• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The similarities and differences between ways in which murder is depicted in "The Tell-Tale Hearts", "The Black Cat" and "Call It Madness" "Buried the axe in her brain". Very graphic depiction of death appears in all 3 of the stories

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast the similarities and differences between ways in which murder is depicted in "The Tell-Tale Hearts", "The Black Cat" and "Call It Madness" "Buried the axe in her brain". Very graphic depiction of death appears in all 3 of the stories, "The Tell-Tale Hearts", "The Black Cat" and "Call It Madness". There are many similarities between all 3 stories and the way they portray death, there are also many differences between the Edgar Allen Poe stories and the Maupassant story. The 2 authors have different styles both describing death and murder in there own ways. The black cat is a story written by Edgar Allen Poe. The narrator describes himself as a caring person when he was a young man, "my tenderness of heart". Poe creates the character in this way so early on so that later on in the story the reader feels sorry for the murderer even though he has committed a crime. However this is not successful because of how evil the murder is. During the story the narrator describes his love for animals deteriorating into hatred this then leads to the murder of his first car Pluto. ...read more.


This shows that his mental state has completely gone. Even though Poe tries to make us feel sympathetic towards the murderer, the murderer's reliability must be questioned due to his drinking and his sheer brutality. During the Black Cat the murderer kills something he likes; Poe also creates another murderer like this in another of his stories. The Tell-Tale Heart is a story about the murder of an old man and the only motive being his eye. The language used in the Tell-Tale Heart is less descriptive than that in The Black Cat. Like the narrator in The Black Cat the murder is described very bluntly, quickly and without any real description. He explains how 'In an instant I dragged him to the floor, and pulled the heavy bed over him'. This small quotation is the whole description to a murder that thee writer has built up to from the start of the story. The description shocks the reader because of the bluntness of the language. The short, brief and blunt depiction of death also appears in The Black Cat. ...read more.


He tells of his 'urge to strangle her, to pin her to the bed'. The narrators fantasy is very detailed and violent giving us an inside into his confused state of mind and his relationship with his wife. As in The Black Cat the narrator tries to make the reader sympathise with him. At the start of Call It Madness the narrator complains about how he has 'suffered, suffered unendingly, intensely, agonizingly'. He uses a whining tone which makes the reader feel sorry for him and have pity on him. The murder in Call It Madness contrasts with the rest of the story. Instead of being very detailed it is blunt and abrupt. Rather than describing the murder in detail he simply 'let her have my other bullet in the stomach'. This shocking technique is used in all 3 of the stories because it shock the reader after giving such detailed description before hand. As we have seen all 3 of these stories depict murder in a very blunt way. The authors manipulate the readers into feeling sorry for the murderers before they commit there violent acts. Once the narrator has murdered the readers begins to feel strong hatred towards them because of how they tricked the readers into believing their innocence. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Edgar Allan Poe section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Edgar Allan Poe essays

  1. Compare and contrast The Tell-Tale Heart and The Black Cat

    we were told at the start of the story how "dreadfully nervous" the narrator was. His nervousness caused him to come forward as the perpetrator because he could not handle the emotional challenge of concealing the body. In The Black Cat, it was by accident that the body was revealed to the police.

  2. Comparison of 'The Tell Tale Heart', 'The Black Cat', and 'The Oval Portrait'.

    It concentrates in the dark thoughts of a man who is becoming increasingly hostile towards his pet cat. These stories all contain traces of chaos and trauma, but again, 'The Oval Portrait' contains far milder references, making it hard to classify the story as mentally disturbing material.

  1. Edgar Allan Poe's "Tell-Tale Heart" and "The Black Cat" - A critical comparison.

    There is no real reasoning for this decision, except for the fact that the narrator suddenly takes a violent dislike to the way the old man looks at him. The narrator is essentially losing his mind; he is consumed by some inconceivable need to rid himself of the insanity caused by the old man and his eye.

  2. Compare and Contrast "The Tell Tale Heart" by Edgar Allan Poe and "A Confession ...

    'The Tell-Tale Heart' the victim is an old man, but in 'A confession found in a prison in the time of Charles II' the victim is a very young boy. Another difference is where the murders take place; in 'The Tell-Tale Heart' the murder takes place inside, but in 'A

  1. How is tension created in 'The tell tale hearts' and 'The black cat'?

    The stories are written in first person narrative, which makes the reader feel as though they are in the story, involved personally, and is made to feel what the narrator feels. From the very beginning of the tales the reader gets an idea of what kind of stories they are

  2. 'The Fruit at the Bottom of the Bowl' 'The Tell Tale Heart' And ...

    A third person narrative is when we are given an account in of what occurred in a situation. This account should hopefully be less biased as it is not given to us from the principal character's perspective (the main character).

  1. 'How are nineteenth century short stories traditional short stories?'

    Now we will be looking at 'The Stolen Bacillus' written by H.G. Wells. This story is about a man who steals the disease cholera to spread it among London's population. The first line in the story is, "This again,' said the Bacteriologist, slipping a glass slide under the microscope, 'is a preparation of the celebrated Bacillus of cholera-the cholera germ."

  2. Choose two of the pre-20th century short stories that you have studied. Compare and ...

    -- Tear up the planks!" We feel the tension mount throughout the story as we learn what happens, and since it is written in first person, we discover the storyline as the narrator tells it, it is written as a confession, as if the narrator was trying to find a way to 'pardon his sins'.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work