Using the four poems; 'Song of the old mother' by William Butler Yeats, 'On my first sonne' by Ben Johnson, 'Digging' by Seamus Heany and 'Catrin' by Gillian Clarke, I am going to compare how the poets use different techniques

Authors Avatar

Poetry Essay               11/11/2004        

Choose; two poems from the poetry bank, one by Seamus Heaney and one poem by Gillian Clarke and compare all four poems on how they write about the relationships between parents and children.

Using the four poems; ‘Song of the old mother’ by William Butler Yeats, ‘On my first sonne’ by Ben Johnson, ‘Digging’ by Seamus Heany and ‘Catrin’ by Gillian Clarke, I am going to compare how the poets use different techniques to show the relationships between parents and children, also how the writer conveys their ideas to the reader.

In the following paragraphs I’m going to talk my interpretation of the four selected poems.

In ‘Song of the Old Mother’ William Butler Yeats is the writer for this poem however he is not the narrator of this poem, his mother is. This poem is about growing old and how the mother thinks children take things for granted. The mother talks about everyday simple tasks, she has lots of work to do ‘even before the children and sun come out’. She repeats that because she is old, she must work and she is warning her children that one day her children will too be old and have to work really hard and she is getting cold because it is getting late and the fires going out. I think by this the poet seems to be saying that the mother is getting to old and may die soon. She knows as well as the reader that the mother will have to get up early in the morning to start her daily tasks all again. She is also talking about that while she is working her female children are dreaming about silly, stupid, immature, girly things, like ‘ribbons in their hair’. Even though the mother seems to be moaning I feel that she does love her children, she just wants the best for them and is trying to warn them about life in the future.

The poem ‘On my first Sonne’ is about the death of Ben Johnson’s (the poet) 7-year-old son. It was a shock but in those days it was much more common to loose a baby at young age because of the poor medicine and nutrition. Religion was an important part of this poem. Johnson believed, (as well as many other people) that his child belonged to God and that God lent Ben his child for a certain amount of time and then also took the child away again. The poet shows his conflicting emotions and the poets feelings of guilt. The poet tells the reader that he regrets expecting too much but he wants to avoid being hurt again.

The central idea of the poem ‘Digging’ is the contrast between the pen and the spade. The spade is a symbol for Heany’s routes, while the pen is a symbol for his trade and the power of his writing. The poet explains the admiration towards his father and grandfather. In the beginning of the poem Heany was not proud of his occupation, however at the end of the poem he was in a better frame of mind and had overcome his guilt of not carrying his father’s footsteps.

Join now!

Finally ‘Catrin’, this poem is about love and conflict. Gillian Clarke remembers the first, ‘fierce, confrontation’, between herself and the baby. The labour experienced by both of them was probably a painful affair. The poet remembers the tight red rope of love we both fought over, which means they both want to cut the umbilical cord. The poet explains that even when the child is grown up she feels the tension between them still. The poet talks about how they both longed to be separated, however the love between them was still there.

In the following paragraphs I’m going ...

This is a preview of the whole essay