Which is the more effective of the supernatural stories of "The Signalman" and "The Red Room"

Authors Avatar

Which is the more effective of the supernatural stories of “The Signalman” and “The Red Room”

Ghost stories in general need to have certain key features if they are to work effectively. The most important factor is that there needs to be a supernatural element. A well-written ghost story needs to be mysterious with mood and atmosphere. There also needs to be suspense so that the reader will continue to the end to find the solution to the ghostly mystery. In this essay I will discuss the effectiveness of ‘The Signalman’ as a ghost story.

The Signalman is a well-constructed, atmospheric piece, about a gentleman who meets a Signalman. The Signalman tells him about a supernatural figure who appears to him at the mouth of the tunnel just before any disaster is about to occur. The narrator’s dilemma when he hears the Signalman’s unexplained account leads to an exciting ending that keeps the reader’s attention. Supernatural figures are a key element required in a ghost story and as stated there is a supernatural figure involved in ‘The Signalman’ “… ‘I, standing at the door, looked towards the red light and saw the spectre again.’ He stopped with a fixed look at me.” This tells us that the Signalman is very anxious of the spectre because the narrator says that the signalman stopped with a fixed look at him. This also suggests that he froze in what he was doing and was reliving the event as a daydream.  The supernatural figures are needed in a ghost story otherwise the story would become horror or mystery. The writer describes the fearful anxiety of the Signalman on seeing the spectre and this prompts fear in the reader. Charles Dickens used supernatural figures to keep questions being inquired in the readers’ mind, and he maintains the supernatural figure as a extra character and makes the supernatural figure appear when the reader is least expecting it. When he does this it makes the reader think: Why is the supernatural figure here? As well as this the reader may also link the idea of supernatural figures to a murder or death of a major character, this creates suspense because the reader wonders where the murder or death is going to happen and the reader will want to read to the end of the story to find out who died. He builds tension by revealing information slowly.

Join now!

On the first visit we feel there is something troubling the Signalman but reader is made to wait. The three mysterious encounters are then revealed but there is suspense because the ghost has appeared again and we are waiting for the next tragedy to happen.

The atmosphere in ‘The Signalman’ is generally set in the first few pages. This is done by adding an variety of adjectives to the text, and at the same time keeping the story short. A few cases of this are: “solitary and dismal place; excluding all view but a strip of sky; great dungeon; barbarous; ...

This is a preview of the whole essay