Using any literary or linguistic approach with which you are familiar, write about how the impressions of the speakers are created in the poem 'No Dialects Please' by Merle Collins.

for a writin that could wrap up a feelin

an fling it back hard

with the captive power to choke de stars”.

This is done in the poem, which tells of the writer’s feelings due to the suggestion that a dialect could not meet these requirements for poetry. Throughout the writers feelings are conveyed to the reader and are obviously strong, making the poetry that of the category which the competition was looking for which was exemplified by the powerful metaphor “captive power to choke the stars”.

        The feelings in the poem are clear, disgust, outrage and even pain due to the competition’s lack of respect for her dialect, which indicates their lack of respect for the writer’s culture, a feature the writer relates back to the slave trade.

        In the poems graphology two main characteristics indicate the emotions of the writer. The use of uppercase characters and explanation marks indicate an exaggeration in the tone of the words, for instance

        “AFRICAN SLAVES PLEASE!”

The presence of this exaggeration indicates the disbelief of the write at the statements, which is further demonstrated by the presence of the “please” at the end of most the statements acting as a softener to the command prior as a pathetic attempt to prevent the insult that the writer feels.

        Another simple way that feelings are conveyed is through evaluative adjectives in the direct speech of the writer provided by the monologue form, for example when the writer is speaking about the lack of knowledge the British population has about the history of their language she says,

        “how dis British education mus really be narrow”

The strength of the writer’s feeling can also be seen in the syntactical repetition of

        “Is not only dat ah think”,

throughout the second verse and the pattern of three in the third verse,

        “bout a culture o we own

a language o we own

        a identity o we own”

The writer also says,

        “But if dat not enough pain

        for a body to bear”,

indicating the suffering she feels is almost unbearable causing her a great amount of suffering.

The writer’s defiance from the English when she states,

        “Make me ha to go

        and start up a language o me own”

shows she feels like she does not want to be included when they are told,

        “We’re all British!”,

but would rather have her own culture conveyed through her language including her dialect.

        Overall the whole poem acts as an example to show how the competition is wrong to remove dialect from poems, as it will prevent the conveyed feelings to be received by the audience. This is done by the whole poem being in the writers dialect but still being intelligently, shown by the cohesion and educated lexis, and effectively powerful.