• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent does Miller want us to agree with Alfieri's reactions at the end of the play?

Extracts from this document...


To what extent does Miller want us to agree with Alfieri's reactions at the end of the play? Kay Bennett 11JE Mr Rose In A View From The Bridge, Arthur Miller aimed to write a modern tragedy involving 'the common man'. He wrote in 1949 for the New York Times that 'the common man is an apt a subject from tragedy in it's highest sense as kings were'. He thought that tragedy 'is the consequence of a man's total compulsion to evaluate himself justly' and that most of us are willing to remain passive when our dignity and our image of our rightful status is questioned. But some among us 'act against the scheme of things that degrades them' and question what 'has previously been unquestioned'. Miller thought that the common man was capable of such a process of questioning and chose to demonstrate this by creating a character with the spirit to do so - Eddie Carbone. Miller's definition of tragedy shows us that he wished to enlighten and spark discussion about the human condition with the play. Miller choose to close the play with a speech by Alfieri. Alfieri takes the role of commentator in the play. He is wise but unable to change the course of events, similar to the chorus in a Greek tragedy. ...read more.


Eddies tragic flaw is that he is unable to 'settle for half'. He loves Catherine who he cannot have and is not prepared to be a 'sensible client' and listen to reason. Alfieris final speech starts with 'Most of the time we settle for half and I like it better'. In Alfieri's (and probably most of the audiences) opinion, it is best to follow and rely on the law as much as possible even when you are only half satisfied. The law will not always correlate with your idea of justice, but it is still better to follow the law than to take into into your own hands. Alfieri holds the law above justice (which is subjective) and maintains that not obeying the law can lead to conflict, but he also tries to stop Eddie reporting Marco and Rodolpho to the Immigration Bureau "When the law is wrong it is because it is unnatural, but in this case it is natural and a river will drown you if you buck it now." But Alfieri respects Eddie for being willing to lay down his life for what he sees as justice, even if he does not have the backing of law, when he says ' the truth is holy'. ...read more.


This can also be interpreted as Alfieri's horror that Eddie destroyed himself and he was unable to stop it. Eddie is holding the knife as it stabs him, so he literally dies by his own hand so his death could also be seen as his nadir. This links with the part in his introduction at the start about lawyers before him sitting in their offices hearing similar cases, sitting there 'as a powerless as I, and watched it run it's bloody course'. reinforcing the sense of inevitably about Eddie's downfall. Miller wants the ending of the play to inspire discussion and excuse us to question things we have previously accepted. He says in his definition of tragedy that it brings us knowledge or enlightenment as opposed to pathos which just brings us 'sadness, sympathy, on even fear', which just brings us 'sadness, sympathy or even fear'. Without this final speech the play would just and with those things. Arguably, Alfieri's speech is designed to bring us knowledge and enlightenment. On the other hands, Alfieri sounds confused. Miller certainly wants us to discuss the issues raised in his speech but Alfieri is not very persuasive in telling as why feels that something perversely pure calls out to [him] from [Eddies] memory. He sounds as if he has out much of an idea why he feels this way despite evidence to the contrary. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Arthur Miller section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Arthur Miller essays

  1. Catherine says Eddie is "a rat" who belongs in the sewer - To what ...

    She also seems jealous of Catherine; she says to Catherine, "you act like a baby...when you throw yourself at him". She is telling Catherine that she need to mature, then for Eddie to treat her like an adult, but also because now seventeen and is a grown women, so it

  2. How does Miller use Alfieri to inspire Sympathy forEddie?

    Eddie lives in, "the slum that faces the bay on the seaward side of Brooklyn Bridge" which shows that he suffers poverty like all Italian Immigrants in Red Hook in Brooklyn. Eddie migrated from Sicily, where the conditions were even worse, looking for work and a better life in America, the so-called land of opportunity.

  1. Q. At the end of the play Alfieri says of Eddie that despite "how ...

    wrongful things, he still admires him for being able to express his passionate and primal impulses, when the society has succeeded in making most people hide them. We are told that Eddie's primitive passion is the "perversely pure" thing that "calls to...

  2. Does Arthur Miller Want Us To See The Play As A Tragedy? (A View ...

    After Eddie and Catherine, Beatrice enters the room. Her character is a very thoughtful person who cares about every members of her family. She loves her husband (Eddie) and she also loves Catherine. This is the family, which is going to have their life upside down after Beatrice's cousins come.

  1. "There are times when you want to spread an alarm but nothing has happened." ...

    Catherine plans on going out for the evening with Rudolpho, she gets very dressed up to impress him but Eddie makes her change into different clothes, to embarrass her and to make it look like he thinks Rudolpho wasn't worth the effort.

  2. At the end of the play Alfieri says of Eddie that despite 'how wrong ...

    However, although Eddie's death was "useless", "something perversely pure" calls to Alfieri from his memory - "not purely good, but himself purely, for he allowed himself to be wholly known". Most of us, says Alfieri, being more educated, more sophisticated, more in control, can either hide our feelings or, better, overcome them.

  1. Discuss Alfieri's role in the play commenting on how he furthers the drama.

    Alfieri's role as the narrator creates a step-by-step guide of the play for the audience to follow. He guides the audience through all the heightened moments during the play. He talks directly to the audience as the narrator all the way through, so that the audience can capture a clearer

  2. How does Miller make the Vinny Bolzano Story a Fascinating Moment to return to ...

    when he has to talk with Beatrice, he keeps his words as short as possible and usually ducks out of their conversations. When Catherine goes to get Eddie?s cigar, The stage directions say Beatrice has been avoiding Eddie?s gaze, suggesting she sees how he feels about Catherine and how differently he behaves when he is with Catherine compared to her.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work