• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Was the Battleof the Sommea failure?

Extracts from this document...


G.C.S.E COURSEWORK HISTORY Was the Battle of the Somme a failure? 1) Source A, written by Malcolm Brown, expresses the opinion of people who believed the Battle of the Somme was 'a tragic massacre of a generation' and 'an event so terrible it killed the breezy, crusading spirit of 1914-15. Furthermore it tells of the opinion that the Somme ended a 'Golden Age'. Brown states the fact that the 9th Yorks and Lancasters Lost 423 men in its first battle. 2) Source B, a cartoon from Punch published in February 1917, is giving the artists impression of World War I Generals and their roles in battles. Before World War I, battles had been fought on much thinner fronts, thus making Generals able to give commands to all his troops because he could be close to all of them at the same time. In World War I, fronts were much wider and Generals had to stay way behind front lines to give orders to all the troops and had to be done using phones and messengers. The artist clearly does not like the way that the General stays in safety while the infantry fighting are suffering immensely in hard conditions with death everywhere. This feeling was common among a lot of people and the artist portrays the General as quite fat and unfit in the drawing, illustrating how he is always in safety not doing any action while his soldiers go to there deaths without the General caring. ...read more.


This would explain the casualties to an extent. The 2 sources explain source F fairly well but they do not explain them fully because there are many other reasons why the British had such high casualties. The Ineffectiveness of the artillery against the enemy barbed wire, meant that soldiers were delayed because the barb wire was in the way. This was another reason for the high casualties as they got shot at when they were cutting the wire. The machine gun was another reason for the high casualties. The slow walking troops got massacred by the machine gun causing many deaths and explaining the high casualty figures. Lastly another reason for high casualty figures was the fact that the troops we're new and inexperienced so did not know how to deal with situations like these so got killed more easily. Source D and E while explaining the casualty figures to an extent they do not explain the casualty figures fully because there were many other reasons for the high casualties which they don't explain. 5) Both of the sources G and H can have their reliability brought into question. Source G was written by Lloyd George and published in 1933-36 as his War Memoirs. Lloyd George was very critical of the Battle of the Somme in his memoirs and disliked the Generals of World War I so was seen as very biased against them especially Haig who wrote Source H. ...read more.


Source D an eye witness account explains the British advance and how it was walking across waiting to get slaughtered by German machine gun fire. This kind of fighting can also support Taylor's quote because it is accurate of what actually happened and is most likely quite reliable. Source G which comments that the 'Somme killed off far more of our best' Is by Lloyd George and is partially true and does supports Taylor's idea, however it is not very reliable and considered bias as I said before. Source E states that Germans had strong morale and good physique and says that the Germans had excellent defenses stopping the British which was true and these defenses proved to be decisive in the Battle and caused big losses on the British's side the source slightly supports Taylor's idea but not strongly. Sources I and H however describe the fact that the Germans morale and will to fight was also drained and they had suffered from having too high expectations of the war. It tells of a German Soldiers disgust at life. This shows that it was not only the British soldiers that got brought down to earth by World War I but also the Germans. I believe that the sources do provide evidence to supports AJP Taylor's words. The evidence is fairly reliable but shows how British troops had unrealistic expectations of war and war only server to make them realize the reality of war. The sources also show that it was not only the British whose 'Zest and Idealism' perished but also the Germans and other countries. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE War Poetry essays

  1. Was the Battle of the Somme a success or a failure?

    On the German side they had built much better trenches. They believed that they would be in their trenches for a very long time and so built their trenches with very deep and strong dugouts. These were far more advanced trenches than the British and the trenches played a major role in the battle.

  2. Why is the battle of the Somme regarded as such a great military tragedy?

    This severely effected morale and the amount of enlisted volunteers dropped in a shocking manor. I understand this to be another reason for the Somme being realised as a military tragedy but also a human tragedy because of the lose of most of male population in small towns, the huge

  1. The Battle of the Somme - source related study.

    I believe I need to mention Haig's personality in this source, as it is something that needs to be dealt with. Haig was a Calvinist and this led him to believe that God approved all of his actions. This is why I believe that he seems so unconcerned about the

  2. Pre 1914 War Poetry - The Drum and Drummer Hodge analysed.

    John Scott says 'thoughtless youth', and portrays them being seducted into war. Elder readers would have been able to relate ignorance and youth to their own younger male relatives, and then been able to dissuade them or prevent them from going to war.

  1. War Poetry GCSE

    as the fewer there are of them the more likely they are to lose. Amongst many of the other key ideas another which stands out is the promise of 'Immortality' which King Henry V promises to all those who fight alongside him.

  2. Book Review: First Day on the Somme

    He also studies the relationships between Haig, Rawlinson, and Gough, the three generals in charge of the attacks, as he believes that their relationships towards each other may have had powerful influence on their decisions within the battle. Middlebrook thoroughly describes the plan of attack, but is careful not to

  1. Britain and the Western Front.

    as he believed the key objectives of the battle had been achieved with the Verdun area of France saved, with the aim of a "War of Attrition" successfully met, due to the 500,000 German casualties. Sir Douglas Haig stated that he warned the politicians in 1916 that the country had


    Another possible reason for George's positive overview of the situation could be that he realises the battle isn't going quite to plan and sees morale is dropping throughout the British forces and feels that its in there best interest that he gives an over positive synopsis of the battle, to boost morale.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work