• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Who is to blame for the tragic deaths of the twins in Willy Russell's 'Blood Brothers'?

Extracts from this document...


Who is to blame for the tragic deaths of the twins in Willy Russell's 'Blood Brothers'? Blood Brothers, a story of twins separated at birth, growing up in completely different environments, but with the same genetic composition, "never knowing that they shared one name, 'till the day they died, when a mother cried, my own dear sons lie slain", is a compelling story of which we will discuss in detail, of who is to blame for their tragic deaths. There are many character in 'Blood Brothers', which can be blamed for the tragic deaths; Mrs.Lyons, the rich, devious woman, Mrs.Johnstone, the under-privileged mother of eight, Sammy, Mickey's brother and his influence, and even superstition and fate. First of all, we will discuss the case of Mrs.Lyons, a vindictive, manipulative woman who has a caring side to her, for the desperation of the love for a child. Indeed she did start all of this deception, by offering to take one of Mrs. Johnstone's baby's and lying to Mrs.Johnstone that she could see her child everyday. She also lied to her husband that the child was theirs and not an adopted baby (as Mr.Lyons hated the fact of adopting children). ...read more.


Did Mrs. Johnstone say this to protect Edward, her son, or did she just have to let out the truth, after so many years, which she could hide no longer, resulting inadvertently in both deaths?! We can now discuss a background character, Sammy, older brother of Mickey, as a potential, capable character of blame. Sammy, vehemently forced Mickey into a 'job', and Mickey accepted because he was desperately in need for money. Thus leading to Mickey getting caught, and being put into prison. If Sammy hadn't forced Mickey to take the 'job', Mickey would not have been in this situation that he faced, and may not have let all of anger out on Edward, when released from prison. Sammy also influenced Mickey, as a child, and Mickey looked up to him as a role-model. This may have been the cause of the twins deaths, establishing that if Sammy had not influenced Mickey into crime and shooting at an earlier age, then Mickey may have not wanted to or would have thought of shooting Edward, "Y' don't get up again if one of these hits y'...it's not a toy y'know (referring to the gun)". ...read more.


Her actions, her rudeness to others, her lying, her cruelty of separating twins all confirm that she was indeed the main 'devil' of the play. "You gave your baby away. Don't you realize what a crime that is. You'll be locked up. You sold your baby." Mrs.Lyons acted in the play, as though she could control everyone around her, which she did manage to achieve, as she controlled Mrs.Johnstone, lying to her that she could see her baby every day, to her husband, by showing others, such as Mickey, what would potentially harm them, or make them feel jealous or hateful, without realizing the consequences of her actions, and what she had done to others, even her own son. She had lied to her own son about who he really was, which I believe to be a very horrid act. Another and the most important reason I believe that she is to blame for the deaths, is the fact that she started all of the treachery and betrayal in the play, which led to many more fraudulent things, and the death of her son. I believe that if she had not started all of this, then no-one would be dead, no-one hurt, and no-one guilty. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Blood Brothers section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Blood Brothers essays

  1. GCSE Drama Review of 'Blood Brothers' by Willy Russell.

    and Eddy replies: "Adolph Hitler"! So you can see that Eddy could be brave, even more so than Mickey and Linda, he just needed to be let out of his shell. Eddy's lexis was a lot different to Mickey's as he used words like 'smashing' and 'goodness'; whereas most of Mickey's lexis consisted of swear words.

  2. "And do we blame superstition for what came to pass? Or could it be ...

    the gynaecologist tells her that she is expecting twins when she can only just cope with the amount of children that she has. This also justifies how the shoes on the table were unlucky for her, Mrs Johnstone says "If I'm careful we can just scrape, by even with another mouth to feed."

  1. Blood Brothers interview with Willy Russell

    Lyons there is an incredible class difference. On one hand, you have Mrs. Lyons who can give a baby everything money can buy. On the other hand, however, you have Mrs. Johnston who is making up excuses to not pay the milkman; for the Johnston family life is a real struggle.

  2. Blood Brothers

    Both these quotes show that Edward is childish. By contrast, it shows that Mickey is mature because in the scene he does not look amused. The reason why Edward acts like a child is again because of class. He is from an upper-class lifestyle which allows him to still act

  1. Blood Brothers. In the play we see that Mrs Johnstones life totally contrasts with ...

    We are told this when the narrator says " during the song Mrs Johnstone has gone to her house and locked herself in" she does this because the song is going on about "the devil" and the rent man is after her for her rent.

  2. Blood brothers - Willy Russell writes entertaining drama and champions the socially disadvantaged

    we have her mistake her son knocking at the door for one with her screaming, "go away!" to the person. Meanwhile we see on page 18 how Mrs. Lyons without hesitation asks for fifty pounds (which considering that era was a lot of money)

  1. The German Job

    those two lads had been inquiring about a job and where talking to Jim about any openings, who was going to phone them the next morning about whether they could work for him. So if it hadn't been for us turning up when we did and telling him about wanting

  2. Who or what is to blame for the tragedy in blood brothers?

    there never bloody well is." The language shown here is an example of how the kids have learnt to grow up, and taught. But also it shows how deprived and unfortunate the family really is.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work