• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Through a comparison of 'A Case of identity' and 'The Stolen Cigar case' discuss how successful Bret Harte is in parodying Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

Extracts from this document...


Through a comparison of 'A Case of identity' and 'The Stolen Cigar case' discuss how successful Bret Harte is in parodying Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. There are two forms of detective story: there is the 'who dunnit' idea in which gentlemen detectives are called upon in all sorts of impossible situations, but always manage to solve the crime. In this type, the reader has a good idea of who committed the 'crime'; however, the characters in the story don't. The other type of story is a mystery, in which neither reader nor investigators know who is responsible for the crime; together with the characters, the reader too is invited to figure out the sequence of events. In the Sherlock Holmes stories the focus is on the character of the detective himself (Sherlock Holmes) and follows the story of him solving a mystery. Sherlock Holmes (S.H) was a legendary figure as he was the very first fictional detective; his stories were written in the Victorian times by the writer Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. The S.H stories have many common features. For example S.H is seen to be very well organised and by the end, his efforts have concluded in solving the mystery/crime. This has made it easier for Bret Harte to parody Conan Doyle's style; he uses many similar features like the same old fashioned language and also in having Sherlock Holmes or Hemlock Jones (as he is called in the parody), portrayed as a very precise, eccentric detective. ...read more.


He is very confident in himself and states his own opinion as a fact, "there is nothing so unnatural as the commonplace". All these and the following points about S.H are what makes the stories so easy to parody: he always has the same features and has the same distinct mannerisms "finger-tips still pressed together, his legs stretched out in front of him, and his gaze directed up to the ceiling". He also has a constant "look of infinite languor in his face" showing he doesn't let any case trouble him. Also he has a meticulous process of deduction involved in his method of investigation: he finds a clue and sits in silent thought; he is always right. He has a certain process of questioning, then observing, then analysing. S.H and Watson seem very close and the impression is given that Sherlock is never out of work. Their relationship however is similar to that of some teacher-pupil relationships, as Watson admires Sherlock while Sherlock looks down on Watson. Not only does he correct Watson's observations; S.H labours the point to make his assistant appear incompetent. For instance when Watson remarks that much of what he's read is "invisible" to him, S.H responds "Not invisible, but unnoticed, Watson. You did not know where to look, and so you missed all that was important." ...read more.


As seen in "A Case of Identity" S.H has meticulous record keeping, Bret Harte ridicules this by showing small glass jars on H.J's shelf containing "Pavement and Road Sweepings" and even "fluff from Omnibus and Road-Car Seats"! H.J's speech and language are also very melodramatic to magnify the fact Sherlock speaks in a formal fashion. In the story, H.J goes to eccentric lengths to try and prove that his partner Watson has stolen his expensive cigar case, when all along it is clear to the reader that it has just been mislaid. He goes as far as to say to Watson "You bartered your honour for it-that stolen cigar case was the purchaser of the sealskin coat". This left Watson stunned. However by the time H.J has finished his long speech about how Watson must have taken it, Watson was left doubting his own sanity, Even though he knew deep down he hadn't stolen the cigar case. When Hemlock realised that it had been in his draw all along he was "vexed" and in shock as he said slowly "I have been mistaken", despite this he still didn't apologise to Watson for accusing him. I think Bret Harte did an effective parody of the Sherlock Holmes stories as they are already over the top to start with, so it must have been difficult to compete with that. I think he achieved a comic affect within his version of the story and was good at enlarging the ridiculousness of it for the humour of the reader. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Conan Doyle essays

  1. With reference to two of the stories that you have read discuss what makes ...

    The hissing ceases and when they go into Dr Roylotts room they find him dead with a speckled snake around his head. A Scandal in Bohemia in about the king of Bohemia coming to Holmes to ask him to find a picture.

  2. In this course work, I attempt to discuss how the lead characters are portrayed ...

    Her desire for money is shown in the opening page but she also does not want to waste her energy on a case she could not believe in.

  1. Brighton Rock and Sherlock Holmes: A Comparison

    The simple description has therefore set up an atmosphere; it is atmospheric. In The Man With The Twisted Lip Conan Doyle does use one unusual device to add depth to his writing: a ruse in the plot at the very beginning to throw the reader off what the true plot is.

  2. Pre-1914 Literature Arthur Conan Doyle

    If a man of the upper class fails to acquire these fundamental aspects of a well character gentleman they would be known as a fallen gentleman. In 'The Speckled Band' Dr Roylott is a perfect example of a fallen gentleman: "he beat his native butler to death and narrowly escaped

  1. Overview Of "The Adventure Of Te Engineers Thumb" By Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

    Suddenly, however, as I ran, a deadly dizziness and sickness came over me." the story now leads to where Holmes is best, at solving crimes with very little evidence and clues. Holmes then shows Hatherley a newspaper advertisement saying "Lost, on the 9th inst., Mr.

  2. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle Case File

    In 1892, Louise gave birth to Arthur Allyne Kingsley. Also Conan Doyle's most famous stories, The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, were published. The following year, Conan Doyle visits Reichenbach Falls. Sadly, Louise is diagnosed with tuberculosis and Conan Doyle's father, Charles, dies.

  1. Why is Conan Doyle a successful writer of crime stories?

    He is loud and abusive, "What has she been saying to you? Screamed the old man furiously". He is also private, "Don't you dare to meddle with my affairs". He also has an Indian past, "When Dr Roylott was in India he married my mother, Mrs Stoner.".

  2. Howdoes the society have an affect on Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's writings?

    Sir Arthur Conan Doyle often thought that women have less strength but they are more emotional than men because in both stories "The Speckled Band" and "The man with the twisted lip" the ladies at the beginning are "terrified manner" as Conan Doyle expresses Helen stoner and "lost her self

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work