• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Who or what is to blame for the tragedy in blood brothers?

Extracts from this document...


Coursework: Who or what is to blame for the tragedy in blood brothers? Blood brothers is more than a tale of twin brothers separated at birth, yet destined to reunite as closest friends - despite radically different upbringings and ignorance of their relations. It's equally the tale of two mothers with totally different kind of motherly love, one unselfishly giving and accepting (Mrs. Johnstone) and the other obsessive, stifling and ultimately destructive (Mrs. Lyons). Fertile Mrs. Johnstone, financially needy but willingly spirited and open hearted, is already the abandoned mother of a passel of kids when she finds herself pregnant with twins. Though she's counted each shilling so as to make ends meet on her maid's wage with one more mouth to feed, she's forced to give one twin away to her wealthy barren employer Mrs. Lyons who fakes pregnancy, telling no one the truth of the true origin of her new, longed for son Edward (not even her mogul husband). Many factors play a big part in the final scene between the brothers. The main one being the contrasts in class. The twins are genetically alike but as far as their lives are concerned they are too different to tell their relations. ...read more.


The lack of the father figure in the Johnstone household can make the discipline of the children uncontrollable and of a very low level. Mrs. L however, is happily married and has a son, which she has always wanted. She only has one child which is not hers. This shows the difference in maternal control between the two women. The Lyons family is well off and have no financial worries and can afford to buy things cash in hand instead of on the "never never". The language is also of some contrast: "Pissed off. You say smashing things don't you? Do you know any more words like that?" This shows how the influence of the parents has played a big part in the lives of their children. Edward hears a regularly spoken swear word but yet fails to recognize what it actually means, also he speaks grammatically correct and speaks every letter. Whereas Mickey teaches the swear words to Eddie and speaks a lot off slang and does so infront of his mother who does not show an ounce of bother. Mrs. J works as a cleaner for Mrs. L and makes just enough to get by. ...read more.


The narrator is constantly reminded us of the dangers of acting like Mrs.J is and its as if she is destined to suffer from what happens in the last scene. The narrator is referring to the devil being after Mrs.J all the time and this shows that no matter what she does it will never be to satisfaction that she is doomed.mrs.L is not superstitious but manipulates Mrs.J's beliefs and says that the twins must never find the truth just so she can protect herself. In all honesty I believe that the main reason for the tragedy is the divide in class. As a result of the contrast in class, both twins suffer from different upbringings and jealousy which leads to the final devastation. The great differences between the alike characters lead to problems in society, they end up in trouble with the police, both liking the same girl, both move as a result of knowing each other. These all contribute to the two innocent lives. If I was to place the blame on anyone it would be the two mothers, as they made the promise to accept n receive the child and promise to keep the secret in the first place if they never kept them apart from each other and the truth then the shoot out would not have been even considered. BY CLAIRE SCOTT 10T ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Blood Brothers section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Blood Brothers essays

  1. Blood Brothers Coursework

    The main element showing class divide is the uniforms that Mickey and Eddie wear at the beginning of the play when they are young. The Lyons family present themselves as very well educated because they wear nice clothes therefore they are well off as they can afford better quality, indicating

  2. And do we blame Superstition for what we come to pass? Or could it ...

    The next time we see the twins, Mickey and Edward, is when they are aged seven. Some people think seven is a lucky number so superstition is covertly making an appearance again. Mickey starts playing near the park and the expensive houses where Edward lives so Mrs Johnstone tells Mickey

  1. Blood Brothers Coursework

    When they first meet the language differences are highlighted. Mickey: ....."because I'm pissed off". Eddie (awed) "Pissed off! You say smashing things, don't you?" Mickey says things like pissed off and he later says 'the F word'. He doesn't know what they mean but has probably heard them being said

  2. What is a hero? In this essay I will be discussing three short stories ...

    We are then left wondering - will Lassie come to his rescue? Will the narrator be able to yell for help? These questions are soon answered, as the narrator raises his voice and cries out for the dog. The dog does come, but not without hesitation.

  1. My Mother Said I Never Should - response.

    Doris is a lot like the grandmother in the first half of the role-play and Rosie is a lot like the granddaughter in the second half of the role-play. The same theme in our role-plays were also reflected from the play because the same scenarios occur within the play itself, for example, when Doris reflects on her life with Rosie.

  2. 'Street Scene' was written by Elmer Rice and exploits the values of a Catholic ...

    But then I went into the house and seen little Willie, his eyes glazed with fresh tears, staring at the ceiling. He brought it all home to me that I couldn't go without him... Rose looks at her watch. Time went by, I suppose I waited for three or four

  1. Who is to blame for the tragic deaths of the twins in Willy Russell's ...

    Johnstone to move away, with thousands. We notice here that when Mrs.Lyons becomes desperate, she is willing to give up thousands, just so her son would never find out who his real mother is. The last point affecting Mrs.Lyons case is that which we could consider as the most important,

  2. Who was most responsible for the tragedy that occurred at the end of Blood ...

    Act one page. 15 "don't tell me which one, just take him!" The second reason that I blame Mrs Johnstone for the wicked tragedy that took place at the end of blood brothers is, that she gave Edward a locket with a picture of Mickey and herself in it just

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work