What makes a good short story? With detailed references to the stories you have read from the nineteenth century, explain what has interested you.

Authors Avatar

WHAT MAKES A GOOD SHORT STORY?  WITH DETAILED REFERENCES TO THE STORIES YOU HAVE READ FROM THE NINETEENTH CENTURY, EXPLAIN WHAT HAS INTERESTED YOU.

I have studied three different nineteenth century short stories.  These are ‘The Signalman’, ‘The Red Room’ and ‘The Stolen Bacillus’.  Both ‘The Red Room’ and ‘The Stolen Bacillus’ were written by H.G. Wells and ‘The Signalman’ by Charles Dickens.

  All three of these stories are very detailed and traditional with their long and complicated words.  The best aspect of these short stories was their genre which, was a mystery and I find that mysterious stories always make me want to read on because I want to know what’s going to happen.

  Short stories are effective because they get straight to the point and are quick to read.  Out of these stories, I found that they all have a similar plot in the way that they all have a sense of danger or warnings in them.  For example, in ‘The Red Room’ the old people try to warn off this man from entering the red room because it’s supposed to have some sort of fear in it.  Then, in ‘The Signalman’ a signalman keeps seeing a spectre before something terrible happens and so the spectre he sees is trying to warn the Signalman that something’s going to happen and as we find out, this spectre is trying to warn him of his own fatal death.  “Signalman killed this morning, Sir...”

  In ‘The Stolen Bacillus’, the Anarchist wants to create havoc and danger by trying to spread a fatal disease called Asiastic Cholera around the world.

“...the little tube that contained such vast possibilities of destruction gripped in his hand.”

  The atmosphere in these short stories are very similar in their own way, by the fact that they are gloomy and they have a sense of danger in them. ‘The Red Room’ is very scary and eerie.  It makes the reader feel uneasy.

“Long, draughty subterranean passage was chilly and dusty.”  It gives an uneasy, mysterious presence and the story seems to get scarier as it progresses.

Join now!

“The echoes rang up and down the spiral staircase...” The red room is also separate from all the other rooms around the castle and this adds to isolation.

  In ‘The Signalman’ it has the same sort of gloominess and terror around it.

“Barbarous, depressing, and forbidding air...”

  There is tension between the characters as they start to bond and they are wary of each other.

“I was doubtful,” he returned, “whether I had seen you before.”  This shows us that the Signalman is very cautious and afraid of his visitor.  He thinks he has seen the visitor before ...

This is a preview of the whole essay