• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Write a comparative analysis of 'Shall I compare thee...' by William Shakespeare and 'The Flea' by John Donne from the Best Words anthology.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Write a comparative analysis of 'Shall I compare thee...' by William Shakespeare and 'The Flea' by John Donne from the Best Words anthology. 'Shall I compare thee...' by Shakespeare focuses on romantic love, whereas Donne's poem, 'The Flea' is all about seduction and sexual love. The situations in the two poems are very different. In 'Shall I compare thee...', the poet is shown as a lover who is addressing his lady. His tone is gentle and romantic. He starts with a rhetorical question to which he must answer and therefore he does not put demand upon the lady. The poem gives the impression that it is set perhaps in his room, where he is composing his poem. One thing is for sure and that is that the woman he is addressing is not with him, because all the way through the poem, there is no response from her. Shakespeare wants to emphasize her beauty. In 'The Flea' the poet is directly appealing to the woman or his mistress. They seem to be in bed together with a flea, but no sex seems to have taken place. If it had, then the situation would be very different. The poet has seduced her as far as the bedroom and at this point, it seems as though he is going to try a new strategy. The woman does not appear to be very keen and is resisting his advances. ...read more.

Middle

However, the poet uses her triumph in his own favour. He says that since nothing has happened due to the killing of the flea, then surely nothing would happen if she were to give in to him. She would not lose "so much honour". Syllogism is also used in 'To His Coy Mistress" by Andrew Marvell. Marvell is also trying to get the woman in the poem to have sex with him. He firstly argues that if they had all the time they wanted, they could progress their relationship slowly. He goes on to say that time isn't in their hands and then finally argues that, because of the situation, they should make the most of their time, and therefore have sex now. In 'The Flea', Donne uses the flea as the structure of his argument, however Marvell uses time to link the poem and his argument. Marvell uses other things in his argument to convince the woman in his poem. He uses the idea of space, by talking about the rivers "Ganges" and "Humber". He is trying to say that if they had all the space they wanted, they could let their relationship develop slowly. The poet also uses words associated with death, such as "grave" and "ashes", to convince the woman to have sex with him before it is too late. 'The Flea' is a battle of logical argument between the man and the woman. ...read more.

Conclusion

The rhyming couplet concludes the poem and signals the end. The metre used is iambic pentameter, which includes five stressed, and five unstressed syllables for every line. Shakespeare does appear to use a three-part argument, but it is not as apparent is in 'The Flea'. Shakespeare firstly argues whether he should or should not compare the woman to a summer's day. He secondly argues how imperfect a summer's day is unlike her. Lastly, he argues that as long as this poem survives, her celebrated beauty will survive as well. 'The Flea' has a regular rhyme scheme of aabbccdd, which gives it a regular rhythm. This poem is a mixture of pentameter, which are ten syllable lines, and tetrameters, which are eight syllable lines. Donne uses an obvious three-part argument, or syllogism, where he uses the flea to structure it. Shakespeare uses a sonnet, which was a traditional way of writing about romantic love. Donne's poem is more intellectual in which he uses persuasive and rhetorical devices. The comparison's Shakespeare uses are passionate and interesting, but Donne's poem is more enjoyable to read since it uses wit and a clever structure to make it entertaining. The farfetched idea of using a flea to persuade a woman for sex is very unusual and makes the poem more enjoyable. Shakespeare's poem is more typical of a love poem, since the language he uses is more affectionate, but I have found Donne's more appealing to read because the wittiness and content of the poem is so unexpected. Zaki Rafiq-Khatana English Literature Coursework March 2004 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Love Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Love Poetry essays

  1. Compare "Shall I Compare Thee To a Summer's Day?" (poem 1) by William Shakespeare ...

    The poet uses the word sweet two times in the poem, which suggests that the boy thinks that the girl is very sweet. When the poet realises that he has fallen in love with the girl his face went "deadly pale" and his "legs refused to walk away".

  2. "The Flea", a witty poem of seduction and conceit, taken from John Donne's "Songs ...

    However, there is a clever finish to Donne's argument, and one that reveals a lot about his attitude to love and women. He shows impudence and confidence when he says that no harm has been done, equally there would there be no harm done if they were to make love.

  1. These poems portray love in different ways, discuss - Sonnet 130 by William Shakespeare ...

    doctor unfortunately she was bedridden because she injured her back while riding, so she used to write poems, later she met a penniless poet and eloped to Italy as her father insisted she couldn't marry him! In those days if you did something like this you were considered as a whore.

  2. The two poems which I shall analyse and explore are, "Shall I compare thee ...

    The subject matter of each of these poems is, therefore quite opposite; Shakespeare's sonnet, "Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?" is set in the summer time, in a beautiful garden when all of the radiance of summer is in the bloom.

  1. Compare and contrast the attempts at seduction in To His Coy Mistress and The ...

    As the woman has killed the flea and shown that the mixture of bloods did not matter to her, and that she has not lost anything in herself by killing the flea, the speaker uses this to his advantage and tells her that "Just so much honour, when thou yield'st

  2. GCSE English literature Pre 1914 Comparative poetry coursework assignment

    The poem has an 'A,B' rhyme scheme which at first isn't very apparent because of the use of enjambment you can only notice it when you look back over the poem and not when its read aloud. The use of vocabulary is typically quite complex but that's not unusual for a poem from that period in time.

  1. Examine the arguments for love in the seventeenth century lyrical poems ‘The Sun Rising’ ...

    In the second stanza Donne tries to take some authority over the sun by stating: 'Thy beams, so reverend and strong why shouldst thou think? I could eclipse and cloud them with a wink,' Donne is saying how easy it would be for him to close his eyes so that he can eclipse the sun.

  2. Pre-20th Century Sonnets - Comparative Analysis

    another example of the alliteration included in this sonnet to express that love can survive anything on its own in spite of the pressures and influences of time. The couplet finalising the sonnet ends with a confident conclusion that love is the most powerful spiritual element and suggests a contradictory

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work