To what extent are the deaths of Romeo and Juliet caused by them being 'star-cross'd lovers', and to what extent are they caused by the different characters own actions?

Authors Avatar

To what extent are the deaths of Romeo and Juliet caused by them being ‘star-cross’d lovers’, and to what extent are they caused by the different characters own actions?

Romeo and Juliet was written in 1595 for an Elizabethan audience. It was set in Verona and Mantua in Italy. People of Shakespeare’s time thought of Italy as immoral and famous for it sexual affairs and crime. The audience would have expected Romeo and Juliet to include affairs and violence but would still react shocked to the actions going on in the play, as even though it would be normal, because of the notorious rumours of Italy, the audience would be used to have a happy ending. When fate and inevitability are present in a storyline the audience feels pity for the characters and fear for what is going to happen. The deaths in the play Romeo and Juliet have many possible causes, although they both eventually kill themselves, Romeo and Juliet could have been influenced to do this by other characters or each other. It is constantly suggested that their deaths were determined by fate, so none of the other characters could have influenced this anyway. Or it could just be because of their bad luck. They are not the only characters killed in the play.

Romeo and Juliet opens with a prologue, which sets the scene to the play and gives the audience their first impressions of the characters. It particularly focuses on the parents feud  “ancient grudge break new mutiny” shows us that the two households have had friction between them for a long time and that, they constantly fight and bicker particularly between the younger more headstrong members of the families. Romeo and Juliet being of different house holds, were born to hate each other, “fatal loins” shows this, as it implies that because they were not supposed to like each other because of their parents hate for each other. It also suggest that fate had already planned for them to meet and fall in love. Tybalt is a perfect example of how the Montague-Capulet feud had taken over his life. “As I hate hell, all Montagues, and thee” shows how much he really despises Montagues. He has been taught and brought up to believe that the Montagues are the enemy, so he is always trying to fight them. When he finds out that Romeo went to the Capulet’s party, Tybalt says that he wants to kill him. His actions are melodramatic and this is showed with the punctuation that is used. There is an excessive amount of explanation points and short words, which create the effect that he is short tempered and energetic.  Shakespeare has used Tybalt to reflect the intense hatred for each other, between the households.  This does not let the audience ever forget the feud between the Montagues and the Capulets. Mercutio blames both the Montagues and the Capulets for his own death, when Tybalt stabs him after becoming involved in a fight between them. He repeats the word “a plague o’ both your houses” he curses them both for continuing the feud. The feud between the two households causes a rift between Romeo and Juliet but they choose to ignore that their families are fighting and still meet each other in secret and continue to develop their relationship. “a rose by any other name would smell as sweet” shows that Juliet realises the risks in meeting Romeo but her feelings are so strong that she still does.

Join now!

 At the very beginning of Romeo and Juliet, Romeo is head over heels in love with Rosaline. Romeo falls in and out of love very quickly, or at least he says he loves people after not knowing them for a very long time. In the first scene he complains to his cousin Benvolio that he loves Rosaline so much but because it is unrequited love he states that he does not want to do anything. Romeo acts very upset, crying and hiding in the dark and constantly uses poetic language, with oxymoron’s, e.g. “ O loving hate! … O ...

This is a preview of the whole essay