"This dead butcher and his fiend-like queen" - To what extent do you agree with Malcolm's summation of the Macbeths and why?

Authors Avatar

“This dead butcher and his fiend-like queen” – To what extent do you agree with Malcolm’s summation of the Macbeths and why?

I do not fully agree with Malcolm’s summation of Macbeth as a “dead butcher” because even though he (and L. Macbeth) carried out the murders of what they thought was necessary to achieve their target of getting the crown, it is the influence of the supernatural (the three witches), and Lady Macbeth, as she is responsible in controlling Macbeths emotions and thus to a certain extent his actions which consequently lead them to their deaths.  However, I agree to a greater extent with Malcolm’s description of Lady Macbeth as a “fiend-like queen” because right from the beginning we can see her burning ambition to become queen, and how she asks the evil spirits who “tend on mortal thoughts” to come into her and “stop up th’ access and passage to remorse”, so she has the strength to cope with the murder of King Duncan.  She also manages to persuade Macbeth to carry out the murder of King Duncan when he clearly said, “We will proceed no further in this business”, by mocking Macbeths lack of courage and calling him “a coward”.  We can see she is stronger, more ruthless and ambitious than Macbeth was.

Join now!

In the beginning of the play, Macbeth is introduced as a brave warrior hero who won the battle for Scotland.  He is first mentioned as “brave Macbeth”, this is important because a tragedy depends on the audience witnessing the downfall of an already great man.  Phrases such as “Valour’s minion” (bravery’s favourite or servant) and “Bellona’s Bridegroom” (husband of goddess of war) emphasizes his reputation on the battlefield.  “Valour’s minion” is a metaphor which is ironic because in this case, his great (murdering) skills on the battlefield is advantageous to him now, but later on in the play it ...

This is a preview of the whole essay