• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Write up the ideas from your discussion about the attitudes to love shown by these writers - Promises Like Pie-crusts by Christina Rossetti

Extracts from this document...


The Poets say... Write up the ideas from your discussion about the attitudes to love shown by these writers * Promises Like Pie-crusts by Christina Rossetti I think that some of the main themes of the poem are about how risky love can be, and it is better to be friends that to be lovers. For this person love is a risk which they dare not take, there are so many underlying unchangeable factors which count towards the final product; whether that be a broken relationship or against all odds a strong and healthy relationship. For them it is much safer to be friends rather than lovers "Let us be the friends we were, Nothing more, nothing less: Many thrive on frugal fare Who would perish on excess" Many people can flourish in a friendship that wouldn't survive the harsh realities of a relationship. A friendship can be loving, nurturing and much easier to live with. People can stay friends for life, but a relationship often ends in hurt and the damage done to the relationship and both parties can be irreversible. ...read more.


I think the poet has had many broken promises, and is now very wary and aware of the reality of rashly made promises. For the poet to be friends means to be free, 'Keep we both out liberties', free to lust after, free to go, free to say, free to think, and after all that not feel guilty. Not to be held to false promises, for the poet even knows herself that it is easy to feel tempted to break impulsive promises "If I promised, I believe I should fret to break the chain." Freedom for Christina Rossetti is 'Never false and never true'. Freedom is just always there, neither working for or against you, unlike promises which can be true or false, for the poet it is too much of a risk to take and she sides with the constant: freedom. Freedom has no bonds like a needy love or a need of love with someone. Love can be a confining office room with a typewriter and a bin. ...read more.


I also think Kahlil Gibran is saying to love yourself as well, be an individual and use your self-love as a way of loving everyone or vice versa "Sing and dance together and be joyous, but let each one of you be alone, Even as the strings of a lute are alone though they quiver with the same music" Gibran says that love should not get too personal or it will fall apart, 'For the pillars of a temple stand apart', i.e. if people, like the pillars in a temple, become too close, the relationship, the temple, collapses. And like trees people cannot grow in the shadows of another tree and so people should give love and also stand back to give them growing space. Love, for him, should be a unity of hearts contained by a hand with a gentle grip and yet bound by love. These insights are only similar up to a point. Gibran feels that opening your heart without the strings attached is the way to love, but Rossetti feels that love hurts, and people who open themselves to love are easily wounded. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Love Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Love Poetry essays

  1. Love after Love and This Room

    sent by someone who was in love with the deception of their self, and not their real self, or the "stranger" as it's referred to in the poem. And it says "bookshelves" because maybe these letters were works of fiction because the lover didn't actually love who they were, but

  2. Some Poets' Attitudes To Love

    By this, I think she means that hard work has been put into the relationship to make it work and so it is not failing, but a small 'crop' still exists and is still growing. A harvest is used to describe the relationship (or the life)

  1. Explore the Presentation of Different Kinds of Love In a Room With a View ...

    Mr Emerson believes that through love, you can understand one another and once you have fallen in love with someone that "is the only person you will ever really understand". This teaching has made George be different from the rest of society because before judging he tries to love and understand people.

  2. Biography of Christina Rossetti

    In 1854, her brother, William, brought the family back to London to live with him. However, her father Gabriele died soon after. To earn a little extra money, Christina wrote dictionary articles and Italian translations. The most she made was ten pounds a year.

  1. The contrasting manner in which love and passion is expressed by Tita and Gertrudis ...

    Gertrudis is so overwhelmed with passion after the meal that she runs off naked and jumps on the horse of a federal troop and rides off with him. Dobrian describes this act of Gertrudis' as; "Esquivel inverts the prominent virility of the romance hero and transfers the hyperbolic nature of

  2. Compare how the poets explore their ideas about love in the following Italian sonnets: ...

    The octet does show another contrast by the fact that it shows darker images of love, although still talking about the greatness. An example is at the end when Elizabeth Barrett Browning begins to touch the subject of death. Browning shows a good use of repetition in her poem.

  1. Explain the principles that Christians believe should guide their personal relationships.

    However in the Christian church a divorce can be approved. I have stated this for the reason that many Catholics would respond in different ways to sins such as adultery. Many would like to be granted a divorce, yet will be told by the church that they must show forgiveness for their partner.

  2. Discuss the treatment of the theme of love in Elizabeth Barnett Browing's , 'L.E.L.', ...

    There is alliteration found in verse two, "rivulets rise and run". When you say those words, you can image a stream following along. This stream is displaying the misery of Landon and showing how it is endless just like the stream.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work