"The Yellow Wallpaper" and "The Nightingale and the Rose" both contain main characters that undergo hardship. How do the authors make us sympathise with these characters?

Authors Avatar

"The Yellow Wallpaper" and "The Nightingale and the Rose" both contain main characters that undergo hardship.  How do the authors make us sympathise with these characters?

"The Yellow Wallpaper" by Charlotte Perkins Gilman and "The Nightingale and the Rose" by Oscar Wilde, are two stories in which the authors induce a great feeling of sympathy in the reader.  Using character personality, circumstance, language and narrative style, both authors encourage us to sympathise with the main characters in a thought-provoking and often unexpected manner.

       The main character in "The Yellow Wallpaper" is the narrator, whose name, we learn at the end, might be Jane.  The reader sympathises with the narrator largely due to her situation.  She suffers, it is implied, from post-natal-depression.  As she recuperates with her neurasthenia, she is not allowed to do anything but rest, she has "a schedule prescription for each hour in the day" and is especially forbidden from the creative work of writing.  Moreover, the narrator is confined to an unpleasant and threatening room, one she strongly dislikes.  She states "I should hate it myself if I had to live in this room long".  The narrator grows progressively insane, up to the very end of the story, where she is found to have locked herself in her room, and is circling it, creeping.  The reader sympathises greatly with the narrator in this situation, not merely because she is ill, but also because of the 'cure'; she is disallowed to do the things she loves, and - as is evident at the end of the story - this is extremely damaging for her.

       Alongside the narrator's situation, her personality produces sympathy in the reader.  The narrator is shown to be an intelligent woman, as she knows "a little of the principle of design" and goes on to describe, with great knowledge, the uniqueness of the wallpaper.   From the very style of the story, it is evident that she is deeply thoughtful; she dwells on her surroundings and is analytical of her situation and treatment.  This induces a frustrated sympathy in the reader, as one can see the narrator's restrained potential, as she is condemned with the rest 'cure'.

Join now!

       Furthermore, the other characters in the story make us feel sympathy for the narrator.  John, a practical physician, is married to the narrator, but he treats her more like an infant.  He patronises her, frequently referring to her with the diminutive tag of "little", and acts as if she were incapable of reaching her own decisions.  John forbids the narrator from working on anything creative while she convalesces, evidence that he does not understand her condition.  Instead, he believes in a strict, paternalistic divide between men and women; men work outside of the home, as he does, ...

This is a preview of the whole essay