• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

With which of the two murderers do you feel sympathy for in the short stories, "The Tell Tale Heart" by Edgar Allen Poe and "Confessions found In a Prison" by Charles Dickens?

Extracts from this document...


With which of the two murderers do you feel sympathy for in the short stories, "The Tell Tale Heart" by Edgar Allen Poe and "Confessions found In a Prison" by Charles Dickens? My essay will consist of the themes of the two short stories and background information on the authors who were living at the Victorian time, now seen as classical writers. Edgar Allen Poe was born January 19th 1809 in Boston. He was an American short story writer, poet, critic, and editor. He is famous in all of these traits for his cultivation of mystery and macabre writing. The atmosphere is his tales of horror is unrivalled in American fiction. After his mother died in Richmond, in 1811, he was taken into the home of John Allan, a Richmond merchant (presumably his godfather), and his childless wife. He was later taken to Scotland and England (1815-20), where he was given a classical education that was continued in Richmond. His gambling losses at the university incensed his guardian that he refused to let him continue, and Poe returned to Richmond to find his sweetheart, (Sarah) Elmira Royster, engaged. Poe made a name as a critical reviewer and married his young cousin Virginia Clemm, who was only 13. Poe seems to have been an affectionate husband and son-in-law. Poe was dismissed from his job in Richmond, apparently for drinking, and went to New York City. Drinking was in fact to be the bane of his life. To talk well in large company he needed a slight stimulant, but a glass of sherry might start him on a spree; and, although he rarely succumbed to intoxication, he was often seen in public when he did. ...read more.


The motives of the two murderers were different and similar in particular ways. In "The Tell Tale Heart" the assassin was disturbed by the evil eyes of the old man that was an image of a vulture. In "Confessions found In a Prison" the murderer was greedy and jealous because his wife seemed to love his nephew as her own child, the memory of his brother's wife's eyes lived in the little boy's eye in particular, which he inherited. I think there is a lot of evidence as to why the murderer was completely mad in "The Tell Tale Heart" The narrator was simply trying so hard to convince the reader that he/she was not mad, for example "but why will you say that I am mad" or the line "would a mad man have been so wise as this?" this clearly shows that the narrator is trying to convince the reader of his sanity. The repetitiveness and the use of phrases of how a mad man should be keeps relating to themes of madness. The narrator also uses speech, involving the readers by asking questions, e.g. "Would a mad man have been so wise as this?" The killer says in the first paragraph that he/she loved the old man. The killer didn't have any grudges against him, and he had never wronged the narrator. The only thing that came in the way of all of these opinions was that the narrator was haunted by the old man's eye. Such stupid, mad and negative thoughts took the life of an innocent man. ...read more.


The twist at the end of this story fascinated me, and gave effectiveness to the whole story. It was intelligently written. The ending wasn't obvious, and kept you guessing to the very end. I didn't expect the killer in "The Tell Tale Heart" to rip up the floor boards because of all of the hard work and preparation that the killer went through to cover up the crime scene. I took a great interest In the way the narrator was portrayed at the end, when the police inspectors arrived. The killer put on an innocent and relaxed facial expression, just in-case suspicion occurred with the officers. His or her voice tones were transformed into calm, relaxing tones, and the body language is conveyed greatly by the description from the author. The body language was altered depending on the situation to avoid suspicion. The reaction at the end was unexpected, but I could sense a twist building up in the writing. The coincidental visit from the police, and the dramatic confession of the killer was very amusing for me to read. In conclusion, Although I believe that neither of the murderers deserve sympathy, I feel remote pity for both murderers, in the fact that they were mentally unstable, and the knowledge of their crime tore at them until it drove them to confess all. I believe that this does equate for a slight sympathetic vote to go to the killer who showed the most emotion, and regret. I therefore would say I felt the most sympathy for the killer in "The Tell Tale Heart". Steven Morris Page 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Edgar Allan Poe section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Edgar Allan Poe essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    How does Edgar A. Poe build up suspense and tension in The Cask of ...

    3 star(s)

    He argues against this and shows his trowel as a sign of being a mason. Whether Montresor is faking it, joking, or is actually a mason, we never find out. If he is though, there could be an underlying story there, but since we never find out it just adds

  2. How does the writer create suspense in the Tell Tale Heart?

    Finally, he uses a lot of punctuation throughout the whole story giving a good result. Next, Poe uses first person because it lets the reader see the story from the murderer's point of view. This makes the story more interesting, as you can find out all the feelings and emotions of the murderer along the way.

  1. How does Edgar Allen Poe create an atmosphere of suspense and tension in The ...

    For example in "The Tell-Tale Heart" when it says "but you should have seen me". This shows us how great he thinks he is and how he considers himself not mad. In "The Black Cat" the use of "GALLOWS" stands out because it is written in capitals and because he is facing the gallows now.

  2. tension and suspense of the tell tale heart

    Poe uses lots of words that represent horror such as "hell" and "blood" these words are adjectives and are used to describe things such as " the hellish tatoo of the heart."

  1. How does Edgar Allan Poe keep the reader in suspence in 'The Tell tale ...

    this sentence he empathises the word 'cautiously' he does this to get the point across to the reader of how cautiously he undid the lantern. Another example of when Poe uses repetitiveness is when he says 'louder--louder--louder!' this really empathises the heartbeat, and how loud it is and how it

  2. Compare and Contrast "The Tell Tale Heart" by Edgar Allan Poe and "A Confession ...

    This shows that something is going to be confessed in the near future. Both authors use short sentences at the beginnings of their stories. They use this writing technique to build tension. This is shown better in the 'The Tell-Tale Heart,' line 15 where he starts of the paragraph with three sentences in the first line.

  1. Compare and contrast the narrative techniques used in three or more of Edgar Allan ...

    For example it is very clear to the reader Montresor's hate towards Fortunato plus his determination for vengeance. The antagonist in "The Cask of Amontillado" is Fortunato, as he fights for his life and is the opposition of the protagonist.

  2. Ways Edgar Allen Poe created Tension in the"Tell Tale Heart".

    be extremely quiet to hear such a small sound and we are then unsure if the old man will hear it and wake up. The narrator also hears the beating of the old man?s heart just before the murder and described it as a ?low, dull, quick sound?.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work