• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

WHY DO YOU THINK THAT SOURCES I & J DIFFER ABOUT THE BATTLE OF THE SOMME? Sources I and J are both written by Lloyd George, the first when he was 'Secretary for War'

Extracts from this document...


WHY DO YOU THINK THAT SOURCES I & J DIFFER ABOUT THE BATTLE OF THE SOMME? Sources I and J are both written by Lloyd George, the first when he was 'Secretary for War' in 1916 and the second after his retirement in the 1930's in-between of which he was of course he was the British Priminister who signed the peace treaties following the first world war. If one looks at source I first, the obvious thing you notice is that it is a very small source as its only an extract of two sentences from a letter he wrote to Field Marshal Haig on the 21st September after visiting the battlefield. George is very congratulatory of the progress that was been made and plaudits the tactics that Haig has been using 'news of the last few days has confirmed our hopes that the tide has now definitely turned in our favour' and 'I congratulate you most warmly on the skill with which your plans were laid'. ...read more.


Source J shows the Battle of the Somme in a totally different light, albeit around a 20 years difference between George first wrote about the Battle of the Somme and the second time in his war memoirs, but nevertheless there is a marked change in George's opinion towards the tactics that were employed and the overall success of the battle. In actual fact this source is a total contradiction to the previous source as it says 'I travelled the front from Verdun to Ypres' and then goes on to say how he 'expressed my doubts to General Haig as to whether cavalry could ever operate successfully on a front bristling for miles with barbed wire and machine guns'. In source I he says after visiting the battlefield he 'congratulates' 'the skill with which your plans were laid' which shows a total contradiction to his other account of the battle, this isn't the only contradiction, source I says how the tide has tuned where as J says 'This offensive was a failure' and 'it killed far more of our best'. ...read more.


The content of J could still of been what he thought when he wrote I but without wanting to dent morale he curbed his feelings for the battle in the hope it would be the best thing to do in the long run. Another probably more unlikely possibility, could be that George was just fickle and changed his view of the battle to suit public opinion which was critical of the Battle of the Somme and the General who put so many men to the slaughter. These two sources show such a large contradiction it is fair to deem there must be a major reason or reasons for George to show such a large contradiction between his initial thoughts of the battle and Haig to his afterthoughts of them. Although it is still possible that both sources may still be truthful to some extent, it is just that in source I especially he gave a false picture for the benefit of the country, even if the true picture may have been much different, not just to make him self look good. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE War Poetry essays

  1. Was the Battle of the Somme a success or a failure?

    It also doesnt tell us when he said or wrote this. But what it does tell us is that he doesnt believe Haigs plan was good and he doesnt think alot of Douglas Haig. This is a article published by The Daily Chronicle on the 3rd July which is explaining the events of the first day of the battle.

  2. How do the poets of After Blenheim by Robert Southey and The Hyenas written ...

    If they can dig up the bodies they can feast and thrive without having to work too hard in the process as the dead can't fight back. He uses imagery about the natural world in comparing the fight that even the weakest creatures will put up against a hyena attack 'For a goat may butt, and a worm may sting'.

  1. To What Extent Was the Battle of the Somme a Disaster.

    So if you think of it like that the Battle of the Somme was the battle, which prevented the Germans from winning the war. Other positive points are that many of the mission objectives were completed, for example the village of Pozieres was captured and the British did gain land from the Germans.

  2. The Battle of Passchendaele (The Third Battle of Ypres)

    Many small attacks were made to try and, "improve the line" before Gough's main attack was carried out. However, the Germans had other ideas for the battle. They launched their counter attacks to try and regain the Inverness Copse area.

  1. The battle of the Somme - This analysis is to debate whether or not ...

    This source could be reliable because of his first hand knowledge of it, but it could still be inaccurate. Because it is his own opinion of the instructions to "cross no man's land at a slow pace" he could be biased and could have given incorrect information.

  2. Pre 1914 War Poetry - The Drum and Drummer Hodge analysed.

    The poem's first two lines are referring to the innocence and youth of the man whos died, and also the disrespect shown towards him. 'Drummer Hodge' indicates his youth in two ways; the drummers in the army are usually the youngest in the group, and also, 'Hodge' is a generic, colloquial name for a young country labourer.

  1. The popular myth of the Battle of Britain quickly emerged during the early part ...

    We do know that he was the best-known British historian of the second part of the twentieth century. This writing is reliable and useful. The last interpretation that I am going to evaluate is an article entitled 'The Battle of Britain-her finest hour or Hitler's greatest hoax', by Christopher Ray, in 'history review' March 1997, written for A-level students.

  2. The Battle of Britain

    This can be seen on Battle of Britain day September 15th when with only 150 planes and fuel running out they managed to shoot down more planes than they had ever before. Other factors are not mentioned such as leadership and tactical mistakes.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work