• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What makes Romeo and Juliet a tragedy, and who or what is responsible for it?

Extracts from this document...


What makes Romeo and Juliet a tragedy, and who or what is responsible for it? By Michael Taubman The story of Romeo and Juliet has been around for many years. The earliest version of the story first appeared in 1476. In 1530 Luigi da Porto set the tragedy in Verona and Matteo added a few characters in 1554 along with the plot. Then in 1562 Arthur Brooke translated it into English, which became a long, narrative poem titled 'Romeo and Juliet' and is recognized as being Shakespeare's primary source of his play. The story has been and always will be classed as a tragedy, though some critics argue that Romeo and Juliet is not a true tragedy in the strictest definition of 'tragedy'. They believe tragedy comes from a flaw in the characters unlike Romeo and Juliet, which is more a tragedy of fate as it was the circumstances around them which caused the tragic ending, i.e the feud between the two houses. The beginning of the play 'the prologue' speaks directly to the audience by the chorus. The prologue reveals the essence of the plot in a fourteen-line sonnet. The tragedy we are told involves a pair of ill-fated lovers or 'star-crossed lovers' who will end the long and bitter feud raging between their families by their deaths. The prologue begins with the line 'two households, both alike in dignity' which shows that each of the two houses are equal in nobility and states that the feud rages between two families. Also on line 6 it refers to Romeo and Juliet as 'star-crossed lovers'. ...read more.


I believe the Nurse agrees to be Juliet's messenger because she sees how much Juliet loves Romeo and wants her to be happy. Although she wants Juliet to be happy (act 2 scene 5) the Nurse begins to tease Juliet not telling her what Romeo has said. This is probably only because she is excited as well and just wants to see the look on Juliet's face. Later on in the play, when Romeo kills Tybalt and is banished, the Nurse seems to take side with Tybalt most probably because he is part of the family and she raised him like she is with Juliet. Although she doesn't take Tybalt's side entirely, she still blames Romeo for what happened, and then men in general, 'no faith, no honesty in men all perjured'. In act 3 scene 5 the Nurse tells Juliet to marry the County Paris even though she knows Juliet is already married to Romeo. This would be because Juliet's father had told Juliet that she was to marry Paris and in those days girls often married their parents choice of husband. Although this would take suspicion off her and Romeo, during this scene the Nurse does protect Juliet from her father but this completely fools the Nurse, as Juliet has changed not even obeying her own father. In act 3 scene 5 line 239 it marks the end of the relationship between Juliet and the Nurse, as now she has to depend upon herself. The Nurse was a great help for Juliet and was always there for her during the play, but during some parts she could have behaved differently. ...read more.


It begins with the servants fighting which is remarkable as they aren't blood related but still fight for their name. Then Benvolio and Tybalt enter the 'next stage up' from the servants. And finally the 'big guns' of the feud enter Old Capulet and Old Montague each only wanting to fight one another. To me this seems similar to Roman war, the leaders of each army were only properly suited to fight the opposite leader, and anyone else would be too easy. I say this, as the feud appears to 'spark up' at the Capulet Ball between Romeo and Tybalt but Old Capulet doesn't really seem bothered of Romeos presence as he only wishes to fight with Old Montague. To conclude, it's in my eyes that the cause for the tragic end to Romeo and Juliet can be mostly put on the feud between the two houses. It's this feud that caused the death of Tybalt, Mercution, Paris, Romeo and Juliet, as had there been no controversy between these people none would have been slayed by one another. Romeo and Juliet has to be one of the most famous romantic tragedies of all times. But Shakespeare's play could not have been so tragic with the feud and characters action because of the feud, such as Friar Laurence's plan of Juliet faking her own death. This plot would have never come about had it not been because of the feud, the fight between Romeo and Tybalt, which resulted in Romeo's banishment. The feud didn't really affect Old Capulet's marriage arrangement for Juliet and Paris, but had there been no feud then Juliet could have told her parents of her love for Romeo earlier and with no fear of being told she could never see him. . ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Romeo and Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Romeo and Juliet essays

  1. Romeo & Juliet.

    I don�t think that Mercutio� s loss was that important to Lord Montague and Lady Montague as Romeos death was. The endings to both stories made the plot and play understandable to the audience with the speech at the end and of course when the two families settled their differences and made peace.

  2. To what extent do you consider Friar Laurence to be responsible for the tragedy ...

    Conversely, this illustrates his acumen and shows that he cares for Romeo's well being, and this also could be perceived as him having genuine intentions, since he was imparting advice. With Friar Laurence's hypocrisy it could be argued that he did not provide a role model for Romeo as his pretence would have been confusing.

  1. Romeo and Juliet. Discuss the behaviour of Lord Capulet and consider his attitude, and ...

    The two families, Montagues and Capulets, had many problems. There was hate between the two families so much so that even the servants hated each other. This feud would have caused many problems for Romeo and Juliet: These two young lovers knew this and this is why they kept their marriage a secret.

  2. Starting with Act 2 Scene 3 how far do you think Friar Lawrence is ...

    Inequality is also shown is some scenes where Juliet is present, as she is treated as a victim throughout the play. Later on in this scene, Friar Lawrence starts to advise Romeo what to do next. Shakespeare could have shown Friar Lawrence like this, as he sees Romeo like a

  1. Who is to blame for the tragic death of Romeo and Juliet, The Nurse ...

    The nurse also was to blame as she also agreed with the marriage, as she wanted Juliet to be very happy. Although her happiness, also was to blame for this tragic end to their lives. The mistakes that she made was that she kept visiting Romeo and sending him messages from Juliet.

  2. Are Romeo And Juliet Responsible For Their Own Demise

    Because it is an enemy to thee." He further says that he would abandon the name if he had written it; "Had I written, I would tear the word". The word 'tear' is used for personification (on 'word') to allow us to envision how Romeo will actually go about in

  1. Romeo & Juliet - Who is responsible inMaking the play a tragedy.

    This is how deep the feud is. We also know how deep the feud runs. Tybalt is Juliet's cousin but he still detests the Montagues as much as any of the Capulet's family. He definitely does not hide his true feelings about the feud.

  2. What caused the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet?

    Balthasar informs him of Juliet?s supposed death, and Romeo?s reply strongly blames fate ?Is it even so? Then I defy you, stars!? Romeo?s exclamation symbolises his hatred for fate, as he forcibly curses his destiny. He is expressing his self-reliance by saying that he alone is in charge of his

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work