• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Who is the Greater Villain Macbeth Or Lady Macbeth?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Jermaine Maynard-Brown English Mr Cummings Tuesday 30th July 2002 'Macbeth' Who is the Greater Villain Macbeth Or Lady Macbeth? Assignment Details: - Compare the characters of Macbeth and lady Macbeth and say who for dramatic purposes is the greater villain. I believe that Macbeth is the great villain but Lady Macbeth is greater than he. This is because she is pure evil and very persuasive as she is able to influence and force Macbeth into killing his friend and King Duncan. In order for the prophecies made by the three weird sisters in the beginning of the play (when they say that Macbeth shall become King, Thane of Cawdor and Glamis) would happen a lot quicker than they should have done. Macbeth and Lady Macbeth have an argument, where Lady Macbeth contradicts his villainous character and integrity by calling him weak minded because he refuses to Kill Duncan. Yet, she still manages to persuade and corrupt him into killing the king, proving that through her evil-mindedness she is able to convince a loyal soldier into killing the King. It is clear from their character profiles and the play that Lady Macbeth is manlier than her husband at heart and is prepared to do anything to get what she wants in life even if it means murder. ...read more.

Middle

Macbeth appears to be unstable; there is clear evidence that he loses nerves and focus under pressure. For a soldier like him this shouldn't be normal behaviour. This can be seen in his attitude when he goes to kill Duncan and when he sees Banquo's ghost at the banquet. Macbeth truly loves his wife in his own way. When he finds out, she is dead he feels regret and remorseful, showing true love and emotion for his wife. Lady Macbeth is an independent woman of great strength who easily takes charge of a situation. She is in charge of her own life and often Macbeth's life. Lady Macbeth is willing to do most things, including kill her king and frame his guards, in order to advance her husband's future and become Queen of Scotland. Lady Macbeth is both strong and manipulative, in order to get her own way. She proves this when she convinces Macbeth into killing Duncan. It was her plan; she framed the guards and finished the job when Macbeth lost his nerves. I think that she holds the power behind the crown. I also think that she should be the Monarch of Scotland because she has great leadership qualities. The audience's image of her changes when her guilt starts to take over and she regrets the actions that she and Macbeth have taken. ...read more.

Conclusion

On the other hand Macbeth appears to be stronger minded than he actually is. In actual fact he is a weak minded individual who has no control over his life. He would have made a very lousy king; he couldn't even keep rule over his wife let alone the entire population of Scotland. Thus he couldn't possibly be the greater villain. He might have killed Duncan and had Banquo killed but this shows nothing. He couldn't even do the job properly when it came to killing Duncan; Lady Macbeth had to go back and frame the guards. If Macbeth were truly a great villain, he would've killed Banquo himself. He knew that he wouldn't be able to cope with the burden on his head so he hired two murderers to do it for him. He could just about cope with killing Duncan. The dagger that he used to kill Duncan haunted him before the job was done; he couldn't cope with having Banquo killed. Macbeth is definitely too weak to murder unless he is coerced into doing it. Moreover the man was too weak to say no to his villainous wife. Lady Macbeth is definitely more evil than Macbeth because she called on evil spirits to make her manlier so that she could kill Duncan. She convinced Macbeth to kill Duncan; she planned the assassination from the moment she heard the prophecy. Evidently, lady Macbeth is the greater villain with Macbeth at her side. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Macbeth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Macbeth essays

  1. Is Lady Macbeth the villain of the play?

    that Lady Macbeth helps Macbeth to overcome his feelings of guilt and insecurity. At the banquet, Lady Macbeth again proves to be a very good actress as she welcomes the guests with a friendly smile and she then covers up Macbeth's strange behaviour with a convincing story.

  2. Macbeth - Victim or Villain?

    Lady Macbeth uses his desire to be king against him: "was the hope drunk". We notice from this that Lady Macbeth is the main reason why her husband kills the king because she attacks his manhood and destroys his ambition to become king without killing someone: "to be more than

  1. Macbeth: Hero or Villain?

    But to Macbeth's horror Banquo's Ghost appeared. This caused Macbeth to make quite a scene, as no one else could see him. In Act 4, Scene 1, Macbeth goes to fins the witches, when he does he demands answers from them. The witches ask if he want to hear it from them or from the higher powers.

  2. Macbeth: Is he a hero or a villain?

    This leads to his downfall and he thinks he is safe, 'The spirits that know all mortal consequences have pronounced me thus.' Macbeth thinks that the witches' apparitions mean he is safe and this is what he wants to believe.

  1. Who was the driving force behind the murdur of duncan?

    'fair' is also used here to describe the appearance of the predictions, where as before it was to show fair things may not be as they seem, this could be used to hint that there is a negative side to these predictions.

  2. Do you believe that Macbeth is a complete villain or does he have some ...

    He is in a way more interested. His attitude to the witches is strange as he is eager to know what happens to Macbeth. He wants the witches to predict into the future. "...Look into the seeds of time," suggests this. But unlike Macbeth, Banquo dismisses the witches and is not 'rapt'.

  1. Do you believe that Macbeth is a complete villain, or does he have some ...

    This happens because Shakespeare emphasised Duncan's respect for Macbeth, with Duncan saying such things as "worthiest" whilst addressing Macbeth. However, as Macbeth later on in the story kills Duncan, this belies his true political intention of power seeking, and perhaps not solely of his own volition, but driven by his wife's ambitious self-interest.

  2. “Do you believe that Macbeth is a complete villain or does he have some ...

    attract bad, as so, because Banquo is such a good man them Macbeth must also be one. When Macbeth and Banquo meet the witches they are both very bold and courageous. They are also very confident. When they tell Macbeth the second prophesy Macbeth appears to be scared.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work