• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Write an analysis of two different film interpretations of 'Macbeth' exploring dramatic qualities, social, cultural and historical contents.

Extracts from this document...


'Macbeth' Write an analysis of two different film interpretations of 'Macbeth' exploring dramatic qualities, social, cultural and historical contents. The famous Shakespearean work of 'Macbeth' deals with issues that are relevant to any society in any age. It explores the far reaching effects of one mans ambition, from the total transformation of Macbeths character. From a national hero to a nation-wide terror in his pursuit of power. Although 'Macbeth' is set in Medieval Scotland, the issues that are dealt with, the supernatural, Ambition and Tyranny are still just as relevant in our society now as they were in Shakespearean England. The relevance to today's society was displayed in the modern interpretation 'Macbeth on the estate'. Where contemporary ideas of the work was but across while still using the Shakespearean 'backbone'. We compared this version to a far more traditional interpretation directed by Roman Polanski, filmed in the 1970's The modern version of 'Macbeth' 'Macbeth on the estate' opens on a desolate wasteland. In the background we can make out the large shadows of desolate tower blocks. Through the mist we can see a dark shadow walking toward us. The shadow emerges out of the mist. It is Macduff. Immediately we notice the changes the director has made to this opening scene. The first difference from the original play is the use of Macduff opening the play instead of the three witches. To understand the director's decision we must remember that four hundred years ago witchcraft was a major part of life and each year hundreds of witches were being burnt at the stake for practising the 'dark arts'. Nowadays witchcraft does not have the same appeal to the audience who would watch this version and we a forced to conclude that Macduff was used to grab the audience's attention. A factor that was used to grab the audience's attention was the colour of Macduffs skin, black. ...read more.


The end of this film was, to sum it up disappointing. For a film as fast paced and action packed I expected more. There was also no army and no mention of Birnam wood. The film ends with Macduff killing Macbeth with a single shot from a pistol. The director's decision to end the film with a bullet and not a sword or knife is another social issue, as it is now possible to kill someone without 'getting your hands dirty'. The decision could have also been for suspense. As the last thing we expected was Macduff to walk in with a gun. I for one expected a fight between Macbeth's supporters and Fleances supporters. Having said that I thoroughly enjoyed this film although I did think the end was disappointing. I will now compare the contemporary version of Macbeth, 'Macbeth on the estate' with the more traditional version of the play. This version of 'Macbeth' was directed by Roman Polanski. This version was produced in the 1970's when special effects were 'lacking'. I will compare four parts and characters of this play, with 'Macbeth on the estate'. These parts will be: the beginning, the character Lady Macbeth, the character Duncan and the end of the play. In each case, In each case I will try to compare: the use of camera angles, costumes, surroundings, sound and lighting. This version of 'Macbeth' is very traditional and the contrast to 'Macbeth on the estate' is shown in the opening scene. As 'Macbeth on the estate' opened on a desolate urban wasteland with Macduff, instead of the witches speaking. In this version the three witches are on the wasteland, burying a hand, a noose and a dagger. The three witches are very stereotypical views of witches, old, wrinkled skin and dark clothes. That hobble out of the mist. This stereotypical view of the witches is common in Shakespeare's time. ...read more.


The camera is focused directly at Macbeth's face. And the dramatic qualities shown by the actor who plays Macbeth is excellent, as he stares into nothing we can imagine the shock he is in. When the English and Scottish soldiers enter the castle, they encounter little resistance. As the only defender, other than Macbeth is Seyton, Macbeth's loyal armourer. Although he is dispatched by a crossbow bolt to the forehead. But that special effect is rather crudely done, but we must remember that this film was made in the 1970's before High performance computers were around. Especially the ones used to create the special effect laden film, 'The Matrix'. The fight scene between Macbeth and a group of soldiers is rather unusual, and a little confusing, because there are approximately 5 to 10 soldiers against the lone Macbeth. But instead of going in all at the same time, they only go in one at once. This may be chivalry where you gave your opponent a fair chance. But I don't think that's what Polanski meant. We all know that Macbeth can only be killed by Macduff. This is not very well done by the director, as we think it is daft that the soldiers only go in one at once. Once Macbeth finally does get mortally wounded by Macduff, he hobbles around aimlessly around the courtyard with a sword stuck through his chest, Until about 3 minutes after he is stabbed he dies. This is too create suspense before death, but we all know it's just a bad case of bad acting. Although I think this ending was better than 'Macbeth on the estates' ending which was rather disappointing due to what a good film it was. I felt there were certain parts of Polanskis ending that was very god, such as the moment Macbeth sees Birnam wood approaching him, and there are other parts that are terrible such as the killing of Seyton by a crossbow bolt, where the special effects were lacking. Overall I think this was an average end to a below average film. Page 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Macbeth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Macbeth essays

  1. How does Shakespeare create dramatic tension in these scenes?

    This knocking has unmistakeable atmospheric qualities~ it is enigmatic and has definite ominous connotations. Knocking at the dead of night is sinister as it usually means bad news, which therefore creates more dramatic tension. Macbeth is immensely disturbed by the knocking.

  2. In what ways does Shakespeare make the opening scenes of Macbeth dramatic?

    His first words in his first entrance mimic the witches' in scene one, "So foul and fair a day..." Although Macbeth is presumably referring to the bad weather yet satisfying victories, this echo of 'foul and fair' suggests that Macbeth is sub-consciously crossing over to the evil ways and beliefs of the witches.

  1. Macbeth (Analysis of The Banquet Scene)

    When with his subjects, Macbeth's mentality is to impress his Lords in whichever way is possible to him- being seen as an equal, appearing to be strong and authoritative. In addressing his wife, Macbeth's mind seems to be in a state of naivety and weakness.

  2. Shakespeare's use of the Supernatural in Macbeth

    Her very last line is possibly intended to be spoken to Macbeth: 'Come, come, come, give me your hand. What's done cannot be undone. To bed, to bed, to bed.' That was Lady Macbeth's final scene before she commits suicide.

  1. Compare and contrast two different film versions, of Shakespeare's Macbeth.

    Polanski does have some text omitted and introduces some extra props and scenes during the film. He introduces a scene of wild animals, fighting bears and dogs, and also the bird of pray on the ghost of Banquo's shoulder to reinforce the theme of violence and brutality.

  2. The letter from Macbeth to Lady Macbeth

    Lastly Macbeth feels that Duncan's death would cause great sorrow and excite much pity and Macbeth says "and pity, like a naked new born babe striding the blast, or heaven's cherubim, horsed upon the sightless couriers of the air" by saying this Macbeth means he will feel good if he

  1. A comparison of the Dagger scene, Act 2, Scene 1, from 'Macbeth' as presented ...

    In showing this, the two versions differ completely. The film directed by Roman Polanski is a feature film, set in the Highlands of Scotland.

  2. Macbeth Film Comparison

    Again- this may have been done to excite the audience; and instead of letting the audience make up the fight in their minds, a graphical representation has been put on a plate for them. This was not done in 1971 due to the social taboos against showing excessively violent scenes

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work