The questionnaire was carried out by asking random people on the high street some questions.
There were many limitations for this survey as the questionnaire was carried out on a Tuesday at 11 30 am -12 30 pm, when most people with a job would be. For this a longer time is needed, and a range of days. Also I think one would need to ask more than 15 people to get a representative sample.
Land use survey:
This survey was done to help understand how the land was being used in Harefield this helped to show how much of the land was residential, retail, agricultural or open spaces.
This was done by walking around the area and colour coding a map to what category they should be in from a list given.
There were limitations as some greenery had something what looked like a greenhouse on it but it was at a distance, so one would have needed to get closer to the area in question and time was holding us down as we had to do other surveys as well.
Building age survey:
This was done to roughly date the time of the buildings in Harefield. This would help to distinguish if Harefield was a suburb or a village because we would no when it was build e.g. if it was in the World War times it simple could have been an area for people to be re-housed after bombing.
This again was done buy walking around the area in question, looking at the houses and roughly dating them from their style and colour coding a map from a key provided.
There were again limitations, time was a factor but also some houses were hard to date and other had been reconstructed in the original style of house making it hard to distinguish between ages.
Results:
Questionnaire:
CBD survey
Key for CDB survey
A - Post Office (main or sub)
B - Bank, building society
Cl - Clothing, tailor, wool baby
C2 - Dry cleaning, laundry
C3 - Shoes, cobbler
D - Newsagents, books
E - Hardware, home decoration, DIY
Fl - Grocer
F2 - Greengrocer
F3 - Fish
F4 - Butcher
F5 - Baker
F6 - Supermarket
F7 - Drink, wine
G - Garage
H - Hotel, restaurant, pub
J - Hairdresser
K - Chemist
L -Electrical goods
M - Professional e.g. solicitor
N - Department store
P - Public e.g library, church
R - Residential
S - Sporting goods
V-Vacant
Z - Others (specify)
Key for land use survey
-
Residential: Houses, flats etc RED
-
Retail: Shopping, eating places etc YELLOW
-
Commercial: Offices, business parks BLUE
-
Industrial: Factories, warehouses BLACK
-
Agricultural: Farm land BROWN
-
Open Spaces: Parks, playing fields GREEN
Key for building age survey
-
Pre-Georgian (before 1714) BLACK
-
Georgian (1714— 1837) BROWN
-
Victorian / Edwardian (1837 — 1914) YELLOW
-
Inter War (1918 — 1939) BLUE
-
Post War (1945— 1970) RED
-
Modern (1970 — present day) GREEN
Analysis
CBD survey
Harefield’s CBD have very limited shops. Most were food stores e.g. bakeries, Spars, butchers etc…, enough for the local’s needs. There were also some professional shops e.g. Solicitors, estate agents, digital productions but that was really it. Additionally the CBD has a park with open area and loads of pub, but on the other hand Harefield had very public transport, just a couple of busses that don’t make it anywhere near the city.
From what I have just said I feel I stated correctly in my hypothesis that Harefield only really had the basic needs for the locals + a little bit more but I feel that due to bad public transport Harefield’s CDB is best related with a village.
Building age survey
Looking at the building age survey diagram we can see that most of the housing in Harefield is inter war or just after except for a small area surrounding the church which is dated back to the Georgian times. This could mean Harefield was only really established till the war and has evolved into more since then. There is quite a lot of modern housing to the east and south of Harefield mixed in with older houses. It is possible that these modern areas are owned buy upper class families who want a nice environment for their children to grow up in and the worker is a commuter.
From what I can see it seems Harefield was established to house people during the war and best correspond to the characteristics of suburbs.
Land use survey
Looking at the Land use Survey diagram we can see there is a very large amount of greenery. There is also a lot of residential to the east and south but not many offices compared to the amount of greenery. There are 2 main farms in Harefield, Langley farm and Colney Farm which occupy a reasonable large amount of space. We can see that Harefield has nucleatedly grown around its church, but the residential areas have grown linearly in the centre. This is probably due to bad transport and the fact all the other space it taken up buy either farmland or Greenland.
From what I can see on this diagram it seems Harefield is mostly farm with a little residential area with hardly and offices that has nucleated from a church and this best describes a village
Questionnaire
Looking at this pie chart we can see 70% of the people we picked out in the CBD were from Harefield. From this I deduce not many people come to Harefield to use its facilities unless they live/work there.
Looking at this pie chart we can see that out of the people that live in Harefield most of them shop there for convenience hence Harefield must have enough shops to facilitate them.
Looking at this bar graph we can see that out of the 7 people that live in Harefield 5 of them work there and 1 person that doesn’t live in Harefield works there. From this I deduce Harefield must have sufficient shops to accommodate the residents (this one person lived just out of Harefield).
Looking at this bar graph we can see that the majority of people that live in Harefield (+ the one that lives nearby) have been to a fete therefore I conclude Harefield must have a reasonably large amount of residents to pull off this event
Inevitably I would ask this question to help assist me in my investigation and 100% of the people I asked said Harefield was a village (and one random person said ‘it was in the middle of nowhere’ which villages tend to be).
Conclusion
From looking at all the data from the CBD survey, Land use survey and Building age survey Harefield has the characteristics to be a suburb as it has inter-war housing, some professional shops and plenty or shops, but it has very bad public transport to London. From the questionnaire all I deduced is Harefield had all the facilities needed to support its residents as most of them shopped in Harefield. In conclusion I recon Harefield deserves to be a village in its own right.
Improvements
I do not think I can justify my conclusion as I do not feel my results were taken on a big enough scale. I had many limitations of which time was the biggest for all sections.
To improve this I could take a wide range of days and times to carry out the questionnaire. This is because the questionnaire did no account for the people who were working at the time and children who were at school. Also I believe it would be a lot more useful to ask more than 10 people, but a lot more say 200 for example.