• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Yet sinned i not but in mistaking. To what extent do you agree that Claudio deserves Hero as a bride? The quotation in the title is spoken by Claudio in "Much Ado About Nothing" by William Shakespeare

Extracts from this document...


C/W Much Ado About Nothing 16/12/04 "Yet sinned i not but in mistaking. To what extent do you agree that Claudio deserves Hero as a bride? The quotation in the title is spoken by Claudio in "Much Ado About Nothing" by William Shakespeare. He is apologising to Leonato because he has made a mistake by accusing Hero of infidelity. in Elizabethan times, this would have bought dishonour on the family. Claudio is a young, brave soldier who is inexperienced in love. He has fallen in love with Hero who is to be his future wife. This issue is debatable because although Claudio is the romantic hero, he makes some very serious mistakes. Claudio is a convention romantic hero from the genre of romantic comedies. Most romantic comedies include love at first sight with villians or rivals trying to stop that happening. Also there is usaully a happy ending which normally ends in a wedding. "And the conclusion is, she shall be thine". The word conclusion suggests that Don Pedro anticipates the ending to be happy. Claudio is praised by the messenger even before he has entered the stage, his reputation amongst the other soldiers is good because he has done well in battle and he has battled bravely. ...read more.


He gets jealous very quickly and he is so inexperienced in love that he believes what anyone tells him about Hero. Now Claudio knows that Hero is dead, he attends a mourning ritual. He shows genuine remorse of her death. "Done to death by slanderous tongues". This quote is said by Claudio when he is at the service. This quote shows us that, now she has died, it was all because of people using their tongues and saying things that were not actually true. Claudio in act 5, scene 1 believes he is not in the wrong and thinks that he is right as he saw Hero being wooed with his own eyes. Claudio continually defends his honour even after he has found out that she has died. "My villainy". This rhetorical question shows that Claudio believes that he is not in the wrong and his judgements have been right. Claudio also gains the audience sympathy because he is set up by the friar. He is also deceived. "And let my counsei sway you in the case". The audience and most of the characters know Hero isn't dead this is called dramatic irony. However, the evidence is debateable. some critics argue that his actions are unjustified and that he acts cruelly andtherefore does not deserve Hero as a bride. ...read more.


This shows that Claudio strongly believes that he is right about Hero sleeping with other men so he is very nasty to him even though Hero is dead. When Hero is declared innocent, Claudio pleads for mercy from Leonato. Leonato chooses his punishment. He must conduct a mourning ritual at her tomb and marry someone who Leonato will chose. "Give her the right you should have given her cousin and so dies in my revenge". Leonato lets Claudio get away with killing Hero and sets up a marriage. This is a typical of a romantic comedy. Even when Leonato can choose who Claudio marries, he still tells Claudio how much money he will inherit if he does. This would suggest that money is more important to him than who he marries. "She alone is heir to both of us". Claudio will inherit Leonato and Antonio's fortune. Therefore, i conclude that Claudio does deserve Hero as a bride because even though he had made a very bad mistake by embarassing himself and Hero and the wedding scene, it was all Don Johns fault as Claudio believed him as he fort that he was a loyal friend. Also he has loved Hero since the first time he met her and this doesn't change so therefore I think that Claudio does deserve Hero as a bride. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Much Ado About Nothing section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Much Ado About Nothing essays

  1. Much Ado About Nothing - Is the title, "A Merry War" a suitable alternative ...

    These events show the harsher side of the "war of words" between Benedick and Beatrice. This does not support the alternative title of "a merry war", as there is no lighter side to their arguments. Don Pedro then decides that he will match make Beatrice and Benedick as he thinks

  2. To What Extent is Much Ado About Nothing seen as a Satire?

    Therefore Benedick himself is a victim of the playwright's satire. The moment Benedick leaves, we see a new form of satire in Claudio and Don Pedro. One that is not straightforward and funny, and one that is not realised by the characters themselves.

  1. Discuss the extent to which you feel that Shakespeare challenges Elizabethan stereotypes of women ...

    One of the first stereotypes of women at this time is 'Characters of Intellect and Witty Ladies', Beatrice and Margaret are the women I think of first when I hear that title. We see Beatrice's great wit and intelligence from the very start of the play, 'a good soldier to a lady; but what is he to a Lord?'

  2. Much Ado About Nothing' was written in the years 1598-9 and was know for ...

    They repeatedly put one another down because of each other's sex, and the advantages and disadvantages they each possess because of it. In Act 2, scene 1 Benedick mentions, BENEDICK: ...I will fetch you a tooth-picker now from the furthest inch of Asia...

  1. How does Shakespeare reveal Claudio's character to the audience through his use of language ...

    young Hero is, saying I lik'd her ere I went to wars.' This shows he loves Hero and he has realised he loved her before he went to war. This shows he truly does love Hero. But he also seems to be very misogynist as he believes that the woman's

  2. Explore the possible meanings of the title 'Much AdoAbout Nothing'.

    There are two more deceptions that link with the meaning of non existence. Friar Francis suggests that Leonato 'let [Hero] awhile be secretly kept in, and publish it that she is dead indeed'. Because this is once again untrue, when the characters participate and trick Claudio and other members of

  1. "Claudio does not deserve Hero." Do you agree?

    Hero is a potentially rich lady. The idea of 'Love at first sight' some people believe in, yet some don't, but this idea was very popular in Shakespeare's time. For example in the play 'Romeo and Juliet' this happens and they both fall in love with each other at first sight and their love is sincere.

  2. What is striking about Much Ado About Nothing is that it is written largely ...

    The danger of silence also affects the relationship between Hero and Claudio. Since they fail to talk with one another, they never resolve questions relating to the other's motives. Indeed, a crucial first mistake for Claudio is when he allows Don Pedro to speak to Hero for him, thereby creating confusion about Don Pedro's true motives.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work