts beyond denying”
He dismisses these thoughts “with an effort” but not with much success because his candle had the power to flare up making “shadows cower and quiver” And he is chased by shadows
“a shadow came sweeping up
After me” (pg 45)
He also imagines a resulting sound but convinces himself that there is only silence.
There are a few examples of this kind, which turn out to be red herrings and are there to challenge the expectations of the reader.
The narrator tries to behave in a rational and systematic way to combat his fears. He explores all the nooks and crannies, lights candles, locks out any possible intruder, but thoughts of the recently departed duke and others who’d come to an untimely end in the room played on his mind.
He keeps trying to reassure himself that all is well despite his reliance on a revolver and candles. When they aren’t of enough comfort he resorts to rhymes but scares himself with his own echoes. He then has to abandon a conversation with himself about ghosts and their impossibility “for the same reason”
He lights more candles but when they suddenly begin to go out after midnight, he really begins to lose his nerve and starts talking aloud to himself and anything extinguishing his candles. Not surprisingly he now finds himself “almost frantic with the horror of the coming darkness.” Before long he’d lost all reason.
“an invisible hand seemed to sweep out the two candles on the table.”
And then he imagines the shadows to be personified and able to creep “in upon me, first a step gained on this side of me and then on that.” When the last of the light faded he says amongst other things that the darkness “crushed the last vestiges of reason from my brain.” Clearly the battle of wills he waged has been lost to an intangible force.
By the end of the story the narrator has satisfied himself that the room isn’t haunted but has learnt a lot more than that.
He has gained some much-needed humility and regards the old people with more respect then he did at the beginning and they too are less hostile towards him. He says the old man spoke no longer as one who greets an intruder, but for one who grieves for a broken friend. There is no hint of his previous disgust at their senility.
