• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Earthquakes in MEDC's and LEDC's

Extracts from this document...


A well-known principle states that the impact of earthquakes in LEDC's or Less Economically Developed Countries is generally more severe when compared with MEDC's or More Economically Developed Countries. This shall be illustrated by comparing the Kobe Earthquake in Japan of 1995 with the Kashmir Earthquake of 2005. The Kobe Earthquake occurred on Tuesday, January 17, 1995, at 05:46 JST in the southern part of Hyogo Prefecture, Japan. It measured 7.2 on the Richter scale and lasted for 20 seconds. The duration of the tremors was around 20 seconds long. The focus of the earthquake was located 16km below the epicentre, on the northern edge of the Awaji Island, approximately 20km from Kobe. The proximity to the city was a major factor of its widespread devastation. The ground moved 18cm horizontally and 12 cm vertically. The Kashmir Earthquake was caused by the Eurasian and Indian tectonic plate boundaries colliding. Its epicentre was located in Azad Kashmir near the city of Muzaffarabad. It occurred at 08:52:37 Pakistan Standard Time (03:52:37 UTC) on 8 October 2005. According to the authorities, 79000 people died. A major factor in the severity of the earthquake was the poor construction - a salient feature of LEDC's. ...read more.


Fires were set off due to destroyed gas pipes and electricity mains causing a further 7500 houses to burn. The roads were gridlocked causing delays in emergency services. 716 aftershocks were recorded and these lasted for several days. Industries such as Mitsubishi and Panasonic were forced to close. The death toll, however, was only 5500, injuries were 40,000 and 180,000 houses were destroyed. The newly opened Kansai Airport, due to its brilliant structural foundations, withstood the earthquake, as well as the Akashi Bridge. However, when we consider the fact that the population density of both areas was similar yet the number of dead, homeless and injured was far more in the Kashmir earthquake than that of the Kobe earthquake. By July, in about 5 months, most of the infrastructure such as water, electricity, gas and telephone services were up and running. Most buildings in commercial areas were repaired and the places affected by fires had been cleared. Rail services were back in service by August. A year later, 80% of the port was functional i.e. all but the Expressway. There was an increase in the technology used to determine information on earthquakes and movements in the region, and steps were implemented to make sure that devastation to that scale would not occur again. ...read more.


This would place too much of a burden on the Pakistani government. Although these long-term causes should be rectified, other short-term causes should be identified. These include that, since Saturday was a normal school day, many school children were studying and as a result were buried under collapsed schools. It was also during the month of Ramadan, when people were taking a nap after their pre-dawn meal, hence they may not have had enough time to escape. Entire villages were simply wiped out like this. In conclusion, although it is expected that LEDC's like Kashmir would be hit worse than MEDC's such as Japan due to their economies, it is nevertheless possible to prevent such grave impacts that took place in Kashmir happening again. The people should be educated with emergency procedures, the government should invest in relevant technology which would indicate and warn them ahead of time when seismic activity was occurring. In addition, the government should outline new guidelines for buildings in which they are earthquake resistant just as Japan did. These would strain the economy in the short-term, although in the long term this would relieve the economy should an earthquake such as this one would take place again. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Physical Geography section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

4 star(s)

Overall a good review of the impacts resulting from two similar earthquakes. Some weaknesses in the structuring of the essay but otherwise very good.
4 stars

Marked by teacher Eleanor Wilson 08/01/2013

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

4 star(s)

Response to the question

The student shows a clear understanding of the set question with their strong introduction and conclusion. Both clearly introduce and conclude their idea in a coherent and logical manner. The student has considered many different aspects of that would contribute ...

Read full review

Response to the question

The student shows a clear understanding of the set question with their strong introduction and conclusion. Both clearly introduce and conclude their idea in a coherent and logical manner. The student has considered many different aspects of that would contribute to the difference between natural disasters in LEDCs and MEDCs and supports their statements with relevant material. However, I would suggest that they could highlight the difference in technology more. Such that even the earthquake in Kashmir in 2005 (around 10 years after Kobe), hit Kashmir worse than Kobe in spite of the advancement of technology in that 10 year gap. Such attention to detail would really show the examiner the level of understanding of the student and almost ensure that full marks are gained.

Level of analysis

The student offers the typical level of analysis here. I would not say that this has lowered the student's mark at all as this student has included most things that would ensure that they scored the highest possible marks. However, it does not make the student's work stand out from the crowd. Having said this, their response was clear and well developed and a strong and valid conclusion was reached with strong supporting figures.

Quality of writing

I only found one punctuation mistake which was a capital letter on the word 'ignorance' when it wasn't the beginning of the sentence. I find this shocking in a piece of work that has been completed to such a high level. Such shows the lack of proof reading and just proof reading for the sense rather than looking deeper and checking spelling, grammar and punctuation. The technical terms were used accurately, however a further definition of MEDC and LEDC is needed to show the examiner that the student understands the classification for the two. Also, I would say that it is correctly written as MEDCs rather than MEDC's and LEDCs rather than LEDC's. I do not think that the short paragraphs work well either. One sentence cannot count as one paragraph and would suggest the student re-look at the how to formulate paragraphs. Other than this, the piece was well structured and logically written.

Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by crystalclearmagic 27/03/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Physical Geography essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Debden Brook Rivers Cousework Analysis and Conclusion

    4 star(s)

    The average water depth of the river increased from 0.08m at site 1 (Debden Brook) to 0.21m at site 2 (Debden Brook) and 0.55m at site 3 (The River Roding). This increase is because of greater downwards (vertical) erosion due to increased water velocity, discharge and load resulting in more abrasion due to traction and saltation.

  2. 2011 Japanese Earthquake and Tsunami - causes and effects

    It is thought that the overall cost of the disaster to be somewhere in the realms of $300 billion making it the most expensive natural disaster ever recorded. Due to the building collapses, over 500,000 people were left homeless and had to live in temporary evacuation shelters.

  1. Debden Brook Rivers Coursework Data Collection Table

    The first step in collecting the measurement for the depth was to decide where the depth was to be measured. For this it was decided that at each site we would measure the depth in 3 separate parts of the portion of the river we were measuring on.

  2. D1 Recommendations on how a UK tourist destinations can increase its appeal to ...

    If a really big cinema, theatre or shopping centre was to be built it would attract many visitors. Because the lake district is viewed as a boring place by many young people it should be advertised greatly on television and billboards.

  1. Kobe and Haiti earthquake had many differences between the primary effects because in Haiti, ...

    of the city, it resulted in massive damage to property and loss of life. More than 102,000 buildings were destroyed in Kobe, leaving over a fifth of the city population, some 300,000 people homeless. The local government's estimate of the cost to restore the basic infrastructure of the city was

  2. GCSE Geography Coursework: Strand 4 - Interpertation of Data

    This anomaly is due to the abstraction of water from the Calder intake to the Barnacre and Grizedale Lea reservoirs. Hence, this leaves the volume of the water sparse. Between sites 3 to 5, the channel depth is increases from 0.14 to 0.32m; a total of 0.18m.

  1. Letter to the brazilian government regarding the amazonian rainforest

    If the trees and plants were to be destroyed the CO2 would also cause a great risk; being released into the atmosphere, as a greenhouse gas, will contribute massively to global warming. Our descendants will suffer from these effects; be witnessing flooding and climate changes worldwide, if you were to act irresponsibly and destroy Amazonia.

  2. Life and Climate in the Equatorial Region

    The native people would also hunt, fish and gather fruit and nuts. Changes in the Environment: Recently, there has been recent change in this area. Large areas of rainforest have been cleared to make room for cattle ranching, mining, settlements, reservoirs, roads and airstrips.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work