• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What do you think the poet is saying about some teachers of English and the way they mark a students book in the poem English Book by Jane Weir? How does the poet present her opinions?

Extracts from this document...


What do you think the poet is saying about some teachers of English and the way they mark a student's book in the poem "English Book" by Jane Weir? How does the poet present her opinions? (18 marks) Jane Weir seems very unimpressed by the way her son's English teacher marks his book. She is describing her visit to a Parents' Evening and starts by plunging straight in with the pronoun 'they' to begin the poem in the middle of the consultation. The first two lines express her surprise that they seem unaffected by their years 'in a classroom', all sitting 'upright' and correctly to meet the mother. ...read more.


The teacher has very little understanding that (according to the mother) she is killing the child's creativity by concentrating so much on his technical mistakes. The poet, probably writing from real experience, cannot get the teachers to understand that her son has ability with words and that they are not appreciating or encouraging his ideas. The whole poem is full of imagery. The teachers are compared to books: 'they bear no tide mark' and have 'perfect spines' probably unlike the condition of the exercise book that the mother is about to be shown. Later metaphors (lines 13 to 15) seem to describe textiles, in the same way that Jane Weir weaves fabric imagery into her poem 'Poppies' - 'selvedge', 'rolls out' 'flecked with heartfelt' - perhaps to express the situation from a woman's point of view. ...read more.


The resulting page is 'piled with offal'. After the butchering, only the inedible (unreadable) parts are left, nevertheless the mother believes her son is very intelligent. She sees 'the oracle in his entrails' and 'the jazz /of his sequencing' would seem to describe a lively imagination at work. From the mother's point of view the excessive emphasis on the importance of technical accuracy is harming the boy and the teacher makes little effort to listen to the mother's concerns or to see anything worth praising in the boy's writing. Described metaphorically as 'a starved lion-cub waiting for a word kill', this final image presents a child, waiting hungrily to experience and enjoy language, but being 'starved' by a teacher who cannot see 'what beats at (the) centre' of his writing. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Other Poets section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Other Poets essays

  1. Extended Writing on Maya Angelou(TM)s poem Caged Bird

    Angelou also uses alliteration in this line with "worms waiting", I believe this helps the flow of the poem and that it emphasizes the relaxation of the bird. In the final line of this stanza the bird "names the sky his own" this goes back to the first stanza when

  2. Siegfried Sassoon Presentation

    Seeing all these people dying for their country's glory hit home. When his friend David Thomas, and his much loved brother Hamo were killed at the battle of Gallipoli, he went berserk, almost as if he got shell-shock after it.

  1. To what extent do you think that Yeats thought he was living in a ...

    However, his opinion on the Civil War was ambivalent. Although Yeats disliked violence, he understood that those taking part in the Civil War were just good people who wanted a free Ireland, which is something he also wanted. His fear of the antichrist links in with his belief of the 'gyres'.

  2. Thomas Kinsella - A personal response Thomas Kinsella is a poet that is ...

    the it, or I can do what Kinsella does in this poem, which I much prefer, and just accept it as part of life. "I fold my towel.... not young and not renewable, but man." Kinsella isn't happy about the fact that he's aging (and who is?)

  1. Analysis of "The Mother" by Gwendolyn Brooks

    To me the poem voices so much emotion, love and pain, but more so anger and regret. She uses the word ?Dim? rather than abortion, Gwendoline describes the lady as soft and kind, she does this by writing ?you will never neglect or beat them?.

  2. How does the poet show how she feels about her mother in Praise Song ...

    She describes her as ?water?. Traditionally water symbolizes life, healing and cleansing. She continues to describe her mother as ?deep and bold and fathoming? this only accentuates the emotions and feelings within their relationship, the confidence, courage and bravery (all features of the sea if you perceive it metaphorically), and the quality of understanding that her mother has.

  1. Explore how the poet presents his thoughts and feelings about what is happening in ...

    the government whose opinions are imitated as ?Do not rock the boat, We?re doing our best?, suggesting

  2. Drawing parallels with other poems in the Book of Matches explore the ways in ...

    on the hitcher reveals the envy that he felt when confronted by a person who appeared to have total freedom. 'I let him have it' is a blunt description of the physical attack during which the narrator hit the hitcher initially with his own head and then ?six times with the krooklok?, directly in his face.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work